News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by timonovici on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:22AM (#8873960)
What if other people already know about the breach? Would you prefer the joy of ignorance, or would you rather protect yourself by some means?
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by cmdkeen on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:27AM (#8873982)
What about the people hit by the breach in the following 48 hours after the vulnerability is announced? Especially when attackers know they have a short window of opportunity before patch Tuesday hits.

Microsoft do issue out of band updates but they are very rare and for very serious issues.

It isn't like Microsoft was stalling for time, they didn't ask for months, they asked for days to fir into their scheduled releases. It's also worth pointing out the enterprises time things on the patch Tuesday cycle. An earlier release causes all sorts of implementation problems, especially if only a day or two in advance. In all likelihood you wouldn't see many machines actually updated in that period, but cause significant extra grief.

Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by smackfu on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:26AM (#8873977)
Does it really matter if it's 90 or 92 day disclosure?
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:37AM (#8874044)
> Does it really matter if it's 90 or 92 day disclosure?

Yes. Google designed Project Zero to "pressure firms into dealing with security problems more quickly." A firm policy with unambiguous enforcement has its advantages. Muddying the 90-day deadline with questions about when (and for whom) to make exceptions weakens it. For example, in the future, I expect Microsoft will not wait the extra two days in the event of a security disclosure from Google.

One may disagree with the 90-day policy to begin with. I, for one, think it should have had an exception process built in. But while these are Google policies, not laws, I respect them for adhering to published protocol. Even when it was difficult.

Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by jenscow on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:42AM (#8874069)
I feel certain if this vulnerability had a higher impact (like remote execution) then it would have been over-ridden - or at least responded to quicker.
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by cskau on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:32AM (#8874017)
Or you could ask: do two more days of the bug being secretly exploited in the wild matter?
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by Gigablah on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:37AM (#8874040)
As opposed to 2 days of the bug being openly exploited?
Re:Microsoft hits out at Google team over bug report by tarpherder on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:27AM (#8873983)
Almost everyone was already enjoying 90 days of ignorance. And almost everyone could have enjoyed indefinite ignorance with the same relative safety if Google had waited for patch Tuesday.