News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by david927 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:55AM (#8857254)
A doctor told a programmer friend once, "I have to fix problems that God gave us. You have to fix problems you give yourselves."
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by randlet on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:03PM (#8857313)
To be fair, doctors are often fixing problems we've created ourselves too.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jaredsohn on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:43PM (#8858041)
But that's different than problems created by the doctor.

Edit: granted, this still can happens when self-medicating. The general case of doctors fixing the mistakes of doctors is different than what the parent suggests.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jfb on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:28PM (#8858341)
Not always.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by ploxiln on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:14PM (#8858647)
My mother, a family practitioner, sometimes gets a patient which is on 15 or so different medications, all prescribed by different specialists at different times. She whittles it down to 3 or 4, and they get a lot better.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by adamnemecek on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:02PM (#8857312)
That doctor sounds a bit like an arrogant douche.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by thirsteh on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:03PM (#8857322)
"It's not exactly brain surgery, is it?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THNPmhBl-8I
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by _lce0 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:16PM (#8858265)
I wonder if the teams at NASA, working on rocket science says "it's not rocket science, you know"
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by singlow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:45PM (#8858449)
I have a relative who works for Raytheon as a physicist on rocket systems. Whenever he tells be about a dumb mistake he had to fix, he always uses that expression.. followed by, "Oh wait, I guess it is."
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by binarytrees on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:03PM (#8857321)
a tip of that hat
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by lucozade on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:23PM (#8857892)
With my 2015 budget and 2015 requirements, I'm going to need a few miracles.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by andrewchambers on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:33PM (#8859152)
That doctor is wrong. All human problems are caused by the constraints of our physical world.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:47PM (#8859553)
Especially gross oversimplifications of reality and absolute statements.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:30PM (#8859752)
That's why God endows them with greater analytical prowess.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by navan on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:34PM (#8857982)
In a way both are fixing bugs created by someone else.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by a_dutch_guy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:08PM (#8857354)
God on HN? Come on, the world isn't flat anymore.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jacquesm on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:18PM (#8857418)
You don't have to take that literally in order to understand it, but just in case you really missed the point: the doctor is essentially saying that he is dealing with problems that have no direct cause or architect that he can consult whereas the IT people have essentially only themselves to blame and have made the mess they're in (usually) rather than that it has been handed down to them through the mists of time or from above.

In a general sense that is true but in a more specific sense it is definitely possible to be handed a project without docs and horrible problems and it might as well be an organic problem. Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by dasil003 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:51PM (#8858501)
> Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity.

And also mercifully in continuous real-world testing over time with no Big Rewrite to be seen. While an individual organism might have unsolvable problems, nature doesn't have the same tolerance for utterly intractable systems that we sometimes see in the software community.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by iamcreasy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:50PM (#8858083)
> Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity.

Well said.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by marrs on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:46PM (#8859225)
Intolerance on HN? Apparently so.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:09PM (#8857800)
Oh, look, someone who has proven that God doesn't exist. Please, post the proof for all of us to see.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jodrellblank on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:21PM (#8858312)
You'll just have to take it on Faith.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:55PM (#8858534)
That isn't how I, or any atheists I know, define atheism.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:02PM (#8858578)
Just to clarify, the original response was to the original posters claim that God does not exist. My request for him to present his proof to me was not meant as an open attack on atheism or even a critique of it, I was simply speaking to and about one persons beliefs. In any event, I begin to suspect I should have said nothing with this being such an emotional issue for people.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:40AM (#8861771)
I don't know why people would downvote this.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jodrellblank on Friday January 09, 2015 @03:30PM (#8864317)
Possibly because you missed the sarcasm/joke nature of my comment and gave a serious reply. I wasn't defining atheism as faith in no-God.

I was digging at the idea that someone would accept a claim on Faith, then demand evidence before giving up the idea, and how that is inconsistent. If someone can faith into an idea without evidence it should be equally easy to faith out of it with no evidence.

That it's not easy, is interesting.

Nothing -> belief in God, costs little and gains much.

Belief in God -> no belief, costs much and gains little.

Where by costs and gains, I include social acceptance, eternal life, favourable relations with a powerful being, forgiveness of sins, approved life habits, connections to history and social groups, etc.

It's not a Boolean. Or at least, from inside a mind it doesn't feel like a Boolean.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:21PM (#8864873)
I feel like its important to point out that having faith in a creator is not exclusive to having a belief in things like eternal life, favourable relations with a powerful being, etc. etc. People seem to easily conflate faith in a creator with practicing a mainstream religion.

edit: I would also like to add, although I already said it, that I believe both of these opinions regarding the creator are acts of faith, to absolutely say there is not one and to absolutely say there is, and if someone where to have made a statement as if a creators existence was a sure thing I would have called them out just the same.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:30PM (#8858350)
I'd agree, it takes faith to know that there was no creator of the world, the same faith it takes to know there was. Just to clarify, I'm not arguing there's proof that 'God' does exist, I'm arguing there's no proof that 'God' doesn't exist. The original comparison falls short, the world can be proven to be round, not flat.

edit: a thanks in advance to all you enlightened fervent atheists for the down votes.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:39AM (#8861770)
Just to clarify, atheism isn't a faith claim, it's a skepticism of faith claims.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:48PM (#8865206)
Just to clarify, I never said atheism required faith. Please, read the comment you responded to.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:39PM (#8858411)
Atheism isn't having faith there is no creator, it's having the intellectual curiosity to doubt the existence of a creator.

Edited to be more honest.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:44PM (#8858446)
It only takes courage for those who live in areas that are indoctrinated with dense religious ideology's who will suffer consequences for their actions. For most in the western world, it is not such a hard thing to identify oneself with.

edit: original response claimed it took courage to doubt the existence of a creator. It has since edited out to claim it simply takes intellectual curiosity. I would argue that the same intellectual curiosity could have the end result of someone having a belief in a singular creator of reality.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:39PM (#8858839)
> I would argue that the same intellectual curiosity could have the end result of someone having a belief in a singular creator of reality.

Possible, but not likely, given how many intellectually curious people have independently reinvented atheism but no religion has been independently reinvented.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by justathrow2k on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:41PM (#8858853)
Religion and belief in a singular creator are not the same thing. Furthermore, I don't really believe you have any credible way of producing a valid number of 'intellectually curious' individuals who have made the choice to believe in a singular creator versus not.

edit: misunderstanding of mutually exclusive and added some more words.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by marrs on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:27PM (#8859451)
It's far more likely to be the other way round. Atheism was only really formed about 300 years ago, and by that time the world had been explored and the printing press had been invented. In contrast, all of the ancient religions, formed in completely disconnected continents, had the notion of a creator at their centre.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:37AM (#8861758)
> Atheism was only really formed about 300 years ago

This denies the existence of Ancient Greek atheists, and people who were skeptical of religion in general before the modern era.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by bbcbasic on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:19PM (#8859399)
I think you mean agnostic not atheism then.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:49AM (#8861808)
Agnosticism is a belief that we can't possibly know whether there's a supernatural. I don't hold that view. My view is a skepticism of the supernatural, which is atheism.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by cbd1984 on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:38AM (#8861764)
No. I'm atheist, and that is my worldview. Saying I'm wrong about my own philosophy is nonsensical.

I'm also not alone: My definition of the word seems to be the most common one among the current atheist movement.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:51PM (#8858935)
My doctor for one, would benefit most from fixing his own basic problems than from dwelling on God or what problems God has given us, but like most doctors he pretends to solve big problems while saying pretentious things.

I'm just saying you'd expect these doctor types to have the greater powers of analysis, but in my experience they just pretend harder.

[Edit to remove that off putting stuff]