News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by eli on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:24AM (#8857062)
Title II would be exciting and a big change. I think it's a good thing, but I can't help but be a little worried about the unforeseen consequences.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rayiner on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:19PM (#8857430)
Most people here, myself included, are too young to remember what the world looked like when other industries were regulated under rules similar to Title II. It's a 1970's style, "ask permission before you do anything" regulatory framework. Such regulation was applied to airlines, trucking, railroads, etc.

One of the most exciting things happening right now is the disruption of retail with vendors like Amazon shipping directly to consumers. None of that would have been possible if it weren't for air cargo deregulation, which allowed UPS and FedEx to come into existence: http://mercatus.org/publication/unleashing-innovation-deregu....

I understand some people want net neutrality, but this is a bad way to go about it.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by chipotle_coyote on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:35PM (#8857985)
I'm not too young to remember that. Air transport regulation isn't a particularly good comparison. The current wireless cell phone industry is a much better comparison, because it's already regulated under Title II. If that really meant "ask permission before you do anything," cell phone providers would be having to go before the FCC -- or state commissions -- to introduce new service plans or even change existing ones. They do not.

I think it's too easy to leap on the "regulation bad, deregulation good" bandwagon; in practice, it's rarely that clearcut. Look at phone company deregulation in the 90s and the rise of CLECs, Competitive Local Exchange Carriers -- CLECs would never have existed without deregulation, right? That's true, yet it turns out that what created the first C was actually new regulation: incumbent LECs were required to share their networks with competitors. If that sort of "government interference in the market" had happened in the early 2000s with data communications, the end result might well have been having half a dozen different ISPs to choose from no matter where you lived, rather than a choice between your single cable company and your single phone company. (Of course, like what actually happened to CLECs, there's also a good chance that the lack of regulation meant nothing would prevent a series of ever more massive corporate mergers leaving us with the same lack of choice we had before deregulation, but never mind.)

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by otoburb on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:21PM (#8858304)
>The current wireless cell phone industry is a much better comparison, because it's already regulated under Title II.

Quoting from the posted article and jiving with my memory: "[...] the FCC explicitly exempted wireless data networks from Title II in 2007"[1].

More specifically, I think only mobile voice services are regulated under Title II[2]. Mobile data (aka mobile broadband) is exempt, provided the FCC follows their own declaration made in 2007.

[1] https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-07-30A1.pd...

[2] http://techliberation.com/2014/11/19/the-myth-that-title-ii-...

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by ethbro on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:06PM (#8857777)
What is a good way to go about it?

Because from my perspective, there's more than enough accumulated capital / lobbying / entrenched market positions to make disruption of the market a pipe dream.

In that case, I consider slapping "too burdensome" regulations and then later parring them down the lesser of two evils.

Is or isn't internet access important enough to be treated as a utility? That's what Title II asks in my opinion.

If so, then sort out the implementation details later.

(Disclaimer: In a semi-related note, I support the ACA for the same reasons. Is universal health insurance important enough to codify in law? If so, work on the details after you get that point down on paper.)

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by dragonwriter on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:27PM (#8857495)
> It's a 1970's style, "ask permission before you do anything" regulatory framework.

No one yet who has made this claim has established that Title II classification would mandate the FCC to use that kind of regulatory framework, though I don't think there is any dispute that Title II classification could support such a framework.

Of course, rather than arguing about abstractions, we can argue once actual regulations are proposed, at which point -- and only at which point -- will we actually discussing anything other than what someone speculates might be the proposed regulatory framework.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rhino369 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:04PM (#8857761)
One of the massive issues with title II is that it can retroactively punish for "unreasonable charges or practices."
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by tzs on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:06PM (#8859024)
> Most people here, myself included, are too young to remember what the world looked like when other industries were regulated under rules similar to Title II. It's a 1970's style, "ask permission before you do anything" regulatory framework

Wheeler is not going in that direction. There's much more detail in the Ars article: http://arstechnica.com/business/2015/01/title-ii-for-interne...

An excerpt:

------------------

Wheeler went in to a little more depth about the upcoming proposed rules, which he says will be circulated within the Commission on February 5 and voted on on February 26. The chairman—who formerly led cable and wireless industry trade groups—said that in the '90s he worked on the industry side as the FCC crafted section 332 of the Communications Act dealing with mobile services and he implied that the section informed the way the FCC has structured the proposed rules.

“It just so happens that 20 years ago I was the guy that negotiated on behalf of the wireless industry to establish Section 332," Wheeler said.

“Section 332 says that wireless should be regulated under Title II as a common carrier, except that the FCC is instructed to forbear from onerous provisions and inappropriate provisions of Title II, except for section 201 and 202, which is just and reasonable, and Section 208, which is consumer protection," he added.

Sections 201, 202, and 208 include requirements for reasonable rates and practices, a prohibition against unjust or unreasonable discrimination in rates and practices, and the establishment of a complaint process. Wireless voice—but not data—is regulated under Title II. The FCC could reclassify both fixed and wireless broadband as Title II if it so chooses.

”So I say to myself, 'ok there is a way to do Title II right, and sure there are many ways to do Title II that would thwart investment, but there are other ways to do Title II,'” Wheeler told Shapiro on stage. “We ought to take a look at how that fits together with consumer protection.”

Wheeler urged listeners to look at the wireless industry under Title II to see how the FCC might enforce it. “There is no need to file tariffs, there is no need to file all these informational activities,” Wheeler said. “The problem we had at that time [in the 90’s] was the wireless industry was having to go before state commissions to change rates.” Having the FCC approve all rate changes, Wheeler seemed to imply, is not what he wants. Obama has also said the FCC should not impose rate regulation.

”We’re gonna have rules that say—we're going to propose rules that say, 'no blocking, no throttling, no paid prioritization,' and that there is a yardstick against which behavior should be measured, and that yardstick was 'just and reasonable,'" he said.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rayiner on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:37PM (#8859780)
The issue is, of course, that Section 332 does not apply to wireline providers. And the FCC doesn't have the authority to rewrite the Communications Act to impose a quasi-Title II that isn't actually in the statute.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by bsder on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:57PM (#8857730)
The problem is that we don't have competition because you have to dig up the ground. And, everything else which requires that you dig up the ground is regulated (electricity, water, sewage, etc.)

The ISPs did this to themselves with crappy service which they then tried to enforce by regulation (lobbying, sweetheart laws to stifle local deployments, etc.) The ISPs created the openings, and now they're going to have to live with the problems.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by icebraining on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:01PM (#8857745)
Other countries have to dig up the ground too, and they have competition. And no, not every of those countries has public last-mile infrastructure, the ISPs actually build it themselves.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by Shivetya on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:48PM (#8857654)
One thing is for sure, if the define broadband as 25/3; mentioned elsewhere; and do similar for "unrestricted access" or whatever terms they use you can guarantee that is what you will get and likely the most you ever will.

Welcome to mediocrity by regulation. So the new baseline will be less than what I have now and what I have now can cost more since it exceeds the requirements... they can even brand it "ultra" or "extreme".

As soon as ISPs go under such regulation they all arrive at the lowest common denominator.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by josephlord on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:04PM (#8857760)
Why wouldn't companies compete at least as much as now? They might charge more for higher tiers but I don't see any, justification behind your assertions.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by iends on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:29AM (#8857104)
This is what scares me the most because I fear Title II may be used to open the Internet to greater regulation. Hopefully this fear is unfound.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by geoelectric on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:40AM (#8857164)
Either the ISP aspect of the Internet is open to regulation or it's not. That's true right now.

If it isn't, any net neutrality effort is going to get knocked down sooner or later. You have little to worry about.

If it is, this is the right kind of regulation to have, because it prevents a potential (and arguably current) oligarchy from effectively regulating the service aspect of the Internet.

I'm all for free market economics as the rational default when starting from an even playing field. However, the current market leaders got where they are by being treated as utilities from the start, in terms of subsidy and privilege for placement of infrastructure.

It doesn't make sense to give them protectionist advantages, then go hands off from there. There's a great argument for not doing the former in the first place (albeit one that probably would have prevented the Internet at current scale), but once you've committed you have to follow through.

I'll worry about the slippery slope of further regulation when it starts happening. Right now, I'm considerably more worried about ICE and ICANN jurisdiction issues and copyright/trade treaties, as far as threats to the Internet by the American government and corporate structure go.

What's more interesting about this to me is the "only 25Mbps+ is broadband" news bit from yesterday. Does that create a big loophole for exemption from Title II for the grand majority of US internet service that doesn't meet that bar?

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by ep103 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:33AM (#8857126)
Can't be worse than what we have, and our current course
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by twoodfin on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:02PM (#8857309)
It can't? I don't know about you, but my Comcast performance, both promised and real, has been growing steadily for over a decade, at a much higher rate than the price has increased.

That's not a natural law, that's investment in technology and infrastructure. As that investment looks to be worth less, it'll slow down or cease. Look at Verizon's dramatic reduction in FiOS deployment, for example.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by zipwitch on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:26PM (#8857491)
I had better (in terms of both cost and quality) internet living in rural southeast Asia five years ago than I do now, living in a million+ metropolitan area in the US. From my perspective, it realistically can't get worse.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rnovak on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:48PM (#8857656)
You're one person, there are 300,000,000 others that matter as well, and it's an established fact that Comcast, as a whole, is a horrible company. Their customer service is atrocious, and something I myself have had to deal with.

John Oliver had it right, it is literally "preventing Cable Co. Fuckery"

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by geoelectric on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:15PM (#8858653)
That's only half the equation, though. The other half is whether Comcast allows you full use of the line in terms of what services can push to you.

As far as whether your bandwidth will continue to go up and prices go down (comparatively), it almost certainly will if more competitors are allowed to deliver to your house.

What's trickier there is new deployment, but that's what the utility model is all about: protect new deployment of infrastructure for long enough to make rollout worth it, in exchange for a guarantee that it will be usable by the public at large without preference.

That gives you, in essence, the telephone model: copper lines protected until (probably subsidized) costs to the provider are recouped, they're a commodity and no further enhancement will occur, then alternate providers let in on them for competition. Tech changes, protect that tech rollout, repeat.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by raverbashing on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:16PM (#8857399)
Sure it's worth less, that's why Google is deploying Google fiber...

It's worth "less" (and essentially from their market perception today) which doesn't mean it's worth little or worthless, but of course in a monopoly/oligopoly your profits are bigger and you control the market.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by twoodfin on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:05PM (#8857773)
Sure it's worth less, that's why Google is deploying Google fiber...

If Google really believed in the potential profitability of fiber, they could spend $20 or $30 billion over the next few years to get it in every major metro area. But they won't, because it wouldn't be.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by wtallis on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:42PM (#8859208)
If you're considering a multi-year nationwide build-out, what's the harm in another year or two delay to allow the regulatory situation to change to make the expansion drastically easier? If it were the actual digging of trenches that were expensive, Google Fiber would have never happened at any scale in the first place. Google's words and actions make it clear that the deciding factor is the costs of the permits and other local regulatory overhead, not the physical installation.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by SEJeff on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:39PM (#8858010)
Google fiber is plain an simple a serious enough competitor to the major telcos that they'll continue to invest in fast internet tech such as infra upgrades and fiber optics.

Google stands to make money from more people using the internet and being able to send more content to users. If they can spend enough money to force the incumbents to improve performance, they still win.

Pretty sure the point of google fiber was to break even, but not really to ever be profitable. It is more of an insurance policy. They could light up all of the dark fiber they own and be a real problem with the major ISPs if they so chose.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by tbyehl on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:47PM (#8858064)
The existence and decline of FiOS is the perfect example of unintended regulatory consequences. FiOS never would have happened if fibre hadn't been excluded from unbundled access requirements. Line-sharing was eliminated around the same time, bringing on the decline of alternative DSL providers. So Verizon spends a few years doing FiOS build outs instead of improving their copper networks, the DSL competition dies off, and now they've stopped investing in their whole wireline business in favor of wireless.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-kushnick/the-great-veriz...

I don't know what Title II means for ISPs. I see nothing wrong with companies paying for a "fast lane", if we define the fast lane as paying for a level of service to my devices in excess of what I'm buying (ie: If I'm paying for 6Mbps of service, Netflix can buy me an extra 10Mbps to guarantee a better streaming experience). I do have a problem with ISPs purposefully allowing their peering connections to become overloaded in order to extract payment from content companies. I'm not paying Comcast for 100Mbps of bandwidth to their speedtest servers; I'm paying for 100Mbps of bandwidth to the content companies' networks!

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by geoelectric on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:21PM (#8858696)
I don't think a fast lane means what you're saying. It means packet prioritization, so that a saturated network delivers the "fast" packets sooner and/or more reliably. Companies that push data to consumers (Netflix, etc.) would pay for this prioritization. Think QoS rules, but with companies that have paid for preferential treatment at the top.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by tbyehl on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:51PM (#8859258)
Fast lane is a made up political gobbledygook. I think it's fine for an ISP to sell whatever kind of preferential treatment they like to any company which freely chooses to purchase it, with the caveat that they service I'm paying for isn't being degraded.

If Microsoft wants to pay so that streaming stuff to my Xbox doesn't affect my data cap, that's goovy.

If Netflix wants to pay to guarantee they can stream 10Mbps to my devices while my other devices are using the whole 100Mbps that I'm paying for, that's cool too.

If Hulu wants to pay for QoS that prioritizes their traffic to me above my other traffic, that's not cool. Bandwidth management within my home is my domain and I've got my own QoS rules, thank you very much.

When Comcast lets their peering links get saturated in order to force Netflix to pay them, that's absolutely bad. I'm paying for access to the Internet and purposefully withholding the necessary peering to the content I'm interested in means that I'm being ripped off.

TLDR; I believe that ISPs should peer on a settlement-free basis with anyone who can deliver a commercially reasonable level of traffic to any of their peering points, without regard to ratios. And I believe they should be able to sell any kind of paid prioritization they like that does not degrade my other traffic.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by geoelectric on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:01PM (#8859309)
I'm not as worried about paying for cap subsidies, which is basically what your 1 and 2 is about.

Keep in mind that still damages the free market for new services, though, because now they don't just have a technological barrier to entry, they have a purely financial/administrative one. I prefer the T-Mobile (music) model where they allow a whole class of services priority, but not on a corp-by-corp basis.

Your Hulu/#3 example is what I'm pretty sure Wheeler's alternative (call it fast lane or whatever) amounted to, before it was shouted down. We both agree that's a pretty horrible thing.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by tbyehl on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:46PM (#8860460)
| Keep in mind that still damages the free market for new services

If peering extortion is fixed, how are they any worse off?

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by geoelectric on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:58PM (#8863707)
Because if Rdio and Spotify don't count against my data cap because of a paid agreement, a new entrant into music is probably not going to get much of my attention.

They'd have to be -so- much better than the existing leaders that I'm willing to pay for a higher cap or sacrifice part of my current cap to use them.

That effectively means that to be taken seriously, a new entrant has to pay the ISPs for exemption from the cap. Further, if the ISPs can choose not to make agreements with companies, they become the gatekeepers of who will be successful. Piss them off, and you lose your agreement.

This is anticompetitive, for sure, but the FTC has no jurisdiction over common carriers. AT&T is currently flogging this argument based on cc status on phone to escape reprisal from the FTC about lying about "unlimited" plan vs. their throttling policy that effectively caps such a plan to 5 GB. The say that because they're a phone CC, the FTC has to be hands-off period on all their business concerns.

I suspect that'll be found to be BS. However, if broadband is Title II, but we add an exemption to allow anti-competitive agreements around caps, there's literally zero remedy. It's specifically not under jurisdiction of the FTC unless Congress changes that particular law.

So, not a huge worry of mine as long as it's a "exempt all music, anyone can apply," but big worry if it's "exempt Spotify only." There are plenty of streaming markets that aren't sufficiently mature to be commodities yet (PPV on-demand movies like VUDU, iTunes, CinemaNow, Flixter; remote gaming like OnLive, Sony; etc.) and even the ones that are shouldn't be immune from shakeups.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by mwsherman on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:28PM (#8857931)
They are foreseeable. This sort of regulation ensures that only big players (incumbents) will play, because it tilts advantage to those with better lobbyists. http://clipperhouse.com/2010/02/22/net-neutrality-and-preser...
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by worklogin on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:51PM (#8858091)
I'm concerned about QoS. Will it be legal to throttle HTTP for voice traffic?
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by wnevets on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:38AM (#8857155)
what are some of the possible consequences of title 2?
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by maxsilver on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:52PM (#8858102)
Providers would be required to allow competitors on their networks. (Similar to how AT&T is required to let other phone companies sell you home phone service over 'AT&Ts' phone line).

This opens up all sorts of good things:

- Faster peak speeds

- Lower latency

- Better customer support / service

- Lower prices

- Stronger net neutrality protections (no throttling Netflix, for instance)

Monopoly ISP's like Comcast / AT&T / Verizon will never do all of these things on their own -- there's no incentive for them to do so.

But if Title II passes, it will make it legal for competitors to start up and reuse the existing infrastructure while new ISPs attempt to build their own, then all of these things will probably occur. Similar to how this all occurred with phone companies when Title II - like protections passed on phone lines.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by adventured on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:48PM (#8859239)
Serious question - what's the incentive for new ISPs to build their own infrastructure?

As a competitor that's the last thing I would do is build, given the extraordinary cost and political BS involved. I'd put all of my effort into riding existing infrastructure for as long as I could.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by maxsilver on Thursday January 08, 2015 @07:11PM (#8859912)
Well, my opinion is probably not popular, since very few companies appear to be rolling out fiber.

But as someone who tried (and failed) to raise funds to start an ISP to build their own infrastructure, I would do it because it allows better return on investment.

Title II will (presumably) make cable companies open their cable lines to other customers. This will let competitive companies offer 20-100mbps DOCIS 3.0 service. But that's not super compelling. (It's compelling -- very few people like dealing with Comcast and many might switch on that alone. But you'd be offering roughly the same product they sell)

But fiber is the future, and is a huge competitive advantage. (10x performance for the same price). The first person to lay the fiber in a city doesn't just make money on their own network, they make money on all networks. Title II would make them open those lines up to competitors, but there's a lot of money to be made by getting cash from every subscriber -- even the ones who choose your competitors.

There's no incentive for the second fiber ISP to lay fiber. But for the first one to get there, it's much like a land-grab-to-rent situation. Doing that now (before AT&T and Comcast do it) would be smart -- regardless of whether Title II passes or not.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rhino369 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:09PM (#8857804)
Price controls

Higher taxes on ISP service

metered service

drastic reduction in investment due to uncertainty

pole attachment rates could go up since some towns charge more for title II services (for some dumb reason)

The next republican run FCC ruling that not blocking porn is unreasonable

The next FCC ruling that not blocking piracy is unreasonable

All sorts of shit.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by wtracy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:27PM (#8857922)

  metered service
Might actually be a good thing.

  The next republican run FCC ruling that not blocking porn is unreasonable

  The next FCC ruling that not blocking piracy is unreasonable
I thought Title II explicitly shielded carriers from responsibility for the content that went over their networks?
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rhino369 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:21PM (#8858311)
Shielding them from responsibility doesn't mean it can't force them to take measures to prevent it.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by organsnyder on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:41PM (#8858419)
Please cite a case where a Title II service has been required to take these sorts of measures in the past.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rhino369 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @02:55PM (#8858536)
Do Not Call List

The Bush Era FCC was fining people for swearing on TV and Radio.

Both parties support SOPA and 6 strikes.

The FCC regulated phone sex lines in the 1980s.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by organsnyder on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:55PM (#8858952)
> Do Not Call List I think most people are pleased with this.

> The Bush Era FCC was fining people for swearing on TV and Radio. Not Title II.

> Both parties support SOPA and 6 strikes. Can happen with or without Title II.

> The FCC regulated phone sex lines in the 1980s. Not familiar with this one (and I'm not going to research this specific case while at work). Though again, the government could easily decide to regulate this regardless of whether ISPs are under Title II.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by Zigurd on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:01PM (#8857741)
Pole access. That's a Good Thing.