News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Je Suis Charlie by dang on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:40AM (#8855267)
Please do not conduct religious flamewars on Hacker News.
Re:Je Suis Charlie by Jayd2014 on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @07:05PM (#8854209)
Well since you are asking about typing it in google. I actually did. Here is what comes as an answer from the muslim side[1]:

A member on my blog, brother "zulfiqarchucknorris", sent me the following information:

Peace Dear Osama Abdullah I would like to inform you that on the many articles about the "poet killings" (specifically asma bint marwan) you fail to to include why the asma bint marwan chain for ibn saad is weak, although the ibn ishaq version is fully explained. I'll give you the explanasion:

(copied from wikipedia, scroll toward the middle of the page)

Al-Albani declared Ibn Sa'd's chain of transmission to be weak as well, as it includes Al-Waqidi:[2]

Ibn Sa'd → Al-Waqidi → 'Abd Allah ibn al-Harith ibn al-Fudayl → Al-Harith ibn al-Fudayl

Al-Waqidi has been condemned as an untrustworthy narrator and has been frequently and severely criticized by scholars, thus his narrations have been abandoned by the majority of hadith scholars.[3] Yahya ibn Ma'een said: "Al-Waqidi narrated 20,000 false hadith about the prophet". Al-Shafi'i, Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Al-Albani[2] said: "Al-Waqidi is a liar" while Al-Bukhari said he didn't include a single letter by Al-Waqidi in his hadith works.

In addition, this isnad is discontinued (muʻḍal) as Al-Harith ibn al-Fudayl never met any of Muhammad's companions.[3]

2 is al waqidi 3 is ibn hisham

[1]http://www.answering-christianity.com/karim/forgeries_about_...

Copy pasting doesn't help anyone. I'd rather have it that you go to someone who is an expert on this field, do your research and ask him/her what's bugging you.

Re:Je Suis Charlie by waps on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:19AM (#8855115)
And does this answer satisfy you ? Answering-christianity (the site) is full of these sorts of answers. Most are similar to this one.

The technical answer to this reply is, firstly, that the same story is told by different narrators, not just the one mentioned. This is, of course, conveniently left out from the reponse you posted.

But if you're not a muslim, the answer is that this is part of the islamic canon. It's also part of sharia. It's part of the law in >50 islamic countries. If the argument held any water this would not be true.

> Copy pasting doesn't help anyone. I'd rather have it that you go to someone who is an expert on this field, do your research and ask him/her what's bugging you.

Sorry I was trained in exact sciences, and I have family that's in history (with focus on religious history). I believe in first sources' authority over people's authority.

Re:Je Suis Charlie by ZigmundFreud on Thursday January 08, 2015 @01:50AM (#8855292)
And yet Christians have it so right...

"Now it came about after these things, that God tested Abraham, and said to him, Abraham!' And he said, 'Here I am.' And He said, 'Take now your son, your only son, whom you love, Isaac, and go to the land of Moriah; and offer him there as a burnt offering on one of the mountains of which I will tell you.'"(Gen. 22:1-2).

Remember that religious texts are mostly proverbs. These events most probably didn't actually happen, they are trying to communicate moral attitudes via stories... a little like Winnie the Pooh and Friends.

Re:Je Suis Charlie by waps on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:11AM (#8860982)
1) does that excuse muhammad's massacres in any way ? Or should I answer with pointing out that atheists are responsible for the biggest massacres of the 20th century perhaps (ie. the communist "opium for the people" folks)

2) you're mostly showing ignorance, as "mostly proverbs" does not apply at all to islamic texts. Random example :

http://www.usc.edu/org/cmje/religious-texts/hadith/bukhari/0...

Different religions are different (surprising how controversial such an obvious truth can be).

3) Given that you're comparing moral parables ("lies to convey a greater truth" I've heard it defined, like fairy tales) to actual events, your point is reversed.

Re:Je Suis Charlie by yongjik on Thursday January 08, 2015 @12:16AM (#8855109)
He only had one killed? What a modest man, by biblical standards.

For comparison:

> He went up from there to Bethel, and while he was going up on the way, some small boys came out of the city and jeered at him, saying, “Go up, you baldhead! Go up, you baldhead!” And he turned around, and when he saw them, he cursed them in the name of the Lord. And two she-bears came out of the woods and tore forty-two of the boys.

(Not to mention killing all the firstborns of Egypt, wiping out the entire population of the Earth except for Noah's family, yadda yadda.)

Re:Je Suis Charlie by waps on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:01AM (#8860962)
> He only had one killed? What a modest man, by biblical standards.

No this is just one example. Estimates of how many people got killed and/or massacred by the prophet to bring us islam range from 10 000 to 100 000.

Individual people murdered by the prophet or his assassins (on his direct orders, excluding massacres of entire villages/groups/caravans/muslims), according to muslim's own history, is about 1220 people (most were "convicted" by him, the victims not even knowing there was a trial. That's how islam works : muslims would go to the prophet, explain the situation, the prophet would convict someone to death and send a squad of muslims to go kill the man/woman).

Example:

  A girl wearing ornaments, went out at Medina. Somebody struck her with a stone.   
  She was brought to the Prophet while she was still alive. Allah's Apostle asked 
  her, "Did such-and-such a person strike you?" She raised her head, denying 
  that. He asked her a second time, saying, "Did so-and-so strike you?" She 
  raised her head, denying that. He said for the third time, "Did so-and-so 
  strike you?" She lowered her head, agreeing. Allah's Apostle then sent for the 
  killer and killed him between two stones.
(Sahih Bukhari, Book 83, Number 16)

Islam/muslims (the Mughals to be exact) also hold the title of biggest massacre in history. The Mughal invasion of India was a massacre that lasted almost 1300 years and estimates of the death toll range from 60 million to 300 million people. Before the massacre India bordered Russia. Ironically a region of Afghanistan is still called "Hindu Kush" or massacre of Hindus.