News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by maxerickson on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @05:55PM (#8853898)
Isn't that then more of a preference and less of a principled disagreement?
Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by shkkmo on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @06:15PM (#8853966)
Wouldn't leaving your phone on silent and streaming music on HD all night be also principled disagreement?
Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by freehunter on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @10:39PM (#8854878)
I disagree with their policy in principle. In practice, I use the hell out of it. I frequently drive long distances (over an hour each way) streaming music from Spotify the entire way.

I would rather have no data cap the same way my home Internet connection has no data cap. I would rather they not make exemptions for music specifically, since that shows they don't need the caps in the first place. But as long as they offer it (and I used T-Mobile long before they announced it), I will use it to my advantage.

Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by maxerickson on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:53AM (#8855985)
I'm whining about your phrasing. I wish people only used "principle" to describe very strongly held beliefs.

You are weighing your belief that 'data is data' against, basically, a trivial convenience (you have many options, among them: no music, downloaded music, cheap streaming violating the principle, expensive streaming respecting the principle). That action says something about how strongly you believe in 'data is data'.

Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by mdpye on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:09AM (#8856381)
If you want to talk about the phrasing, I think you're missing a subtle distinction.

He disagrees IN principle, not ON principle.

As in, he disagrees in principle, but not in practice. As I understand it, "on principle" is the construction describing taking a stand on a decision because of your deeply held convictions. "In principle" is for a decision you've derived logically from a set of abstract premises.

Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by maxerickson on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:31AM (#8856477)
The first comment in the thread uses "on principle". The next one uses "in principle", but I think it is used there to describe a belief.

I could very well misunderstand, I don't know (or the usage above could be loose).

I guess part of my problem is that I have trouble with a construction like "In principle, I believe in the sanctity of human life. In practice, sometimes you have to execute bad people."

(I think) That's better expressed as a preference that people not be killed. It's a silly extreme example, but I'm having trouble seeing how else it would be used, in a mechanistic sense.

Re:Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive by freehunter on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:54AM (#8856589)
It's more of "my principles tell me that this policy is wrong. However, I don't have the ability to make it right or avoid using it. So until it's set right by someone who DOES have that power, I don't have a choice."

So to use your analogy, I believe in the sanctity of human life. But my government doesn't. I don't kill anyone, but I live in a country that does. The fact that my government kills people won't stop me from driving on the government-built roads.

However you want to word it, I disagree with T-Mobile and AT&T's net neutrality policies. But I'm not in a position of power to make them change that, so what can I do?