News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by bambax on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @05:45PM (#8847621)
> When Bezos insisted that the original 2007 Kindle include a cellular connection so customers could download and access e-books from anywhere, people thought the idea was an exorbitant flourish (...) When Bezos encouraged a free-shipping initiative, executives pushed back, nervous about its impact on earnings. (...) So when it came to the Fire Phone, says one former product lead, "Yes, there was heated debate about whether it was heading in the right direction. But at a certain point, you just think, ‘Well, this guy has been right so many times before.’"

It must be extremely hard/impossible to challenge Jeff Bezos when you're... well when you're not him.

However, the examples given here of Jeff being right, are about features that benefit customers (at a cost that some people thought was too high).

But the problem with the 3-D functionality wasn't that it was costing the company too much. It was that nobody could figure out how it would be useful -- at any cost for Amazon, or the customer.

I remember the videos promoting the Fire phone with random people saying "wow"... they reminded me of the Windows Vista videos, with random people looking out their window and staring at deer in the morning sun.

If you have to pay actors to say "wow" in a video maybe there's a problem.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by potatolicious on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @06:02PM (#8847712)
Right on - the biggest (and IMO only truly relevant) reason why the Fire Phone flopped is because it doesn't benefit customers.

The Fire Phone wasn't built to be a superior phone, or give customers something truly new and useful. It was built to be an Amazon Content Delivery Device.

This is a phone whose primary raison d'etre is to get people to buy more stuff from Amazon. It's a distillation of a platform strategy, not the desire to produce a genuine product.

Until Amazon starts coming at this with the primary goal of producing a greater, better phone - and the goal of selling more Amazon content a distant second - they will keep failing.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by zrm on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @05:43AM (#8849801)
> Until Amazon starts coming at this with the primary goal of producing a greater, better phone - and the goal of selling more Amazon content a distant second - they will keep failing.

The strange thing is that they would have succeeded if they had just adopted their normal strategy. It would be fine if a prominent feature of the phone was that you could take a picture of any barcode on anything and have Amazon ship you one. That sort of thing isn't the problem because it's actually useful.

As an example of what they're doing wrong, Amazon is charging the same 30% in their app store as Apple and Google. They should be charging 3%. Low margin is where Amazon eats. That would get more apps in their store, get all the app developers promoting their devices and put pressure on Apple and Google to charge lower rates to anyone including Amazon who wants to sell content to people locked into the competing app stores. Their competitors look like profiteers if they don't respond and lose revenue if they do.

They're trying to enter a market and beat the incumbents at their own game when they could be making them play Amazon's game instead.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by ableal on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @05:25PM (#8853739)
> They should be charging 3%. Low margin is where Amazon eats.

That is disturbingly insightful.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by qq66 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:18PM (#8848873)
The Kindle Fire tablets are also designed to sell Amazon content, but they benefit the customer with their rock-bottom pricing which the Fire Phone did not have.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by davidw on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @02:56AM (#8849360)
I have one of the original Fire tablets, and would not buy another one if not for the express purpose of delivering Amazon content - videos in that case, since the actual reading experience is far superior on a real Kindle. It's not a bad tablet, but not having the Google apps, as well as something relatively close to stock Android, makes it not as useful as it could have been.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by Methusalah on Friday January 09, 2015 @03:23PM (#8864288)
It's really worth jailbreaking it, if only for the sake of installing google play.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by delecti on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @10:55AM (#8851197)
They also benefit from the fact that tablets (at least in my experience) are primarily content consumption devices, whether that's books, videos, or games.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by snarfy on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @10:00AM (#8850786)
That's how I felt as well. It's a great phone...for amazon, not you or me.

That's how you know the marketing/business types are deciding the features, not product development.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by tiglionabbit on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @07:30PM (#8848111)
I'm not sure what having so many cameras has to do with that.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by rancur on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @08:03PM (#8848233)
nobody is
Re:The Fire phone debacle by mgkimsal on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:27PM (#8848896)
Well... the kindle was pretty much just a device "to get people to buy more stuff from Amazon." But there were no other competitors at the time. The fire phone was going up against a huge market of phone devices with many better features and ecosystems already.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by apozem on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:56PM (#8848962)
I would argue Kindles benefit the consumer in that they're also enjoyable reading experiences. You can carry a library's worth of books in your backpack on a device with a wonderful screen.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by SixSigma on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @10:05AM (#8850813)
I would argue that the connectivity was the killer feature. I have a Pre kindle Sony e-reader, same thing - whole library in your backpack.

Getting those books on the thing, however, is a pain - you need a computer to go with it.

My mom bought an early kindle - worldwide wifi, with email!

So she bought the next kindle too.

Re:The Fire phone debacle by philwelch on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @01:05AM (#8849143)
Hell, even carrying a backpack's worth of books in your hand is a massive improvement.
Re:The Fire phone debacle by unepipe on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @03:22AM (#8849426)
if you like to read, the kindle paperwhite is amazing. so much better than reading on an ipad or iphone, and you can carry/instantly download so many books/pdfs you find online (browser button automatically sends it to your kindle)/etc... Great for reading, actually benefits the customer.