News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by Flemlord on Thursday October 15, 2009 @07:32PM (#884463)
Agreed. If it's too big to fail, it's to big to exist.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by anamax on Thursday October 15, 2009 @09:40PM (#884610)
And the truth of that statement is not bank-specific.

For example, it applies to financial regulators and even govts....

Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by redcap on Thursday October 15, 2009 @10:12PM (#884649)
You really want governments to start failing?

I mean California is getting close, but that's mostly because it hamstrung itself early on by allowing citizens to promote legislation.

While there are a few governments that I would like to be changed (Chinese Democracy anyone), the general trend towards democracy and liberty has been a good thing.

If saw a govt does get too big to fail, having it fail could well lead to chaos or a dictatorship.

I know there is a lot of whinging by Republicans in the US about 'small' government, but really you're not going to get decent change in your country overall unless the federal government acts as the states aren't up to it (seatbelt laws anyone?)

Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by shpxnvz on Thursday October 15, 2009 @11:11PM (#884718)
really you're not going to get decent change in your country overall unless the federal government acts as the states aren't up to it (seatbelt laws anyone?)

The point is that in the U.S. the Federal Government was, by design, to be limited in the powers it could exert over the states and citizens.

I think the argument from those who are for "small government" is not that change such as seatbelt laws are bad or unwanted, but that the cost of and danger in relinquishing to the Federal Government the power to make those decisions is far, far greater.

Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by cvg on Thursday October 15, 2009 @10:46PM (#884687)
I don't think Anamax is saying that he wants appropriate governments to fail, but rather that ginormous governments should be split as well. If a country's failure leads to chaos, perhaps the size of that government should be rethought.

We should step back and realize that a government isn't some sacred perpetual institution but rather a means to represent people. If a government fails to represent it's people, it must be changed.

Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by anamax on Friday October 16, 2009 @12:46AM (#884806)
I thought that that's what I wrote. Thanks.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by ams6110 on Thursday October 15, 2009 @10:29PM (#884668)
I think in the case of governments it's not that they can be too big to fail, it's that if they get too big, they do fail. Though maybe that's the general case, now that I think about it.

edit s/its/it\'s/g

Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by dangoldin on Thursday October 15, 2009 @10:31PM (#884673)
At the same time the bigger the government the less change the country will have since most of the resources will be used by people in government to maintain the status quo.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by dantheman on Thursday October 15, 2009 @10:43PM (#884686)
There is no too big to fail, that is just a ploy to convince you to not be angry at your money being given to them. Sure if they failed it would be bad, but it's going to be bad anyway. All we are doing is prolonging and exacerbating the pain.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by mbrubeck on Friday October 16, 2009 @12:05AM (#884774)
Splitting up the banks won't eliminate the "too big to fail" problem. If a systemic crash (like the one last year) causes hundreds of smaller banks to fail, there will be just as much pressure to bail them out as if one giant bank fails.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by MaysonL on Saturday October 17, 2009 @03:48AM (#886755)
99 have already failed this year, and probably 2 or 3 hundred more will fail before this crisis is over, and their depositors have been bailed out - their stockholders and management haven't, unlike the big guys.
Re:Greenspan Says U.S. Should Consider Breaking Up Large Banks by andre on Thursday October 15, 2009 @07:34PM (#884466)
2nd that