News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by Animats on Friday January 02, 2015 @02:39PM (#8828131)
The cosmology end of physics is kind of stuck right now. Many-worlds and the anthropic principle are back again. What they're theorizing about has way too much stuff that can't be observed or tested experimentally. Some people question whether this is even science.

"Science is prediction, not explanation." - Fred Hoyle.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by jacquesm on Friday January 02, 2015 @02:45PM (#8828158)
It wouldn't surprise me at all if there are very hard limits to what science can prove when it comes to questions like these. After all some experiments can't be done from within the box and the box that we're in is made of the very laws that we're trying to escape from in order to do the experiments.

It's almost the physical equivalent of Gödel's incompleteness theorem.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by yborg on Friday January 02, 2015 @02:52PM (#8828189)
As with Gödel's proofs, proving that it is impossible to come up with an experimentally verifiable demonstration that the multiverse theory is correct would be a major achievement. And Gödel didn't end mathematics with his theorems. It simply moved on, as would physics.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by ccvannorman on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:02PM (#8828232)
Along similar lines, I've wondered if it's possible to prove "any observing entity (e.g. a human) cannot possibly fully understand the system within which it is contained" .. any complete knowledge of a system should necessitate a larger system.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by Xcelerate on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:15PM (#8828291)
I've always wondered this as well.

Consider a finite collection of atoms consisting of a human and an environment. For simplicity, assume these atoms move classically. The human is a subsystem, and since the entire system involves deterministically, there is only a limited number of configurations that the human subsystem can realize within the environment. If a "human" is what is necessary to comprehend reality, then there are aspects of the system that cannot be realized by the subsystem, since there are far more states available to the total system.

Then again, I could just be rambling.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by danbruc on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:59PM (#8828516)
I would argue it depends on the nature of the system. If the system follows (simple) rules then you can likely compress the description of the system into something that fits into a (small) subsystem. If the system and its behavior is a uncompressible mess this will not work out. Up to now, I would say, our universe with all its relatively simple laws of physics looks pretty structured and easily compressible.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by hasenj on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:53PM (#8829444)
I don't think this works. You don't have to encompass everything about the universe in your mind. You can just comprehend a formula that allows you in principle to calculate any part of it that you need.

Think of a fractal. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandelbrot_set

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by rndn on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:21PM (#8829328)
It’s easy to prove "we don’t know that" since maybe it is possible to introspect our universe. For example, suppose someone interacts with some quantum system and it unexpectedly outputs a binary string. It turns out that this string can be interpreted as a command-line interface where one can access the states of individual particles and inspect the running process. Given the program code of our universe is reasonably short, we could possibly fully understand the system from within.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by evanb on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:13PM (#8828861)
There's some relevant discussion on this old thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7244476
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:30PM (#8828935)
The negation of the multiverse hypothesis can be taken to be, "no, there aren't multiple universes, let alone an infinity of them; there is only this one".

This negation is just as hard to prove as the multiverse hypothesis.

Lack of evidence of the existence of other universes doesn't prove their non-existence, nor does it rule out their existence.

However, note that the multiverse hypothesis is simpler in its content. The statement that this universe exists, while all the other ones do not, goes one step beyond the statement that they all exist.

Is there no evidence that there are no other universes?

Mathematics shows us that there are: it shows us that entities exist which are not located anywhere in this universe.

For instance, the number pi. We accept pi as real, but where in this universe is it? It is not computable, so that even if we use all the particles in this universe as the beads of an abacus, it will not represent pi.

If this universe is all there is, then there is no pi; we must stop talking in terms such as "there exists a real number that gives the ratio of the circumference to the diameter of a circle".

(Of course, the existence of this one is shared between the multiverse hypothesis and its negation.)

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by hasenj on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:56PM (#8829460)
PI is a concenpt. Of course it doesn't exist physically* in the universe.

* Well, various "physical" representations/encodings of this concept must exist in different people's brains.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @08:06PM (#8829498)
Whether the existence of pi is different from the existence of a given stone is a philosophical question! Maybe you and I exist exactly in the same sense that pi exists: no more, no less.

Concepts can be reshaped. If pi is merely a concept, why can't we conceive it to be something else, like 4.0?

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday January 02, 2015 @09:08PM (#8829646)
In a curved spacetime Pi could easily be 4.0.

Pi is an idealised approximation of a certain kind of curvature in a certain kind of spacetime. Pi appears to have infinite precision only if you assume the curvature and the spacetime are perfectly smooth and have infinite resolution.

Given there's a Planck limit, it's unlikely the universe really is perfectly smooth. So Pi in the real universe is not very likely to have infinite precision.

That's where the concept of Pi as a Platonic example of mathematical perfection trips over the reality of physics as a messy thing where traditional math structures can only ever provide approximate descriptions.

Beyond a certain level of detail Other Stuff is happening, and you can't assume smoothness or infinite precision.

We don't know a whole lot about the Other Stuff yet. One reason is that math was built to work with smooth functions with infinite precision, and there's no equivalent math that describes the lumps of whatever spacetime is made of, or the relationships between the lumps.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @10:31PM (#8829831)
Pi isn't an approximation but a real number which is uncomputable, but otherwise precisely identified. On the other hand, a rational number like 3.14159 serves as an approximation of pi.

pi doesn't help you find the distance around a circle in some curved space-time, but pi is what it is.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @08:12PM (#8829520)
The multiverse hypothesis by definition asserts that such a thing is impossible. The universes are separate. Any entanglement between universes means they are in fact just constituents of a larger universe.

I think that the hypothesis will be quasi-proven when science hits the ultimate limit beyond which there is no explanation. This will show that the world just proceeds by arbitrary rules that are traceable to axioms. Once you have that, you have shown that it's indistinguishable from any other such a formal system. That is to say, that it exists in the same way: the world is no more or less real than, say, the plane of the complex numbers. After that, although you still don't have empirical evidence of other worlds, there is no short supply of imaginable worlds (such as in mathematics) which are just as real.

In other words, once it becomes obvious that the world is just "math all the way down", it will be as foolish to deny other existences as to deny the square root of -1.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by vorg on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:27PM (#8828925)
> Gödel didn't end mathematics with his theorems. It simply moved on

That's another way of saying Godel's theorems didn't end Mathematics, mathematicians just redefined what Mathematics was, presumably so they could keep their jobs.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by danbruc on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:38PM (#8828408)
[...] some experiments can't be done from within the box [...]

Only true if the box is not everything.

[deleted]
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by 98Windows on Friday January 02, 2015 @04:14PM (#8828589)
Many Worlds does solve the measurement problem (argueably) better than any other interpretation of quantum mechanics. [1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem