I agree and raise you the point that this is Chrome-only, and doesn't even bother to mention it. Half of the spinners fail to work in Firefox stable.
I know they didn't write the spinners, but the company seems targeted at teaching:
> Pathgather is an NYC-based startup building a platform that dramatically accelerates learning for enterprises
Platform lock-in on the Web is an odd thing to teach.
And I agree that a skeleton project to show proper modularization of different components would be great! Our blog just started an Angular series, so we'll try to write one on how we split up our large Angular enterprise app in this regard :)
I sure was guilty of big sites just as much as the next guy. It just saddens me that insted of promoting what we've learned it the past years and applying to current projects we're doomed to repeat bad UX from before.
Sure. Maybe it's literally always a Bad Thing to show a loading screen. But plenty of apps have made that choice, for some reason or other. Maybe the developers are incompetent, or maybe they have a combination of technical and resource constraints that make this the best choice for them. It doesn't matter. At least this loading page can improve users' experiences with apps that have, for whatever reason, made the choice to go this route.
If you look at web applications, Google's music app ("My Music" in Google Play) uses a load screen (complete with progress bar) because it's seriously bloated, while Amazon's Cloudplayer just loads and does its thing (which is, playing music).
Needing a load screen is a sign that your app is not, or aims at not being, a Web app anymore - in the sense that you'd also want to loosen the other restrictions - give it its own window, possibly have local file storage or FS caching, etc.; In that case, something like TideSDK ( http://www.tidesdk.org/ ) may come in handy to deliver a desktop app to power users that is based on the same codebase. And, maybe you'd still want a web app that is functional and lean. (As an example for two apps with non-identical possibilities, Google's My Music allows you to change song metadata on desktop browsers but not in the Android app - yet another sign that My Music is meant as a desktop-y app).
In many cases it can be a sign of hubris or lazyness that you cannot get rid of the bloat. Be real and think whether your users actually enjoy waiting that time, since they'll be doing it more often, on machines with less resources and/or slower connection, than yours.
Note, this isn't always easy to do. If you use on-the-fly gzip compression (which is how most people set their nginx or whatever up), you won't get a Content-Length, so you can't show progress.
For example, we have some heavy reports that take a few seconds to load, so we show a screen similar to this while we crunch the numbers.
My issue with whole-page takeover loaders is that they lose your control and spatial sense of the app. You can't, for example, page away if you decide the report is taking too long to load, or you went to the wrong section of the site when hunting around for a piece of information.
This can likely be extended to only be utilized on part of a widget. If it's something like an ajax call you can easily add an option to cancel the request e.g. underneath a spinner.
For your report example in particular the service could be developed in such a way that the processing occurs independently of the user session. You can mix this in with an additional request which returns the actual progress of what has been calculated in the report such that whenever a user browses to that page, they can see just how much time there is to go before their report is generated.
HTML 5 is the web remaking itself in the image of Flash.
HTML 5 is an attempt to turn the web browser into a replacement for the Flash Player. Punch the Monkey Flash ads are replaced with Punch the Monkey HTML 5 ads.
Javascript framework after framework comes and implements the Flash way of doing things in the browser.
And the irony is that Flex is still the best way of producing RIAs years after Adobe killed it.
I would much more appreciate that dev time would be put into a framework that allows graceful enchancement by deferring loading more heavy components and to allow user to interact with the site ASAP.
Having a skeleton project for gulp (or any other system) that shows how to properly split big, non essential, components and lazy load them would go much further to ease developing big applications and smoothen UX.
EDIT: typos.