I feel the best of both worlds is the bazaar model combined with curated software/library repositories where rules for inclusion are more rigid and opinionated. For example, most programming languages have a standard library (the cathedral) and an ecosystem of third party libraries (the bazaar). Within that ecosystem of third party libraries, we could theoretically have curated repositories of libraries which share a coherent vision. In the real world though, I haven't really seen that happening. Node.js has registry.npmjs.org (no curation), Ruby has rubygems.org (no curation), etc. In the OS world, there is Ubuntu which is more cathedral like but I feel it should be a lot more opinionated perhaps at the cost of flexibility/portability.
The fact that Linux-in-general is a roiling maelstrom is irrelevant to a user using a particular distro. It is relevant to developers and/or packagers though.
That's the problem with opinions, when they are too weak they are almost useless, and when they get stronger people can not agree on anything anymore.
That said, there isn't anything that prevents people from having standards. Both FreeBSD and MacOS are pretty coherent UNIX type OSes. But it is important to realize that a lot of really innovative and cool stuff comes out of the amazing bubbling pot that is Linux as well. I sometimes wish it were possible to do a better mashup.