News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by bjornsing on Monday December 29, 2014 @08:58PM (#8812922)
> He missed the core point that the freedom to protest is important in and of itself.

I agree wholeheartedly. Also, I was a bit surprised that he didn't refute the claim that you need a permit to peacefully assemble in the US. Is that really so?

Where I am (Sweden) you can "apply for a permit weeks and months in advance", but you don't have to. There's nothing illegal about the peaceful assembly of a large number of people, in fact it's a right ensured by "basic law" (similar to a constitution).

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by veidr on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:40PM (#8813028)
It is similar in the USA (the basic right to peaceful protest is guaranteed by the Constitution), but it is not explicit about the details.

So various localities have tried to interpret that as meaning 'you have the right to do it if you do X, Y or Z' (such as obtaining a permit in advance, or not being too loud too early in the morning, or not blocking traffic, etc etc etc).

In general, you do not need a permit in the USA to hold a protest or demonstration. But in practice, in many cases police will interfere if they want to, leaving it up to courts to decide (much later) if the police actions were permissible under the law. Having a permit in advance will make such police actions less likely.

Source: IANAL,BYDNTBAFLTCOBCRILTO

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by embarcadero on Monday December 29, 2014 @11:34PM (#8813351)
I tried applying for one of these permits on the largest stage in the US -- NYC -- on several occasions. The Parks Dept, which issues such permits, is a nightmare to deal with: they charge per application, require multiple applications merely to check different dates, and regularly lie about the availability of parks.

You might think spontaneous assembly is an option, and in some cases it is, but if you're going to have speakers (people), you need a sound system, and to set up a sound system you need a police permit, and to get a police permit you need a Parks permit. Start setting up without these and you'll be arrested before anyone utters a word.

Then there are the various "public-private spaces". Try applying for a permit to rally in Zuccotti Park and the go-to person will put you on hold, only to come back and say they are only issuing permits for cultural events. So the developers get their air rights, while the public gets the muzzle. Bullshit. Anil Dash has written about this some: http://dashes.com/anil/2012/03/captive-atria-and-living-in-p...

Indeed, the very frequency with which the Farmers' Market is now held in Union Square, the most central spot in NYC and a place rich in social movements, might be construed as little more than cover for crowd control, have as it does the effect of making this space all but inaccessible to protesters.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by rquantz on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @12:00AM (#8813412)
the very frequency with which the Farmers' Market is now held in Union Square... might be construed as little more than cover for crowd control, have as it does the effect of making this space all but inaccessible to protesters.

Not saying your argument is unfounded, but may be overstated. I do most of my grocery shopping at union square, and there seems to be a protest there about 30% of the time. I'm sure some people get turned down, but it is clearly accessible to protesters often enough that there are basically permanent police barriers there.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by embarcadero on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @11:57AM (#8815393)
Yes, but how many of these are rallies (with people speaking)? Even though the south end of the square is usually free, including on market days, Parks will tell you that they do not issue permits when the farmers are in the other parts of the square. Ask them why they issued one to, say, March Against Monsanto, and they'll say that event was "grandfathered in" (ie, has been happening for several years). (And ask MAM and they'll tell you it was a huge hassle for them as well.)

Meanwhile, on the north end of the square the city is privatizing park space: http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/eats/restaurant-union-...

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by pdabbadabba on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @12:02PM (#8815420)
Much of what you describe may be unconstitutional. If you can substantiate these claims, and want to make a difference, I strongly urge you to find a lawyer. If you're serious, feel free to email me and we can talk more.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by embarcadero on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @04:25PM (#8821155)
I'd be happy to talk. What's your email?
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by pdabbadabba on Sunday January 04, 2015 @05:22PM (#8836112)
Great. It's my user name at gmail.com.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by vacri on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:17PM (#8813146)
It certainly isn't explicit, which is why US courts have ruled that while the government can't restrict the content of what you say, they can restrict where and when you say it. 'Where' in the past has included 'somewhere where the target of your protest can't actually notice you'. It seems an internally inconsistent position; you can say whatever you want, but not where we don't want you to say it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by venomsnake on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @08:45AM (#8814544)
> It seems an internally inconsistent position; you can say whatever you want, but not where we don't want you to say it.

Totally consistent if the assumption is that the constitution is not the foundation of the government power, but a obstacle to be overcome for it to be able to fulfill it.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by bthomas on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:46PM (#8813052)
But you don't need to be a fucking lawyer to...?
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by veidr on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:55PM (#8813080)
...comment on basic civil rights issues like this one. ;-)
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by viewer5 on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @08:30AM (#8814483)
Can't believe bthomas hadn't encountered that abbreviation in the wild before!
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by pdabbadabba on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @11:54AM (#8815369)
The short answer is that a locality may impose "reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions." Such a restriction, to be reasonable, must be content neutral, serve a significant government interest, be narrowly tailored to further that interest, and leave open ample alternative fora.

So, for example, if you want to lead a large march down a busy street, you generally can't do that in advance without a permit. The reason for this, I take it, is fairly obvious. If a government wants to restrict your ability to conduct a large protest in, say, a public park, on the other hand, they're going to have a harder time in court explaining why the restriction is reasonable.

Courts review these restrictions under "intermediate scrutiny" which means that, while they don't look as hard as they would if the restriction were content based (for example), they are still supposed to conduct a meaningful and detailed review.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by Thrymr on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:07PM (#8812942)
"The right of the people peaceably to assemble" is protected in the Bill of Rights (1st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution). The letter writer seems to be referring to the shutting down a public street, which indeed could subject to a permit by a local government (for a protest or a parade).
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by rquantz on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @12:03AM (#8813419)
You've misquoted the amendment. It is "the right to peaceably assemble." The Constitution was written before the invention of grammar nazis, and before Victorian snobs decided you couldn't split an infinitive verb.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by areyousure on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @05:29PM (#8817107)
No, your parent comment has in fact literally quoted the amendment. For example, on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_S... you will find the full text as follows: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Please be more careful before posting in the future.

You may find it interesting to examine the original text of the Bill of Rights, where the first amendment appears as Article the third: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/79/Bill_of_R...

(Article the first has never been ratified. Article the second was ratified in 1992. Articles three through twelve were ratified as the first ten amendments in 1791.)

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by rquantz on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @12:53AM (#8818397)
Please be more careful before posting in the future.

Interestingly, to me at least, I read the quote, and remembered the text with a split infinitive. To check that I was right, I googled the text of the amendment, which google helpfully displayed above the search results. Seeing that I was right, I copied and pasted the text from google into the comment box here. What I did not do was read the whole text that google provided, only the relevant clause. If I had read the whole thing I would have realized it was a paraphrase rather than the actual text. I offer my humblest and deepest possible apologies to the OP, and to you.

However, I probably won't be much more careful when posting in the future. I try to keep my statements of fact on HN accurate by checking at least some source. In the end that's as far as I'm going to go.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by areyousure on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @01:11AM (#8818420)
Thank you for the explanation of how that came about. Cheers!
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by graycat on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @12:36AM (#8813478)
The excuse I heard was that an infinitive in English is two words but corresponds to a single word in Latin, and, of course, as all good Latin experts know, English grammar should be as much like Latin as possible! So, since can't split a single word infinitive in Latin, we shouldn't in English! So, "to be" is okay but "to not be" would be bad. "To an infinitive split" would be awful! So, string me up if I were to badly split an infinitive!
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by jcrites on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @01:08AM (#8813542)
Sometimes it just sounds better. Why it does is an interesting question for linguists.

"To boldly go where no man has gone before"

"We are determined to completely and utterly eradicate the disease."

"She wants to gradually get rid of her teddy bears."

"Writers should learn to not split infinitives."

It's also not always possible to eliminate the split infinitive, or the infinitive, without changing the direct or implied meaning of the sentence. "She wants to get rid of her teddy bears gradually" works fairly well.

"Boldly going where no man has gone before" is close, but doesn't capture the same challenge, summons, call to action as the original. Nor does it sound as pleasing.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by graycat on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @01:24AM (#8813576)
For the stuff inside the split infinitive, it can to tough to know where else to put it.

So, what would we want?

"Boldly to go where ..."

or

"To go boldly where ..."?

To be really clear that 'boldly' modifies 'to go', it's easiest to split the infinitive.

Your

"She wants to gradually get rid of her teddy bears."

is terrific! There's just no good other place to put 'gradually'!

In case you misunderstood me, for grammar for English, really I have no sympathy for what the heck Latin did!

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by mrpoptart on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @11:11AM (#8815133)
> There's just no good other place to put 'gradually'!

She wants to get rid of her teddy bears gradually.

Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by graycat on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @02:04PM (#8816068)
I thought of that but regarded 'gradually' as too far, too many words away, from 'get', the word it is modifying.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by aninhumer on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @03:25PM (#8816549)
It's not as good as the split infinitive, but it works okay despite the distance, because it's modifying the entire sentence.
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by graycat on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @01:25AM (#8818441)
When I was diagramming sentences, they never let me modify "the entire sentence"! Maybe the reason was that Latin never did that!
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by tekromancr on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @01:11PM (#8815785)
Not an english expert, but would "She wants, gradually, to get rid of her teddy bears" work?
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by graycat on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @02:07PM (#8816089)
Problem is, without thinking about the likely meaning, at first glance it's not clear what 'gradually' modifies, that is, it may modify 'wants', that is, her wanting is only gradual and not yet full; such are some of the possibilities of subtlety of meaning with the English language!
Re:Nashville police chief shares message, responds to questions by tekromancr on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @11:25PM (#8818246)
Ohh, I see the confusion there, but I like the ambiguity it causes. It reminds me of "Pretty little girl's school"