News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by jaysonelliot on Sunday December 28, 2014 @08:29PM (#8808192)
This sentence leapt out at me: "That includes borrowing that may have been used to compensate slave owners when slavery was abolished."

You mean to tell me that after the horrors of slavery finally ceased, it was the slaveholders that got reparations?

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by ars on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:48PM (#8808360)
You can read it for yourself: http://www.pdavis.nl/Legis_07.htm

Slavery was not considered a "horror" at the time, it was considered "injust" and it was seen as equally "injust" to take away a right society had given someone and not compensate them.

It's interesting that they also say "expedient". To me that means they felt their economy would continue just fine without the slaves. And they were freeing them as a sort of "eh, why not".

Remember these slave holders were not people on the fringes of society, they were ordinary people. Society did not consider what they did to be evil, so why would that same society punish them?

You have to look at people's actions through the lens of their own life, not the lens of yours. Well, you can look at them through your own lens, but that only lets you condemn the result, not the people, and not the actions.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by arethuza on Monday December 29, 2014 @04:35AM (#8809093)
It clearly was considered a "horror" in the late 18th and early 19th century - that's why it got banned in places like the UK. Consider William Wilberforce's 1789 "Abolition Speech" in the House of Commons:

http://www.artofmanliness.com/abolition-speech-by-william-wi...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by ars on Monday December 29, 2014 @05:13AM (#8809197)
Did you read the link you gave me?

He did not talk at all about freeing the slaves, but rather about the condition of their transport. To me it seemed that if instead of freeing them, they would have instead improved the transport conditions, he would have been satisfied.

Or in other words he did not see a problem with owning people. He had a problem with treating them badly.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by DrJokepu on Monday December 29, 2014 @06:18AM (#8809339)
Except there are plenty of other sources that clearly show that William Wilberforce did, in fact, support the complete abolition of slavery in the British empire.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by ars on Monday December 29, 2014 @04:02PM (#8811750)
Then he should have linked to that.

But keep in mind, the question isn't really about if they supported abolition, but if they considered slavery a "horror" and slave owners to be "evil".

It's a separate question from supporting abolition because it is morally justified.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by sgt101 on Monday December 29, 2014 @07:41AM (#8809509)
I think the speech should be seen in the context of the struggle against slavery.

This was a battle against substantial commercial vested interests and deeply held racism/race hatred. Wilberforce and other abolitionists argued from biblical belief that all had been made in the image of God. They believed (and spoke and wrote) that slavery was contrary to Christianity, and that to fail to fight slavery was unchristian. Additionally, as in the United States, the use of slaves by the ruling class was held to be an attack on the economic position of the working class, so there was a popular sentiment against slavery which was not moral or anti-racist but instead self interested. Most English people thought that if blatant slavery were allowed they would loose their livelihoods and would either starve or end as slaves themselves. Note: there were many practices in England at this time that would be described as slavery now, but they stopped short of the extraction of free labour via violence as per field slaves in the USA and the Caribbean.

The position of slavery in law was tenuous and attacked by the racism of the establishment and the vast wealth of slave owning and slave trading interests. It rested on the common law assertion of the rights of individuals in England. These rights had emerged over 700 or so years as a bargain between the English ruling class, the King and the peasantry and were the basis of civil society. Undermining them could (and had cf. France, the English Civil War, the Peasants Revolt) led to mass slaughter, including of noble people and members of parliament. They were not explicit or clear.

The position at the time of the speech was that it was vaguely agreed that if someone was in England they could not be a slave. Some people included non-Caucasians in the "someone" category, but there were a lot of people who would exclude non-Caucasians (and other groups like Irish people, Scottish people, people who were poor and so on) from the definition of humanity. There were many examples of slaves being owned and no one doing anything about it. This is very similar to the position in law of domestic violence in the 20th century, it was quite possible to assert that it was banned completely, but in fact it was allowed so long as no one really kicked up a fuss, which if you were very powerful would be never - although if you beat your wife to death you would probably get in trouble.

The question, for the pro-slavers was, where to drive the wedge so as to avoid the nasty "my house is on fire and there are 1000 people outside with sticks" episodes that other ruling classes had been faced with.

So for Wilberforce it was fundamental to assume that Slavery was utterly banned in England, and that it was unthinkable and inadmissible to consider it. Tacitly the argument was that if you drew the line anywhere at all then the position of the elite would be unsustainable. Wilberforce believed that all humans were made in the image of God and were God's children equal in his eyes but was trying to sell the proposition that having slaves in England was impossible and the slave trade was necessarily wicked.

It was not established at all that slavery outside of England and the protection of the Common Law as enforced by God's representative (the King of England) was not allowed. And no one believed that slaves in the USA or any other god forsaken hole would lead to a revolution in England. Many racists didn't care at all that non-Caucasians were enslaved, and didn't see anything wrong with it.

Additionally some silly behaviour in Boston harbour and the subsequent brilliantly diplomatic and subtle disengagement from the territory of the USA by the British (we ran away) meant that there was no prospect of the English parliament being able to assert a ban on slavery in the USA. Also a direct assault on the economics of the sugar plantations in Jamaica would have stirred some strong opposition that the abolitionists were keen to avoid.

The propensity of the English working classes to violence could not be invoked to attack the slave trade or ownership overseas. They could be relied on to prevent the admission in public debate that anyone wanted to establish mass slave ownership in England. The evident cruelty of some of the practices of slavery were widely used to attack it, but it was argued that these were not part of the institution of slavery, any more than cruelty to livestock was part of farming. The cruel practices of slavery could be characterised as aberrant and amenable to remedy. But Wilberforce is arguing that the institution of the Trade of Slaves is necessarily cruel, and these cruelties are not amenable to remedy.

This is why Wilberforce is attacking the trade and not the practice.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by altoz on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:38PM (#8808333)
Believe it or not, the alternative was much worse. In the US, the Civil War cost roughly $8 billion (in 1860 dollars) and 600,000 lives. There were roughly 4 million slaves in the US at that time and using the New Orleans auction prices of that time you get an estimate of $2.7-$3.7 billion for the entire slave population of the United States.

Basically, NOT compensating slaveholders cost more than twice as much and many more lives in the US.

http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/articles/40820/straight-d...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by dredmorbius on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:25AM (#8810111)
Ah, but t'weren't t' North 'as started shootin':

Hostilities began on April 12, 1861, when Confederate forces fired upon Fort Sumter, a key fort held by Union troops in South Carolina.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War

Some transactions are more than strictly financial.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by logfromblammo on Monday December 29, 2014 @11:27AM (#8810396)
Sometimes the first bullet that flies is not the first shot of the war. Some scholars claim that the USA committed the first act of war well before the CSA opened fire on Ft. Sumter.

Obfuscating the adversarial acts that occurred before battle is joined is a choice made by historians. I recall my history teachers teaching about the Stamp Act and the Intolerable Acts prior to Lexington and Concord, but somehow Fort Sumter started the Civil War? That situation would be a lot like petitioning for divorce, getting the house in the settlement, and coming home that night to find that your ex-spouse was still living in the garden shed.

But I think it is safe to say that there were plenty of jerkfaces on both sides of the conflict, and they got a lot of good people killed, along with the bad. I can't say for certain what would have avoided the bloodshed, if anything, because we cannot A/B test history. I believe that war then was substantially similar to war now; it is usually a handful of people who stand to benefit, maneuvering other people into a false choice between losing and losing more. By the time the actual shooting starts, the bets have already been placed, and all that remains is to wait for the dice to stop rolling.

It's nice that slavery was abolished in the whole USA in the aftermath of the war, but on the whole, the UK way of doing it was much better. If the worst aftereffect they are feeling now is some outstanding 4% consols, that's hardly worrisome at all, compared to the lingering legacies of abolition in the US.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by dredmorbius on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @11:32PM (#8855007)
The deeper point is that the conflict wasn't strictly about property allocation, as was suggested by the comment I responded to. Instead it was a power play between two sets of states, not simply a matter of compensating former slave-owners. Which wasn't itself the nominal matter under discussion at the beginning of the Civil War in any regard (though the matter of slavery was in the offing, largely as pertained new states joining the Union).

I'm also not arguing the that the Civil War was the best way of settling the dispute. I will note that in the case of the UK

The point remains, however, that the Confederacy was the first aggressor.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by minot on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:02PM (#8808264)
> You mean to tell me that after the horrors of slavery finally ceased, it was the slaveholders that got reparations?

How would you have done things differently? The slave holders were powerful people. Even the Church of England apparently owned slaves. Compromise is a part of life. Yes, even difficult compromises like these...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by ajuc on Monday December 29, 2014 @07:06AM (#8809436)
The people that had slaves lost money because of the new law. They would have rioted and possible reverted the law if they got no compensation.

Law change is forever, compensation is short-term - of course it's worth it (that's one thing that paradox grand-strategy games taught me - never grant priviledges to provinces for gold ;) ).

BTW there's a lesson there - it shows how we should deal with the CO2 problem and global warming. Countries that industrialized recently won't stop becoming rich just because it's bad for someone else. We can try to make everybody pay, or we can compensate these that need coal industry the most (i.e. developing countries) to make them switch to better (and more expansive) alternatives.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by adolph on Monday December 29, 2014 @06:58AM (#8809417)
As a matter of historical fact, yes, see link below. As a matter of rhetorical response, wouldn't paying off whomever be worth ending the horrors of slavery? As a matter of imagining a counterfactual, what would the late 19th and 20th centuries have looked like in the US if it had somehow followed a similar route instead of embarking upon the Civil War?

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_Abolition_Act_1833

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by Brakenshire on Monday December 29, 2014 @06:13AM (#8809325)
That's one of the factors that damaged Haiti after its independence. In order to normalize trade relations, they had to accept debt at the market rate for the slaves who had been emancipated. This was many, many times their annual income and is probably a major reason why the country became a failed state.