News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by rsp1984 on Sunday December 28, 2014 @05:28PM (#8807715)
I wonder what the process is for paying back the Nominal. Surely Pound Sterlings in 1720 had an entirely different value than today (as has pretty much every other currency, in case Pounds was not the currency for this particular debt).
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by throwaway183839 on Sunday December 28, 2014 @05:35PM (#8807738)
Sure, pounds sterling had a different value in 1720 (although the question arises - a different value in comparison to what? The US dollar and the Euro didn't exist in 1720! You could take a set quantity of gold as your comparison, but the value of an oz of gold has fluctuated more than the value of a pound sterling over the same period).

However, it is all a bit immaterial. If the debt was denominated in pounds sterling, then it will be repaid in pounds sterling. If it was in guilders, then it will be repaid in guilders (or in sterling, at whatever the current nominal sterling/guilder exchange rate is).

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by dredmorbius on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:29AM (#8810128)
The question of how to compare prices over time is an interesting one in economics. There are a few answers which have been arrived at.

There's Angus Maddison's history of GDPs dating to the year 1.

Gregory Clark of UC Davis has compiled a price history of England dating from 1209 to 1914:

http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/gclark/papers/Agprice.pd...

Generally, there are commodities with fairly well-established prices and costs, including food and energy. In particular, food as a share of average wages is a reasonable proxy over time.

Another argument is that money should ultimately be considered to be backed in energy units, an idea I've traced to H.G. Wells and a 1914 short story. It appears subsequently in Arthur C. Clarke, R. Buckminster Fuller, and Kim Stanley Robinson's writings.

Clarke was quite the fan of Wells.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by mohanmcgeek on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:41AM (#8810186)
>The value of an oz of gold has fluctuated.

Compared to what? Other goods.

So, value of pounds is determined by its purchasing power

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by rtpg on Sunday December 28, 2014 @05:54PM (#8807789)
Debts are usually denominated in a currency, so if the nominal was 100 pounds, even if that used to be worth 100 times more before, that's what the government needs to pay.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by dredmorbius on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:33AM (#8810144)
Absent devaluations. I don't believe it's happened in England, but as an example, Russia re-based the Ruble in the 1990s following an inflationary period. The exchange was 1,000 old rubles per new ruble, in 1995, and/or 1998:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_ruble#Post-Soviet_rubl...

https://a248.e.akamai.net/7/1635/50139/1d/origin.nbclearn.co...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by bbcbasic on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:04PM (#8807970)
100 pounds (lb) of silver?
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by rtpg on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:52PM (#8808096)
I think it used to be pretty common to use metals instead of currencies to denote debts, for reasons mentioned in this thread.

I have a friend who once lent me money in one currency, but denoted the debt in "in X Euro or (X Euro in Yen at lend date), whichever is worth more", which I'm pretty sure is the best way to deal with inflation problems as a lender.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by bbcbasic on Sunday December 28, 2014 @11:34PM (#8808552)
Isn't it just priced into the interest rate?

What is interesting is the different types of 'lender'. Banks are lending money they create by fractional reserve, and will pay a lower interest on those deposits than the lent money, so they don't really care about inflation.

A wealthy individual investing in bonds would be a different prospect. But bond prices go up and down based on how the yield compares to interest rates. If I understand correctly lowering interest rates makes the bond worth more.

Any long term debt for 100's years ago is eroded by inflation but by the same token the lender probably profited from all the interest years ago, so the diminishing returns now are just some left over pocket money.

In reverse it is like a mortgage where you can go interest only and have a more modest mortgage in 10 years time, but I don't think that means the bank is the loser.

If you are going to lend money rather than putting excessive terms just factor the inflation risk into the interest rate, and diversify into other assets. Owning some shares, real estate or gold, or foreign currency bonds.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by bostonpete on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:53PM (#8808372)
> which I'm pretty sure is the best way to deal with inflation problems as a lender

Why stop at 2 currencies? Why not specify the debt in a large number of currencies that take the value at whichever is ultimately worth more? Of course this sort of hedging is good for the lender but it would be horrible for the borrower. I guess if you were desperate for the loan (or he was giving a really favorable rate) it's probably worth it, but I've never heard of a lender trying to hedge exchange rates in this way. But then again maybe I'm unaware of some of the games people have to play with other currencies since I mostly only have to deal with the dollar.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by eru on Sunday December 28, 2014 @10:45PM (#8808466)
You could denote your loan in Singaporean Dollar. Their central bank pegs the SGD to a basket of currencies, effectively giving you a similar hedge.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by zodiac on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:28AM (#8810123)
If you do so, you run the risk that in the future the Singapore dollar is no longer pegged to a basket of currencies.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by eru on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:40PM (#8813030)
You do. That's akin to counterparty risk. Depending on the time scale, this risk can go from miniscule to certainty.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by nl on Sunday December 28, 2014 @08:43PM (#8808221)
Currency exchange rates are not the same as (or even very closely correlated in the medium term to) inflation.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by toyg on Monday December 29, 2014 @08:03AM (#8809569)
Pound Sterling didn't evolve in a vacuum -- there are acts of Parliament regulating exchange rates with previous denominations; I expect they will be used, and have likely been used to pay out compounded interest until today, i.e. when the last Sterling reorganization happened (in the 70s? I can't remember), these debts were likely recalculated. It's not like the Bank of England is still issuing XVIII-century Pound Sterling just to pay interest on something.

One thing the United Kingdom of Great Britain really excels at, is continuity of government. It would be much more difficult for, say, Germany or France to deal with debts from 1720, considering they went through several revolutions and dissolutions and likely defaulted or simply ignored previous obligations at various points.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by omh on Sunday December 28, 2014 @06:31PM (#8807895)
Yes, they'll only get the nominal amount back.

Although there has been a huge amount of inflation since then you'd expect that the interest payments have more than made up for this.