News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by vlad on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @02:27AM (#880834)
First, Dropbox has not commented on why Dropbox.com redirects to them, nor about their lawsuit of the domain owner. Therefore, this is a horrible news article, with an assumption that Dropbox holds an new ownership stake in the domain.

Second, it's actually quite possible Dropbox asked the .com holders to forward traffic to the real site in order for both parties to value the domain's contribution to downloads/upsales from type-in traffic (is it 90% new users? Or almost always those who have an account?). This would mean TechCrunch hurts Dropbox by increasing their cost to buy/license the domain.

Third, we can't tell who owns the domain, so it could still be the same party! The .com could forward to the real site for just one day to tease Dropbox by sending it visitors for just one day. This also means they could point to the real site for a month, then a competitor later on after links start rolling in.

Finally, I don't think this owner, nor Justintv.com, are cybersquatters since they owned their domains since the 90's.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by dzohrob on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @04:25AM (#880948)
Evenflow owns dropbox.com now. Check http://whois.sc/dropbox.com .
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by vlad on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @07:59AM (#881133)
Yes, looks like the .com turned off Whois privacy, and Dropbox does own it now (most Whois services still point to Domains by Proxy, including when I checked). But since Dropbox didn't have a comment for TechCrunch on why the domain pointed to the real site while it was still privacy-protected, the headline of the article didn't make sense.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by invisible on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:02PM (#881669)
I would say putting ads and turning a profit by advertising competitors of the brand your domain is mimicking would be considered squatting a domain.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by slig on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:38PM (#881758)
It's the price you have to pay for choosing a brand name whose .com you don't own/can't buy.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by invisible on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @07:44PM (#882401)
Dealing with squatters is the price we as web developers/entrepreneurs must pay? If domain names actually required a registered business to purchase a domain name that'd make perfect sense. Unfortunately I could go buy sligenterprises.com and you'd be out of luck if that's what your product was best represented as (except for suing me). I'd amount it to putting up a big ass sign, waiting for someone to also use a similar name, then you change the sign to have a competitor's phone number beneath the name. How is the legalese in that "you are screwed?"
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by slig on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:58PM (#882663)
I agree with you, but in this case the original owner wasn't a squatter.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by anurag on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:31PM (#880626)
From the PDF:

"21. Plaintiff has expended considerable time and effort promoting and advertising Dropbox, using DROPBOX as its brand name. To date, Plaintiff has spent in excess of $1 million dollars marketing the DROPBOX brand."

They have $1.5m in funding (according to CrunchBase), and they've spent over a million dollars on marketing already? There has to be an interesting story in there somewhere.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by harpastum on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:52PM (#880655)
Seems like a pretty large number, but remember, funding isn't dropbox's only source of income.

In addition, depending on the definition of 'marketing' (IANAL), the referral engine (i.e. free space for referring other users), might count as marketing the dropbox brand, and the 'value' of the free space would likely count as the amount customers would have to pay, not the cost to dropbox.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by panic on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @10:41PM (#880540)
It's worth mentioning that the first hit for "dropbox.com" on Google is the actual site, "getdropbox.com". Many people navigate to a site by googling its URL then clicking the first link.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by dugmartin on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:10AM (#881315)
When I was at Britannica in the late 90s our #1 search term was "yahoo.com" and #2 was "sex".
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by eli on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:15PM (#880600)
I doubt most people navigate that way. Sure, plenty of browsers will do a google search from the address bar but only if what you've typed doesn't resolve on its own.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by blasdel on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:21PM (#880608)
You'd be surprised how far normal users will go out of their way to avoid the address box, often using comically complex routines.

Google is much more trustworthy than DNS -- it's essentially content-addressed.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by kyro on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:25PM (#880617)
Reminds me of the time I searched for 'Google' using my browser's Google search, and then clicked on the first result to get to Google to search for what I was looking for...
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by stcredzero on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:52PM (#880654)
Makes me wonder what a Google Search for "Google Search" will yield? Is that a new kind of Quine? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quine_(computing))

Chuck Norris is the 3rd item!

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by dminor on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:08PM (#881562)
Visits on our site over the last month were 14% direct, 5.7% searching for our name, according to GA.

If you are unsure of the domain name, Google is definitely the more trustworthy option.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by indranil on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @03:14PM (#881942)
I do that all the time! Any site whose domain name I can't remember totally, or rather, any site I'm visiting by putting in the domain name, I use google.

That way, I get an extra layer of protection of scams and what-nots. Well worth the extra click or two.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by theklub on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @07:49AM (#881121)
The same "normal" users that are using dropbox in mass? Doubt it.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by there on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:30PM (#880624)
here's a related story that i am reminded of: i had a customer complain that a survey form on their site was occasionally not working, according to their customers, which they learned by those customers filling out a feedback form on the company's site which then sent them an e-mail. this survey form was a special url that was printed on receipts they gave to customers.

after looking in the server logs and finding nothing strange that would explain why the survey is only occasionally not working (i still didn't have a concrete definition of what "not working" meant), i had the company talk to one of their customers to get more information. he forwarded me the feedback email generated from their website, which included the end user's ip, which i then looked in the logs for.

what i found was that the way the user got to the company's feedback page was by typing "www.theirdomain.com" into yahoo search, clicking on the first result, and then going to the feedback link from their site (the referrer of their initial visit was a search.yahoo.com query for the domain). only after typing "www.theirdomain.com/survey" into yahoo's search box, did i discover the root of the problem.

for whatever reason, yahoo wasn't returning any results for the specific "www.theirdomain.com/survey" query, despite the page being there for years and having proof of yahoo crawling the url many times in the logs. google would bring it up as the first result, as did every other search engine, but for some reason yahoo would just return a "couldn't find anything matching that" error, which the end user translated into "your company's survey page doesn't work". after telling the specific user to type the survey url into the box "at the top of the screen", it of course worked. every other customer complaining about the problem was doing the same thing, all because of yahoo.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by lyime on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:27AM (#880695)
Yea you'd be surprised. When I look at Mugasha's organic traffic. The number keyword for search is Mugasha or mugasha.com.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @08:02AM (#881135)
If you thought it's easy to get to Google, think again. In our current round of usability research, only 76% of users who expressed a desire to run a Google search were successful. http://www.useit.com/alertbox/designer-user-differences.html
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by tdm911 on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:28AM (#880698)
I frequently see users type www.microsoft.com or similar into Google. I think people see Google as their address bar, as generally it's set as the home page.

Asking a user what the address in the address box/bar is often ends with a blank expression on their face!

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by petercooper on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:08AM (#881311)
I've been using the Web for 14 years and I do it from time to time too! Once you're in the search box anyway, it's more hassle to correct yourself than just search for the domain you wanted :)
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by peterlai on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:06PM (#880580)
At MIT's Startup Bootcamp, Kyle noted a similar squatter on http://justintv.com/.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by vlad on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @02:31AM (#880838)
If so, then News.com is very succesfully cybersquatting Hacker News, in the same way.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by buugs on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:33PM (#881748)
I think this would be more like if someone else owned bitly.com and raised the price to 400,000 when everyone started using bit.ly
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by willwagner on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:12AM (#880749)
FWIW, I was trying to find out what the site looked like before this kerfuffle. I only found this:

http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://dropbox.com

which doesn't show too much except for some godaddy.com domain parking.

If it was just a domain parked while the guy was trying to figure out what he wanted to do with it, I'm not so excited about the outcome. If it was misleading site pretending to be getdropbox.com, then that's a whole other story.

There really needs to be a better system for domain name registration. I'm all for inexpensive domain names but perhaps there should be some sort of waiting list, and if people are on the waiting list, the renewal fees get raised by a set amount each year (perhaps capped at something like 25%) as long as there was a waiting list. Once the person doesn't renew, the first person on the waiting list gets it but they get charged at the new rate.

In that way, you couldn't just squat on a domain without doing something with it and eventually there would be a fair market price for it. If no one wanted it, the price for the domain would stay low.

There is probably still some gaming in a system like that but at least it would encourage more turnover of unused domains, which would be a good thing.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by ars on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:28AM (#880765)
When I saw it (not long ago), it was a completely empty page with a google header.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by xelfer on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @03:45AM (#880907)
The page with the google header is what I saw 2 days ago.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by ujjwalg on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:02PM (#880572)
It is unrelated to this post but, dropbox rocks. I have tried 4 different file sharing services but dropbox simplicity and efficiency beats them all.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by kyro on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:16PM (#880602)
Haha. You know, this must really be an amazing company. I have never used the product myself, but every time a post about Dropbox comes around, there are always at least a few comments of people just wanting to mention how much they love it, regardless of the actual submission topic.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by lupin_sansei on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:39PM (#880632)
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by kyro on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:09AM (#880678)
Wow, lots of really cool uses there. I like the torrenting one in particular.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by elblanco on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:53PM (#880656)
It really is an amazing product.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by furriner on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:11AM (#881317)
I wonder if this service is only available to US companies? If my foreign company registers a trademark in my own country then finds a website that was registered 9years ago will the US court force them to hand over the .com domain?
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by lutorm on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:51PM (#882654)
I think the key is the trademark confusion part. If you have a domain name that was registered a long time ago and then realize that it's a name for some successful business and then start to use your domain name for something related, then you are guilty of trademark infringement. If on the other hand you've been running a business since before the other one started, then it's they who are guilty of infringement. If you own ibm.com for your business "Indiana Boomerang Manufacturing, Inc.", IBM can't really push the trademark infringement allegation because the risk of confusion is small. That's at least my understanding of how trademarks work.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by jpeterson on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @01:02AM (#880736)
So will dropbox.com redirect to getdropbox.com in perpetuity, or will you guys eventually migrate over to the new domain?
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by spicyj on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @10:36PM (#880535)
I don't know who this "everyone" is who thought they owned the domain. I certainly noticed before I signed up that they used a different domain.

That said, it's excellent that they get the domain that they deserve, which will undoubtedly increase traffic and profit for the company.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by timdorr on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:04PM (#880574)
I'll admit that I fell for the wrong domain before.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by blasdel on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:17PM (#880604)
I was just noticing earlier today how clumsy a dl.getdropbox.com/u/00000/file URL looks

Feels weird being exhorted to "Get Dropbox" when I already using one...

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by staunch on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @10:48PM (#880552)
Like TheFacebook.com -> Facebook.com. Now we just have to wait for the $150+ million acquisition from HP or EMC.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by vaksel on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:01PM (#880571)
so how much did you guys ended up paying(or was it free?)...or is this some huge corporate secret
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by eli on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:14PM (#880598)
Sucks that it took lawyers, but good for them
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by greendestiny on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:37PM (#880630)
Seems like the guy initially registered dropbox.com before anyone had heard of it, not sure I think its a great thing. Surely you just call your company something that you can get domain for. Well whatever really, I love dropbox and this guy was just leeching off them.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by pingswept on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:54PM (#880658)
I met Drew, one of the founders of Dropbox, a few years ago at Barcamp Boston. If I remember it right, he said that the initial dropbox.com owner was just some random dude who was planning on starting some sort of venture related to dropboxes, hadn't done it yet, but didn't want to sell. My impression was that he got the domain some time before Dropbox launched, and at least initially, he wasn't doing anything particularly irritating other than letting a short domain name languish (not that bad, in the big picture).

From the PDF in the link, it sounds like the original owner then transferred the domain to a third party, who then ran ads for Dropbox's competitors, leading to the legal wrangling.

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by greendestiny on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:12AM (#880682)
More or less the opinion I got from it, although the third party seems more like a service the guy used. The guy was clearly using Dropbox and its brand name for his gain, but I can't easily get behind this as good thing when he had domain name first and legitimately. If he went ahead and made a company of his own called dropbox he might well have been fine, who knows. Just felt compelled to comment because the anger directed at the guy seems a bit unfair - it was Dropboxes choice to start a company up called that when they knew they someone else owned the domain.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by lutorm on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:55PM (#882661)
He probably would have been fine if his business was airdropping goods or something else that can be construed as "dropbox" but in a realm sufficiently different from file syncing. He certainly couldn't have started a file syncing company called dropbox, that seems like obvious trademark infringement. Mere registration of a domain doesn't create a trademark.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by pingswept on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @08:08PM (#882429)
Yeah, that seems about right to me. Still, I wish the guy would have just sold the domain if he wasn't going to do anything useful with it.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by terrellm on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:27PM (#880622)
It was still probably cheaper to get the lawyers involved than buying it on the open market or public auction.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by mattmaroon on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:20PM (#880607)
My offer to break that guy's knees from summer 2007 still stands.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by slig on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @12:33AM (#880706)
Why so much rage? The original owner registered the domain first.

note that I don't like squatters either, but who can tell that he wasn't legitimate when he registered it first?

Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by dkersten on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @04:05AM (#880926)
Not to mention that he registered it in the 90's! How does that possibly count as squatting?
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by mattmaroon on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @11:26AM (#881472)
It was a joke from our summer session. There was a lot of annoyance over the domain even then. I didn't expect many people to get it.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by petercooper on Wednesday October 14, 2009 @10:10AM (#881316)
You won't need to do that to screw up his life. The lawsuit is calling for $100k in damages minimum. If he's as poor as most of us here, that'll mess him up for a while.
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by bjclark on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:12PM (#880592)
I thought google just bought dropbox.com? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=857101
Re:Dropbox Acquires The Domain Everyone Thought It Had: Drop... by mbrubeck on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @11:14PM (#880596)
The domain owner had set the DNS to point to the Google App Engine servers. Google was never directly involved.