I watched the whole video, and I'm not impressed. Same old 'no true Scotsmen' crap that is epidemic to Agile. Yes, in almost 15 years, we are all still failing Agile instead of the other way around. Only now, it's gotten so bad it needs a new name. What he should realize that he doesn't like is complexity. If you have more than a thousand developers working together across multiple related product lines with various marketing, sales, and development dependencies then the 12 original principles and $2 will get you a bottle of soda. He shouldn't be mocking Agile in the Enterprise, he should be trying to figure out what is wrong/missing in Agile that causes it to become so pathological at scale.
As we learned with the Apollo Guidance Computer [0] and Shuttle computer systems development [1], the methodologies were not strictly waterfall. I'd like to do some more research in historical engineering techniques. I am not convinced that waterfall has had a much sway as the industry makes out.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Hamilton_(scientist)
[1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iterative_and_incremental_dev...
Now, that said, Agile is fairly new as software engineering goes. It isn't that young of a field.. waterfall put man on the moon, after all. Agile particularly speaks to how one can remain somewhat stable while optimizing for velocity, and is particularly well suited for the type of businesses that have dominated the last 10-15 years: self hosted consumer applications or SaaS. The key to choosing a process is to understand what you are trying to optimize for and what sort of release process your project requires. Agile, for example, might not be the best solution for gamma knife firmware or embedded systems in cars. To give him the benefit of the doubt, perhaps he's reached the age of reflection and trying to emphasize that everyone should step back and consider their goals, and reevaluate their strategies in light of those goals. [edit: and understand a lot of people are lazy and/or risk-averse, and would prefer to think that there is a magic best practice, that if applied hard enough, will work for everything]