News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by StillBored on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @03:25AM (#8792089)
I blame my own personal loss of time partially on long commutes. Previously, I lived about ~8 minutes away from where I worked. Now I live about ~40 minutes (which is only about 12 miles) from work. So, that works out to ~5.3 extra hours a week I lose sitting in my car. Or about 6.5 work weeks of time a year. With that time, I could be teaching the kids something, learning a new skill, exercising, working on my own projects, or just relaxing.

Think about how much work you can get done in 6 weeks at work. That is what is being lost because I live in a state/city that puts infrastructure projects near the bottom of the priority list.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by roel_v on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:07AM (#8792421)
"That is what is being lost because I live in a state/city that puts infrastructure projects near the bottom of the priority list."

I'm not belittling your problem or saying that it's your own fault or anything, and it's empirically true that that short commutes contribute significantly to QoL, but more or better infrastructure is not (should not be) the goal. The mantra (which has become the norm in transportation research, to a lesser degree in professional transportation planning circles and only to a small degree in policy circles) is 'we don't need better mobility, we need better accessibility'.

To make this more concrete, you don't need better roads, you need better jobs close to your home. But you'll only get these once this becomes the common sentiment and people start voting with their feet. Because what you're doing now (take better job in exchange for worse commute) only makes the overall situation worse - more people competing for jobs in central locations, and/or people trading bigger houses further away for a longer commute.

A lot of work is being started (in Europe, I know little details of efforts elsewhere but from the current literature it seems this is a global trend) on getting people to change their sentiments on transport and home/work location. It will take a number of years for the first effects to show of course. Just spatial planning policy interventions take 10 years to become active, let alone for their effects to be significant.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by twelvechairs on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:02AM (#8792679)
European countries have been fighting to keep their polycentralism for at least a century but it hasn't stopped them becoming more monocentric (both within cities and in comparing cities themselves) than ever today. There is a continued trend in the west for jobs to want to be located in centres, particularly as most white collar jobs want physical access both to other workers and to government buildings (courthouses, politicians, central govt offices, etc). None of this shows much sign of abatement.

The big trends to deal with this now are improving transport (which you argue against), moving people into dense centres (which you seem tacitly against) and remote working (which is a trend in tech but hasn't taken off in any other industry).

There is little to suggest that smaller centres will be the focus of future economic activity, though I'd be interested in your sources. this is my field as an urban deisgner by the way

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by roel_v on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:03AM (#8793047)
While I understand how you can understand that from my post, the stream-of-consciousness style of posting on websites muddled my points:

- I see as the only long-term sustainable trend for much more people to move into smaller, much more densely populated areas - megacities. But there are no (not yet) facts that corroborate this claim, although more people in my field and adjacent fields are at least informally starting to share this idea. Not that it's very relevant what the objective situation is - many people feel cities are Bad and think we need to move away from them. And politics follows popular opinion, on macro topics like this.

- 'Accessibility' is not just 'smaller centres'. Without wanting to get into the debate over which of the 5000 definitions is the 'right' one, what I meant was that thinking of time it takes to get to different places in terms of 'we need to increase rush hour capacity so that I can get to work faster' is (apologies to the GP, not meant personally) stupid. The congestion-decreasing effect of adding a lane on a main artery lasts, give or take a few years, 5 years. After that, people have adapted to the new circumstances - i.e. bought houses further away from where they work, because it's cheaper there (in the first years after the intervention) and thereby made the problem worse.

- I disagree with your assertion that the trend to build more and wider roads and more public transport are a way to deal with concentration of economic activity on less area. Moving people into dense centres is, but 'improving transport' is (imo) a band aid to deal with negative externalities of densification - i.e. rising house prices, lagged upgrades of amenities in areas that increase in density, etc. Said in a less roundabout, academic and cautious way: politician build more roads to deal with constituents bitching about not being able to buy a detached house with 10 ares of lawn for their children to play on in the area where I work, and look there are plenty of houses in that shithole farm town over there, just build a road and I'll vote for you.

I'm not quite sure any more where exactly I'm going with this to be honest, just wanted to say that the solution to transportation issues is not 'build more roads' but 'create an environment in which people will naturally need to travel less'. But building roads is easier, of course.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by twelvechairs on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:31AM (#8793141)
I see your point now more.

I agree on roads being a band aid and pushing people further out, which if it continues requires exponential additions to roadways, which is impossible. Metro rail, on the other hand, is a different thing in allowing accessibility across the dense centre. The most effective 'acessibility' I can see is rail stations as the focal points of density.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by galfarragem on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:04AM (#8792858)
Good to know that I'm not the only architect in HN. I completely agree with you.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by humanrebar on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:10AM (#8792708)
> we need better accessibility

So why aren't more localities actually innovating around this principle instead of blaming their constituents?

Off the top of my head:

* Encourage telecommuting

* Encourage flexible work schedules

* Encourage new product delivery systems: delivery groceries, delivery laundry, Seamless, Uber, etc.

* Hold employers accountable for commute times, especially in the absence of telecommuting and flexible work schedules

* Make employers accountable for reassigning employees (you're working across town now, but it's still within driving distance, so no relocation benefits)

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by prostoalex on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:09AM (#8793288)
Because localities don't make money on accessibility, they make money on property and commercial taxes, which encourages build-out and real estate development of anything that's left untouched.

Better accessibility (and higher density) would also mean a leaner city services staff needed to service it all, so it's understandable a municipal bureaucracy is not going to be the prime advocate of that.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by nickik on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:44PM (#8793985)
We should start by chaing laber market laws that pushe everybody into the traditional work day schedule.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by johnchristopher on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:11AM (#8792427)
> A lot of work is being started (in Europe, I know little details of efforts elsewhere but from the current literature it seems this is a global trend) on getting people to change their sentiments on transport and home/work location.

European here. Could you point to some ressources on that work being started in Europe ?

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by roel_v on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:28AM (#8792925)
Well when I mean 'work', I mean that in the research sense (since for me that's 'work' :) ), and what I see and hear on conferences and symposiums, so I don't have any easy links. There are some FP7 projects that worked on this (search e.g. the Urbact websites, the FP7 website under transportation and sustainability themes, the Interreg website under the respective themes etc) and there are also many calls in Horizon 2020 that cover these aspects. There were some calls in the past in ICT subjects with open submissions that were won by projects working on crowd-sourcing and serious gaming applications that also covered this subject.

Furthermore (and again without having anything concrete at hand), there are regularly articles that cover aspects of this in the usual journals: European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research, Transportation, Transportation Journal, Transportation Science etc.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by lucaspiller on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:44AM (#8792976)
The idea of a 'business park' [0] seems like it could solve these problems, but the only examples I've seen (in the UK) are dull and lifeless blobs of concrete in the middle of nowhere.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_park

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by simonh on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:05AM (#8792417)
And you're falling into exactly the trap the article is talking about. Worrying about the cost of all that time spent in the car, when you could be thanking your lucky stars you have that extra time to yourself.

My commute is 1 hour each way and it's wonderful. Having a busy job and 2 kids means I have a lot to do at work and at home, but those 2 hors a day are entirely my own.

Mostly I listen to podcasts and audiobooks, but I also carry an iPad and read on that when I get a seat on the train. It's a great opportunity to listen to novels, history and science podcasts, comedy shows or read material I wouldn't get a chance to otherwise. Podcasts and audiobooks are perfect for car journeys too though.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by izolate on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:56AM (#8793020)
> but those 2 hours a day are entirely my own.

You haven't tasted freedom, my friend. Commuting hours are enslaved hours. I have the fortune of a 15 minute bike ride to work. The extra hours in my week can be spent in any old direction, not just listening to podcasts. I can go to the bank, sit in a coffee shop, play some guitar, whatever.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by nickik on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:14PM (#8793840)
I commute more then 2h a day. Honstly I dont mind because it means I can live where I want to live.

Its not lost time, I spend 1h on day on Hacker News and Reddit anyway. I would do the exact same thing at home. Im writting this comment from the train. I also have my personal media collection, a book, a kindle and my laptop.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by rifung on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @05:29PM (#8794754)
I think you are fortunate to be able to do things you enjoy while commuting. If you had to drive to work and sit through terrible traffic, things might not be as nice unfortunately. I have more recently been taking the bus but I still can't really read on it because I get dizzy..
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by falcor84 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:18AM (#8792577)
Well, that's the difference between having a good public transport option and driving. I hope that it won't be too long until self-driving cars solve this problem.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by Dewie on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:22AM (#8792911)
> Well, that's the difference between having a good public transport option and driving.

Why? He listens to podcasts and audiobooks, something which can be done while driving.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by pixl97 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:12AM (#8793076)
No. Not exactly. You cannot both focus on the radio and driving at the same time with the equal amount of attention that a person who is just listen to audio while passively riding. It is not possible. Driving is not just visual clues, it is audio. Are my tires making the correct noise? Am I being honked at? Is that a siren I hear? Does the feedback from the road tell me about any dangerous conditions the road my present?

There were over 30,000 traffic deaths in 2012. Over 5,000,000 automobile accidents. Yes, listening to audio while driving can be enjoyable, but it is a secondary task to not dying or not killing someone else.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by Dewie on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:56AM (#8793232)
> Are my tires making the correct noise?

Seriously? You have to spend a lot of time worrying about stuff like that?

If you're stuck in a crawling rush hour commute, your only concern might be to not rear-end the car in front of you. Commutes in general are often described as being boring and routine, not something that you have to have your senses heightened in order to escape from with your life: think about driving along the highway for 15 minutes, straight ahead.

> Yes, listening to audio while driving can be enjoyable, but it is a secondary task to not dying or not killing someone else.

Of course, the usual fearmongering. We're talking about listening to audiobooks, not blasting techno or death metal at obscene volumes so that you can't hear your surroundings. Driving a car is a pretty routine task which, while we should always have respect for the terrible destructive power it has, being constantly worried about everything that might possibly go wrong is just going to sizzle our nerves. Just being alert and present in the moment is sufficient for a lot of routine driving.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by okatsu on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:54PM (#8794041)
I think it depends on the individual; I know I can't drive and pay attention to the radio or an audiobook at the same time. I could easily miss a red light.

And sure, commutes are routine, but you're not driving with the same people every day under the same conditions. I've lost count of the times I had to evade someone doing something stupid.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by ggambetta on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:52AM (#8792827)
I wrote a novel and three feature-length screenplays commuting in Swiss trains. Now I'm in London and my commute is slightly shorter but not as useful :(
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by s_husso on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:57PM (#8793754)
> "My commute is 1 hour each way and it's wonderful."

I agree. My commute used to be 20min each way with car, but now I take the train which means my commute went up to 50min each way. When commuting with the car I somehow couldn't get myself around to reading or learning new things when arriving home, even though I had the 1h/day more time on my hands. I tried different things but none of them seemed to stick, so then I just thought to myself screw it, I'll take the train and the longer commute. Haven't regretted that decision one bit.

Couple of positive things I've noticed after taking the train. I'm more productive in the office as I get things rolling already on my commute (note that I don't do any work stuff on my commute) and if I've had productive day at the office I'm productive on the commute back, which leads I also get things done at home :) Also as the commute time is timeboxed I don't muck about so I'm focused on the task at hand. I usually switch between reading/coding/learning depending on the mood of the day.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by mariusandreiana on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:24AM (#8792749)
What science podcasts could you recommend? Thanks
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by alex_anglin on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:48AM (#8792818)
I recommend Quirks & Quarks[1]. It's been on the air in Canada for a long time and has a big back catalog as a result.

[1]http://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by afoot on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @04:51AM (#8792290)
This is what regularly makes my 8-9 hour day a 12 hour one.

People who live close to the office manage to cook nice meals, exercise, spend time with family etc all while I'm commuting.

The most I manage is replying to a few emails and listening to podcasts while standing up on the train with carriage after carriage of commuters.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by jzwinck on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @03:57AM (#8792170)
> That is what is being lost because I live in a state/city that puts infrastructure projects near the bottom of the priority list.

Isn't it rather because you choose to live 12 miles from work?

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by sliverstorm on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @04:06AM (#8792189)
Well, you must make these choices in the context of your city, but 12 miles would not be a big deal with, for example, a subway or lightrail.

Living right by work is optimal, but not always practical, so the runner-up of solid transit is a good alternative.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @05:15AM (#8792336)
> 12 miles would not be a big deal with, for example, a subway or lightrail

That's not true at all.

I'm from London, which has a pretty extensive subway system (we call it the tube). The only way you'll do a 12 mile* tube journey in 40 minutes in London is if you (i) live and work on the same subway line, and (ii) have <2 minutes' walk at each end. This is not true for 99% of people.

Sure, you could build more tube stations at great expense, to reduce the walking time, but more stops means more time stopped, which means more time spent in the tube.

I've lived in Beijing and Shanghai, and what I've written above, in reference to London, applies almost equally in those two cities.

*When I say '12 mile' above, I'm talking about the equivalent journey by road, not the 'as the crow flies' distance between two points, nor the distance the tube train travels.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by mattmanser on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:58AM (#8792525)
The worst part of this as well is that my city, Nottingham, and also the whole of England, changed to a "spokes on a wheel" method of organising public transport. This is where they have all public transport go to a central hub, rather than organising around transport demands and having direct buses from residential to industrial areas or cross country trains.

So you always have to go into a hub (city center in Nottingham, London in England), and then walk & wait around for a new bus/train (or tube from station to station in London).

This significantly increases journey times to anywhere that's not the hub. Also the assholes charge £20 more for having the gall to go through London, even though that's precisely how they set the system up. So now to get to my home town I either have to get 4 trains outside of London, or 2 and a tube through London.

It's more economical and profitable for the bus/train companies, but costs everyone not going to the central hub a lot of time.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by lmm on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @05:44AM (#8792386)
To give a concrete example, my commute in London is 5 miles and 50 minutes - 10 minutes' walk to the station, 25 mins on the train, and 15 minutes walking to work. (Cycling is a little quicker, but still in the 40 minute region).
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by ido on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:12AM (#8792560)
My commute in Berlin would have been 4.7 miles if done by car & takes me ~30-35 minutes by subway (including ~10 minutes walk), so a little bit better but not much.

I would have liked going down to ~20 minutes but beyond that it's entering into diminishing returns territory & I'd much rather work fewer hours and/or from home instead.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by a2tech on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:07AM (#8793279)
That sucks-I regularly make a 45 mile trip into a contracting job and I can be there in ~40 minutes (its +10 minutes at rush hour time). This is into a major metropolitan area in the US. And I do it in my own car-comfortable, quiet, and I listen to my podcasts. Its probably my favorite part of the day.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by sliverstorm on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:31PM (#8793917)
Darn, I must have an overly rosy memory of my short time in the NY subways & on light rails. It has been many years.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by alchemism on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @02:21PM (#8794174)
To be fair, NYC's subway system is not a hub-and-spoke system, it is a true network of rail lines. Practically a matrix. One of the finest in the world.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:11AM (#8792555)
I live and work on line 10 in Beijing, and I still save a lot of ti e by taking the taxi, even with traffic.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:32PM (#8795318)
And line 10 is one of the newer/nicer lines.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by rab_oof on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:07AM (#8793059)
It's hard to get from Bromley to Victoria in 45 minutes.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by BerislavLopac on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @05:08AM (#8792324)
If more people were allowed (and enabled) to work from home, that would help mitigate that issue heavily.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by snarfy on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:21AM (#8792742)
More like he was priced out of living any closer to work.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by radicalbyte on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @03:38AM (#8792123)
I've just quit a job that is 40mins driving for one which is 10mins drive or 20mins cycle. I'm going to cycle.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by anton-107 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:49AM (#8792511)
My office is 40mins cycling away - that's the best!
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by lordbusiness on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @06:00AM (#8792408)
This right here is my strongest motivator for embracing remote working. Reclaiming these hours has been the single most liberating and uplifting thing I've done in the pursuit of the oft promoted but rarely implemented work-life balance.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by smu on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:14AM (#8792568)
Depending on your personal situation and goals, cycling to work could be a solution. 12 miles works out to 20km, which for me would amount to less than an hour of cycling time with good equipment. As a bonus, you'll arrive home with an empty head and you'll already have exercised!
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:17AM (#8792573)
Depends if cycling is practical. Many places don't have the weather, topology, or traffic for it. It would frustrating and bad for my health (pollution) to cycle to work in my current city (beijing) while I did nothing but in my previous coy (Lausanne, even with the hills).
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by zhte415 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:55AM (#8792833)
I do not want to sound flippant, just really practical, as I'm also in China (not Beijing) but sometimes have a somewhat long commute. Would it be possible to have a conversation =to argue time in the taxi, with laptop open and on a mobile connection was morning emailing time, and get the taxi charged to the company if it is a regular thing.

I just do shift based on core hours I need to be in the office, as does everyone in the company.

Re:Why is everyone so busy? by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:03PM (#8793786)
My company doesn't reimburse taxi fare, I just see it as worth the cost. I do shift my hours to make it worse, but line 10 is so crowded during peak, I'd have to anyways.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by eliben on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:09PM (#8793523)
YMMV, but I find that audio-books and audio-courses are a superb way to make an otherwise boring commute more tolerable. I hate commuting as much as anyone, and thankfully my commute isn't long, but even then, it's much more fun "reading" a book while sitting in the car.
Re:Why is everyone so busy? by kirk21 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:42PM (#8793687)
Buy audiobooks :)