Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by jordonwii on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:43AM
(#8787076)
That sounds plausible to me. Apparently, even things like exhaust from another car in cold weather can interact with the laser in a way such that the car can mistake it for a large object directly in front of the vehicle.
Source: tech talk at my university by a self-driving car engineer.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by eru on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:54PM
(#8786238)
Not pigeons right in front. But the driverless car often sees dangerous spots (like debris on the road, or an accident site) before any human can see. So they might stop or slow down earlier.
(I think I learned that in one of the tech talk videos about it.)
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by justincormack on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @06:23AM
(#8787718)
Well I guess we wont get these in Europe (due to rain) but there are lots of cars that look like that here already.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by iandanforth on Monday December 22, 2014 @09:06PM
(#8786471)
Plastic bags actually. A plastic bag looks pretty solid to most sensors and cars have been known stop suddenly when one flies in front of the car.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by kuboa on Monday December 22, 2014 @09:38PM
(#8786551)
And they should stop, and err on the side of caution. An anecdotal digression, if you'll allow me: I'll never forget the time when a plastic bag was gently flitting across the highway a friend and I was traveling on, in that nonchalant manner plastic bags usually do, and how we, not giving it even a second thought, drove right through it... Except we couldn't, since it turned out there was actually a small picnic-type propane tank inside the bag, rolling on the asphalt, and our car's motor was totaled by the impact, though thankfully we didn't suffer any serious injuries.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by sitkack on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @02:50AM
(#8787228)
This is why you never run over anything in a car. Ever.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by cgriswald on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:56AM
(#8787362)
No, they shouldn't. I'm glad you weren't hurt, but your freak accident aside, most plastic bags are just plastic bags and human drivers are not expecting vehicles to yield to them. (There is also a difference between a plastic bag moving on the ground and one flying around.) If we are erring on the side of caution we shouldn't be creating a more probable hazard to avoid a less probable one.
And if we remove humans entirely from the equation what we get is traffic that comes to a stop because none of the vehicles can avoid or get past the plastic bag which floats around more-or-less randomly.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by betenoire on Monday December 22, 2014 @06:04PM
(#8785808)
oh I sure hope it takes more than a pigeon, but I see your point
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype
by JoshTriplett on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:37PM
(#8786178)
I hope it doesn't; consider the PR disaster that'll happen the first time a driverless car hits poor little Fluffy the cat. Nevermind that cars with drivers do that all the time.
Moreover, I think Google wants their car to be recognizable as a driverless car. They don't want it to blend in, because people would (at least for now) think that was "spooky"—that any car anywhere around them could be being secretly driven by a robot.
Instead, the visual distinctness means that it's instantly clear that these are their own thing, in much the same way that golf carts, scooters, and backhoes are—despite all being wheeled vehicles that can be driven in car lanes—their own thing. Because they're recognizable, it makes it possible for you to build a separate autonomous response into your subliminal "driving event loop" for the class of "driverless car", the same way that you will react separately to seeing any of the above in your lane. Which is exactly what people want, in order to feel in control: the ability to notice and compensate for the driverless cars around them if they all encounter some pathological edge-case.
(Just as an example of what I'm talking about—and this is a completely untested hypothesis on my part—I bet that driverless cars come to a complete stop a lot more frequently, in surprising places, because their sensors tell them something is standing in front of the car—e.g. a pigeon. A regular driver knows a pigeon will just sit there minding its own business as the car approaches it, but fly away right before the impact would happen; a driverless car might not know that. Because of this, your driving algorithm for being behind a driverless car will likely have a component similar to driving behind a school bus: "this vehicle makes frequent sudden stops, and I need to be ready to stop too. I should be more car-lengths away from it than are strictly necessary.")