Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by muaddirac on Monday December 22, 2014 @06:00PM
(#8785792)
It's pretty interesting to see this in picture form, but it wasn't a big secret that you could eat a days worth of calories in a single meal in most chain restaurants.
The comparison to home-cooked at the end is a little ridiculous. A 22oz steak will be a lot of calories whether you cook it at home or have it at a restaurant. They intentionally picked healthier options for the home meal, and always included large sugared drinks or milkshakes with the fast food options. It would be interesting to see the same article, but comparing each individual meal at a restaurant with a home-cooked version of the same meal (and I'd imagine you'd mostly be shaving off a couple hundred calories unless you're really messing with the ingredients.)
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by dack on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @08:29AM
(#8788011)
I agree with you it's a bit misleading - they do make it seem like "home cooked food" inherently has less calories when it obviously doesn't.
I think the real point they were trying to make was that when you are actually cooking your food, you are more conscious of what you're eating and therefore more likely to choose lower calorie/healthier options.
However, I am not sure I really agree with them. I can make a giant plate of spaghetti at home or eat several peanut butter sandwiches really easily - burning through 2000 calories without paying attention. And since some restaurants have calorie counts on their meals anyway - it's pretty easy for me to choose that if I want to be on a diet.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by lanna on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @11:04AM
(#8788646)
I do not think the comparison is totally unfair. They are not comparing "similar meals", they are comparing "typical meals", what you would actually eat at a restaurant vs. what you eat at home. It is not just the cooking.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by army on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:05PM
(#8786044)
"It is possible to eat healthier at each chain. You can ... order from the “Skinnys” menu at Potbelly, which has sandwiches with fewer than 400 calories."
Or you could skip the chips, cookie or drink, or order the regular size (not the big size). Or have a different sandwich from the Italian, which has the highest calorie content of all the sandwiches on the menu. It's not rocket science.
Honestly I expect a little better than such a blatant false dichotomy from the article.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by auganov on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @04:46AM
(#8787484)
Would be so much more valuable if they'd show the difference between the most and least calorie-dense choices at the same restaurant. That way you'd actually help people make better choices. It comes across as poor propaganda (and is?) with their assumption that people will automagically choose calorie-sparse meals at home.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by DKnoll on Monday December 22, 2014 @06:52PM
(#8785986)
1. Why would you base this around a single meal, when ideally your daily caloric intake would be spread throughout your waking hours.
2. Even suggesting that most people need 2000 calories is wildly dangerous as this is a figure that will vary for EVERY individual. I myself need ~3000 calories just to maintain a healthy weight.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by kenrikm on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:15PM
(#8786082)
1) Show the worst food at Restaurants
2) Show Healthy food from home
Profit?
Talk about manipulating the facts to get the end result. Why would I drink diet soda at home but always order regular at a restaurant? because that's the only way to get the "oh wow" factor for the photos.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by claystu on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @09:07AM
(#8788126)
I disagree...the restaurant pictures show what I see people typically order...or darn close. Obviously, they have big menus and if you want, you can go to a fast food restaurant and order nothing but green salad, but I don't see many people doing that.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by rondon2 on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @11:16AM
(#8788699)
The person who eats 2,000 calories in one sitting at burger king is much more likely to make a Frozen Pizza at home than a Arugula salad and Grilled fish.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by claystu on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @02:45PM
(#8789821)
There is no reason to suppose this.
My wife eats salads all the time at home and packs them for lunch, but whenever we go to a fast food joint, she orders the Big Mac and fries specifically because she doesn't eat them at home and doesn't feel like eating healthy. (That's why we got fast food in the first place)
Fun Fact: two slices of digiorno pepperoni (1/3 of the pizza) is still only 640 calories. So even if this person does cook a frozen pizza at home, it would still be a lot healthier. An egg omelet with coffee, a salad for lunch plus some fruit, and two slices of pizza plus some cookies for dinner would be approximately 2,000 calories.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by Mz on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @04:42PM
(#8790387)
Keep in mind that all of the examples are actively shooting to hit 2000 calories. It says nothing about what is a "typical" meal at the chain. In fact, for the Chipotle example, it lists a burrito in order to hit that mark: Chipotle Carnitas burrito (945), chips and guacamole (770), Coke (276). then, in the paragraph below that, it indicates: Chipotle says burrito bowls, which leave out 300-calorie flour tortilla, even outsell burritos. Furthermore, the authors chose the guacamole for the article because it is, hands down, the highest calorie dip available. It is nearly twice as many calories as the sour cream and it is ten times the calories of some of the salsas. But most folks aren't ordering chips and guac. Chips and salsa is a far more common thing to order as a side. My firsthand observation suggests that, because the burritos are so big, people who order a burrito often do not order any sides with it.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by legalbeagle on Monday December 22, 2014 @04:39PM
(#8785409)
There is no information in the article about where the information on calorie counts came from. Personally, they seem wrong to me, at least on some of the items. I don't think the Cowboy Ribeye from Ruth's Cris, for example, really contains 1650 calories.
That of course assumes that the whole thing is pure protein, when it obviously has fat and bone in it. So at 1650 calories, the steak would have to about 2/3 protein. This matches up with my experience at Ruth's Chris. On top of that, is the delicious butter they serve everything in, which is additional calories.
So yeah, 1650 seems completely reasonable for the Cowboy Ribeye.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by legalbeagle on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:54AM
(#8787110)
Two errors in this. First, the 22 oz is before cooking weight. After cooking will be less - maybe 16 oz raw (after you deduct bone and fat) and 12 oz after cooking. The remaining lean meat isn't pure protein. There's other tissues. nutritiondata.self.com lists only about 76.7 calories per oz, or about 920 calories for the whole thing.
Re:What 2,000 Calories Looks Like
by DanBC on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:58AM
(#8793027)
Why are you discounting fat? You don't lose that when cooking the steak. You've forgotton to add anything for the butter they add. I don't think the bone weighs six ounces - but I admit I have little idea what a fucking ounce is.
Google tells me there are 291 calories in a cooked ribeye steak. That's over 1,000 for a 16 ounce steak.
You are severely underestimating the calorie content.
The comparison to home-cooked at the end is a little ridiculous. A 22oz steak will be a lot of calories whether you cook it at home or have it at a restaurant. They intentionally picked healthier options for the home meal, and always included large sugared drinks or milkshakes with the fast food options. It would be interesting to see the same article, but comparing each individual meal at a restaurant with a home-cooked version of the same meal (and I'd imagine you'd mostly be shaving off a couple hundred calories unless you're really messing with the ingredients.)
I think the real point they were trying to make was that when you are actually cooking your food, you are more conscious of what you're eating and therefore more likely to choose lower calorie/healthier options.
However, I am not sure I really agree with them. I can make a giant plate of spaghetti at home or eat several peanut butter sandwiches really easily - burning through 2000 calories without paying attention. And since some restaurants have calorie counts on their meals anyway - it's pretty easy for me to choose that if I want to be on a diet.
Or you could skip the chips, cookie or drink, or order the regular size (not the big size). Or have a different sandwich from the Italian, which has the highest calorie content of all the sandwiches on the menu. It's not rocket science.
Honestly I expect a little better than such a blatant false dichotomy from the article.
2. Even suggesting that most people need 2000 calories is wildly dangerous as this is a figure that will vary for EVERY individual. I myself need ~3000 calories just to maintain a healthy weight.
There's about 400 calories in 8ozs of steak; there's about 350 calories in 50g of butter.
Profit?
Talk about manipulating the facts to get the end result. Why would I drink diet soda at home but always order regular at a restaurant? because that's the only way to get the "oh wow" factor for the photos.
My wife eats salads all the time at home and packs them for lunch, but whenever we go to a fast food joint, she orders the Big Mac and fries specifically because she doesn't eat them at home and doesn't feel like eating healthy. (That's why we got fast food in the first place)
Fun Fact: two slices of digiorno pepperoni (1/3 of the pizza) is still only 640 calories. So even if this person does cook a frozen pizza at home, it would still be a lot healthier. An egg omelet with coffee, a salad for lunch plus some fruit, and two slices of pizza plus some cookies for dinner would be approximately 2,000 calories.
A Big Mac is 530 and a Large Fry is 530. Your example is off by about 50%.
Source of the calorie counts for the sides: http://www.chipotle.com/en-US/menu/nutrition_calculator/nutr...
So yeah, 1650 seems completely reasonable for the Cowboy Ribeye.
Google tells me there are 291 calories in a cooked ribeye steak. That's over 1,000 for a 16 ounce steak.
You are severely underestimating the calorie content.
I think this is pretty common these days, to see such info either in store or on the chain's websites.