However, he failed to grasp some basic IP concepts, especially wrt US law. Algorithms are not copyrightable, and most are not patentable (especially after Alice v CLS) under US law. However, there is solid precedent for similar systems being eligible for patent protection (soundex, other patents that cite his systems as source material, etc). It does not appear that he applied for this protection at this time.
Moreover, under the modification clause of the 3 clause BSD license he used in his source file, there is a significant amount of commentary suggesting such a rewrite would be permissible under the terms of that license. However, re-licensing it under MIT would on the surface not be permitted.
EDIT: he may have applied for a patent. This could preclude the project from including his system. However, I'm not a patent lawyer, so I don't know how well this would hold up in international implementations (github being a US entity makes this point relatively moot).
Unless he applies (has applied at this point) in a particular country, or has a Patent Cooperation Treaty application filed in some country and is pursuing it in a particular country, he is completely out of luck by publishing his algorithm. (And as another commentor mentioned, post-Alice, it's pretty unlikely that a patent applicant will succeed with software patent applications absent some pretty close coupling to something specific about the computer hardware.)
It's amazing to me that so many software developers have no basic grasp of IP--the thing they work so hard to produce. It's not like it's all that difficult: Copyrights protect the expression of an idea; patents protect inventions. This developer seems to think that copyrights protect ideas.
Indeed. His patent was abandoned, according to the USPTO's PAIR website at [1], after being rejected for non-patentability. Aside from being apparently non-patentable subject matter, the examiner noted that Philips's application was similar to a previously rejected application no. 10/454,261, and rejected the former on the some of the same grounds as the latter.
(I am not a patent lawyer.)
When patents are involved, it makes more sense to us a license like the GPL3 or Apache2.0, which also grant licenses for any patents which are covered by the code.
If you want a non-derivative work you need to do something like a clean room implementation where the one writing the code doesn't have access to the code of the existing implementation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design
BTW this guy can not stop derivative works once he has released it as BSD.
As the Wikipedia link you gave says:
> Clean room design is usually employed as best practice, but not strictly required by law. In NEC Corp. v Intel Corp. (1990), NEC sought declaratory judgment against Intel's charges that NEC's engineers simply copied the microcode of the 8086 processor in their NEC V20 clone. A US judge ruled that while the early, internal revisions of NEC's microcode were indeed a copyright violation, the later one, which actually went into NEC's product, although derived from the former, were sufficiently different that they could be considered free of copyright violations.
As another example, BSD Unix evolved sufficiently away from AT&T Unix that only a couple of files needed to be replace to get away from AT&T's copyright.
Both derive from someone else's works, but that's a different sense of "derivative" than what copyright law cares about.
could he just remove the BSD license from all subsequent commits to the code base? The existing code base will still continue to be BSD licensed of course.
I can take any BSD code, close source it, develop it further inside my company, then sell it as a proprietary, closed source app.
Or re-license to GPL.
Forfeiting copyright is not possible in some jurisdictions.
I'm not sure what is unclear about a refutation of a single sentence.
Moral rights are generally impossible to forfeit and assign. Economic rights usually (I don't know of any jurisdictions where assigning economic rights to the project maintainer would be impossible - are you?) are possible to assign.
In common law systems, the two are usually traditionally much more closely tied, and when we talk about copyright in English, it is usually the economic rights we're referring to.
I know to contribute to Clojure/ClojureScript-proper, I had to sign http://clojure.org/contributing
The short version is assign FSF copyright, or put it in the public domain.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_v._Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCO%E2%80%93Linux_controversie...
There are tons and tons of cases in this area.
Aside: Isn't is possible to revoke a license?
http://ifosslawbook.org/france/ ("Moral Rights" heading)
All rights granted under this License are granted for the
term of copyright on the Program, and are irrevocable
provided the stated conditions are met.
How does France work against this?If that's the law in France, it trumps the license text.
Just as the law trumps any clause requiring the sacrifice of the licensee's firstborn on an altar.
If conditions are imposed on you (whether by court order, agreement or
otherwise) that contradict the conditions of this License, they do not
excuse you from the conditions of this License. If you cannot convey a
covered work so as to satisfy simultaneously your obligations under this
License and any other pertinent obligations, then as a consequence you may
not convey it at all.
Since allowing the licensor to revoke the licence would be an extra condition.I don't know how this affects the GPL specifically, but you can be pretty sure that if the GPL doesn't contain France-specific French-language legalese to work around it, then it's likely to be revokable whatever the license says. Of course this only affects you if you're in France or have French contributors.
> Nevertheless, the Intellectual Property Code provides some specific rules regarding moral rights over software. It provides that the author may not oppose modifications of the software, in as far as such modifications do not affect his honor or reputation, and exercise his right of withdrawal.
The remaining issue is that you can still forbid modifications that "affect your honor or reputation".
[1] http://legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCodeArticle.do?cidTexte=LEGI...
Assuming he holds the copyright for the entirety of the program, he could change the license for all future versions, and he also could stop distributing old versions under the old license (putting a new license on it, or simply discontinuing distribution). But, the old license has already granted thousands, or millions, of people, the right to distribute it under those terms.
If you give someone the right to do something and don't specify how you can take it away, you can't take it away again. Without termination clauses a license is a contract thats valid indefinitely.
In software, the license is what you sell. I don't buy MS Windows or Photoshop, I buy a license for it. If you sell me a 3-seat license of software v1.0 allowing me to install it on up to 3 computers, you can't come back 2 years later and change the terms to only 1 computer. Now, in 2 years, you might have v2.0 and require a new license for that. But the license you sold me for v1.0 remains in place.
By releasing the software under the BSD license, he basically sold us a license (price immaterial) granting permission to redistribute and alter the code, provided that new code includes the BSD license.
I understand that wasn't his intention. Another commenter pointed out that the author gave permission to another project which was being released under the BSD license. Now anyone that was "sold" the software with that license has been granted those redistribution rights.
If I pay money in return for a license to use Photoshop, there is a reasonable expectation that I can use that indefinitely. I give then money, they give me permission.
If I simply download a piece of open source software from the internet, that isn't the same thing. There's no transaction. There's no anything. If the author subsequently tells me "I hereby revoke all previous licenses", I don't see how that wouldn't have legal weight.
Money has nothing to do with it, all reproduction of bits is automatically covered by copyright law, and has a legal presumption of "all rights reserved" unless explicitly delineated in a license.
Even when paying money, it isn't a reasonable expectation to expect to be able to use it forever for all software. With shrink-wrap or click-through agreements, perhaps, by convention, but plenty of software is sold on subscription for example, or may have revocation clause without refund which is common with MMO games for example.
Some software also may naturally break some day due to incompatibility or disinterest by the author. Other than limited warranty protections by law, there's not much a buyer can do about it. This is of course subject to local laws which may allow moral revocation (France) or stricter warranties.
With regards to downloading a piece of open source, the downloader is consenting to the copyright license it is offered under: it's the same as a click through.
If there is no license, you technically have no right to use or redistribute the software (all rights are reserved).
If there is a license, usually that will explain the author's intentions for fees, redistribution rights, and rights of revocability.
The OSI exists to approve licenses as "open source" when they (among other clauses) explicitly denounce revocability. The only recourse is that an author can refuse to OSI license future modifications or releases of the software (basically making a private fork).
These licenses are explicit about what they do/do not grant. p
You put out code under a BSD license and people have some reasonable expectations that they can use that code.
I don't see anything about a patent grant - do you have a link to that?
Algorithms are sometimes subject to patents, though I believe they shouldn't be, and if the author wanted this sort of control over the algorithm a patent is the path he should have taken, but as far as I can tell the author has not patented this particular algorithm (and I doubt it is novel, as it sounds similar to quite a few pre-existing tools in related fields).
This is just a sort of weird conversation. Why Open Source something if you don't want people to use it in interesting ways?