My quick read suggests that the authors are restating the relationship using their "Entropic View" notation which, as it turns out, has the same expression if you come at it from the uncertainty principle side or the wave equation side.
That is nice from the point of view of validating their notation but it doesn't give us anything we didn't already know.
Basically, the very meaning of de Broglie's law (a particle with momentum p has a wavelength L = h / p) specifies a "particle wavelength", but that wavelength can only exist within that particle's position-uncertainty. Shrink that uncertainty and you necessarily have a small L to fit within there, which means a very high p, which means that little fluctuations e.g. in the direction of p translate to large uncertainties about p. About a quarter-way into the course it is revealed that de Broglie's law essentially identifies p-space with k-space (that is, the Fourier conjugate to x-space), and you then prove that all Fourier conjugate pairs have an uncertainty principle, quite independent of quantum mechanics. So the earliest statement of wave-particle duality already implies the uncertainty principle and this has been known for a long time.
The generalized uncertainty principle is nothing but an application of the 'Schwartz Inequality' to two non-commuting operators. Specifically, if the commutator [A,B] = iC for operators A and B (C can be an operator or scalar, i is sqrt(-1) to preserve Hermitian-ness), then the product of uncertainties Delta A x Delta B >= <C>/2. Where Delta A = sqrt(<A^2> - <A>^2) and <A> is the expectation value of A for a given wave function, and [A,B] = AB - BA.
The wave function itself is the fundamental driver behind the wave-particle duality. And the generalized uncertainty principle just follows downstream from mathematical application. I don't see why the article (not the papers though) is saying they're two unrelated things.
FYI, this brings back annoying memories from one of my midterm exams in grad level quantum mechanics. Five questions to solve in one hour. And one question alone was to derive the generalized uncertainty relation from first principles.
(And your note reminds me of some of the QM and modern physics tests I had as well - I didn't take grad work, but I still remember thinking, "Man, we spent hours deriving some of the stuff, and I've got... less than 10 minutes. Whelp...")
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v375/n6530/pdf/375367b0...
In particular, they have a description of why they find the traditional connection between uncertainty and wave-particle duality to be unsatisfactory. Unfortunately the technical details are beyond me, but hopefully someone else can sort them out?
Edit: Okay, some more digging suggests the following story: (i) We have wave-particle duality => Heisenberg uncertainty, but not the other way around (ii) With entropic uncertainty [1] (stronger than Heisenberg uncertainty), the authors show that we can obtain wave-particle duality
Again, can somebody more knowledgeable can clarify? :)
Aside: If |Psi> is a state with wavefunction <x|Psi>, then is there a linear operator A such that <x|A|Psi> = log(<x|Psi>)?
Note: Logarithm of a complex function.
<x|A(|Psi> + |Chi>) = log(<x|(|Psi> + |Chi>))
= log(<x|Psi> + <x|Chi>)
= log(<x|Psi>) log(<x|Chi>)
/= <x|A|Psi> + <x|A|Chi> log(a + b) = log(a) log(b)
is a rule I'm familiar with! log(a + b) /= log(a) + log(b)
in general, the result is still correct.The idea behind my question: does the Shannon entropic integral correspond to the L2 length of some projected state? Leading to a prescription to prepare a state with minimum uncertainty product of canonically conjugate physical quantities.
Afaik, in classical statistical physics the log() shows up when the N! in a binomial probability distribution limits to large N via the Stirling approximation. It would be interesting to find a different route for log() to enter the picture from a quantum standpoint.
All admittedly vague and hand waving speculation.
Anyway, I get an error when I click on the paper. I still expect it to contain something else, besides this article's contents.
However, we never observe collapse to a single eigenstate of
a continuous-spectrum operator (e.g. position, momentum, or
a scattering Hamiltonian), because such eigenfunctions are
non-normalizable. In these cases, the wave function will
partially collapse to a linear combination of "close"
eigenstates (necessarily involving a spread in eigenvalues)
that embodies the imprecision of the measurement apparatus.
I suppose I just took away that the particle 'point' idea is likely just an asymptotic approximation of what the thing could be modeled as, but in reality - deep down at the atomic scales - it's really a 'linear combination of "close" eigenstates'.It's like suddenly being able to say, "Enough! Just tell me the value right there!" Which turns out to reduce to your friendly neighborhood point particle model. (Pretty much by design, if I'm not forgetting my history correctly - it's sort of a made up tool that sort of abuses notation, like the Heaviside step function.)
But deep down I never trusted that a particle was actually a basically zero dimensional-like point, though. It was just useful to think of it as one.
Was it a serious idea that upon measurement the particle literally lost it's wave properties? Like, there were actually two separate approaches to the math? I know we made some efforts to simplify in class, approximating as particles and such due to the drastically simplified math, but we all knew that was happening; the professor was reasonably explicit about it. EDIT: As in, I remember us going over the evolution of a waveform, and how boundaries affect the solutions, and how uncertainty causes the particles to have field distributions that just happen to be the wave solution of the particle.
I'm completely serious about being confused here: QM is super easy to misunderstand, and I'd love to feel the eureka this article is trying to convey.