News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by dang on Thursday December 18, 2014 @02:26PM (#8769163)
This story was killed by user flags. That was a bad use of flagging, so we've overridden it. The article is clearly substantive enough to pass the minimal bar for this site. Whether it's great or not, or even good or not, is a different question.
Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by chc on Thursday December 18, 2014 @03:12PM (#8769389)
It is substantial, but it is not relevant. This article is clearly far enough afield from the topic of this site that it deserves to be flagkilled. Whether it's substantial or not is a different question.

Also, if you're going to override people's flags, you should also override all the upvotes, because there is no way to just downvote irrelevant crap like this, so political diatribes, Buzzfeed links and everything else that has a solid core of upvoters will dominate if we can't filter for relevance.

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by dang on Thursday December 18, 2014 @03:57PM (#8769571)
> This article is clearly far enough afield from the topic of this site

I'm afraid you have a misconception, and it's a crucial one. There is no "topic of this site". The axiom of Hacker News is intellectual curiosity, and intellectual curiosity does not limit itself to one set of things.

Of course we're not all curious about the same stuff. That's why we have voting—to express personal interest. But to flag an article like this one is to say it has no (or nearly no) potential for intellectual curiosity at all, and that seems clearly to be a bad call.

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by chc on Thursday December 18, 2014 @04:20PM (#8769675)
I think the guidelines suggest something a little less broad than "whatever you personally find interesting":

"Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic."

Let me elaborate: Should I start spamming links to long-winded vegan propaganda? I would find it interesting, because it appeals to a viewpoint I happen to agree with. I also find Sailor Moon to be interesting. Should I start linking Sailor Moon content? Exactly how ridiculous and fluffy do my interests have to be before we can agree that there would be a better forum for the content?

Although they might be interesting to some particular hackers, vegan evangelism, libertarian politics and Sailor Moon are pretty far from the obvious intent of "things that good hackers would find interesting."

More than that, political content is poisonous to good discussion. The more you allow politics in, the more politics will consume everything, and the more comment threads you'll have that only gratify people's need to be outraged. I can understand that some political stories legitimately reflect a new trend that affects hackers and entrepreneurs, but allowing anything that interests anyone just allows far too much junk and hastens the site's decline.

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by dang on Friday December 19, 2014 @01:23AM (#8771314)
It isn't whatever you find interesting, it's whatever you find intellectually interesting. Intellectual interest is only one kind of interest. I think this answers the examples you raise—e.g. long-winded vegan propaganda wouldn't be intellectually interesting, but an article about the history of veganism might be.

The guidelines do say that most political stories are probably off-topic. But "note those words most and probably" [1]. They're not there by accident.

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922304#up_4922426

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by dragonwriter on Thursday December 18, 2014 @04:23PM (#8769696)
> The article is clearly substantive enough to pass the minimal bar for this site.

Perhaps it meets the minimum bar for substance (but if so, that bar is so low that almost nothing could squeeze under it), but if so only in a general interest sort of way, exactly the kind of way referred to in the guidelines (emphasis added):

"Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."

A review of the rather old phenomenon of the political philosophy of Objectivism that is prompted by a reasonably recent convention but doesn't really address anything new about it doesn't seem to fit into the topicality guidelines even if grants that it is substantive (which, in this case, seems excessively generous.)

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by raldi on Thursday December 18, 2014 @03:41PM (#8769508)
I appreciate your transparency and your willingness to trust your own judgment as to when to intervene.
Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by adwf on Thursday December 18, 2014 @03:28PM (#8769469)
It'll surely trigger some flamewar warning eventually. User flagging is just pre-emptive ;)
Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by mindcrime on Thursday December 18, 2014 @04:12PM (#8769630)
As an avowed Libertarian, libertarian, and fan of Ayn Rand (but not a self-identified Objectivist), even I think this is off-topic here. Granted "intellectual curiosity" covers a lot of ground, but I struggle to see the relevance of this piece to a site named "Hacker News".

All of that said, I'm just happy it isn't the flat out hatchet job I expected. When the mainstream press mentions Rand, it's almost always to portray her as some "Wicked Witch of the West" caricature, and to misrepresent her philosophy so as to marginalize it.

Re:Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip by Tycho on Thursday December 18, 2014 @03:04PM (#8769359)
Presumably these are the sorts of people who would apply for positions in the Thought Police if they got the chance.