News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @11:16AM (#8762789)
In March 2007, we signed a term sheet with Mangrove who wanted to invest in Zlio..A few days after, I met a Google Executive who decided to buy the company. For the little story, Zlio, became blacklisted/sandboxed by Google 6 months after…. It killed the company…

When I’ve taken a job at Zlio.com in 2007 to start their US operations, with Jeremie Berrebi as a CEO, I was really excited by the growth I was seeing. All signals were green : users, revenues, traction, VC funding. They had it all.

A week after I joined the company, Google sandboxed us, and we’ve lost 90% of our traffic. After months and months of work trying to solve our inbound traffic issue, we pretty much all gave up and decided to move on to other things.

Is it possible they were doing blackhat SEO, which got them banned from Google?

Otherwise, this sounds pretty damning for Google. I'm just trying to think of alternative theories. It seems like if Google were willing to act this way, they'd have a history of doing so. Do they?

EDIT: Yes, probably spam: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4755386

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @11:21AM (#8762810)
I don't think Google did anything intentional, but it probably doesn't matter.

They probably were doing something that would raise a flag at Google, but the Googlers knew how to get around that. So they let the app run, then let the system kill it. Meanwhile, they could do something very similar that would not raise the flag, and it'd work.

It's not intentional, but if you work down the hall from the guys who control a ton of web traffic and others who are responsible for app security, it helps. One might even say that it becomes an unfair competitive advantage.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by jber on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:04PM (#8763043)
We don't think Google did something intentionally We worked a lot with them.

They posted that on their Adsense blog 1 month before the blacklisting : http://adsense.blogspot.com/2007/08/adsense-api-on-e-commerc...

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by gcb0 on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @02:52PM (#8763944)
apple is the new ibm. google is the new microsoft. and ironically, microsoft is the new apple (spining cool products that ultimately fail in the market). So it is no suprise google shoves it's weight around to shutdown (or buy, its the same) competitors.

just remember this and you should be fine with your unix beard in the XXI century. :)

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by birken on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @03:21PM (#8764106)
The Google search team actually has 3 weekly meetings with the deals team. The deals team keeps them apprised of potential deals they are working on, and then the search team tunes the weekly algorithm updates to either boost or penalize the various companies, whatever the deal team wants. Sometimes they are boosting on Monday, but by Friday they are penalizing. Things move fast in the deals team!

Sometimes overall search quality suffers, but of course the deals team is the #1 priority in the company. I honestly don't know how they get away with this from a monopoly perspective!!!

Edit:

OK, people aren't getting this. This is a joke. Google does not do this. I never worked on Google search, but those people were insanely serious about worrying about search quality and isolating themselves from other teams. The claims in this joke are also ridiculous, I thought the fact this was a joke was obvious, but I was wrong.

Sorry for the confusion. I will label all jokes in the future.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by tptacek on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @04:23PM (#8764436)
I downvoted this comment, but that was dumb of me; I should have clicked through to the user profile. If you're going to write something like this and sign your name to it, you should get some of the benefit of the doubt. Which is what you did.

Sorry for the downvote.

Also: wow.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by tptacek on Thursday December 18, 2014 @12:05AM (#8766044)
"Your sense of humor is a bit of a high-wire act, isn't it?"
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by birken on Thursday December 18, 2014 @01:31AM (#8766251)
Yeah it was in this case. I've clearly got to know my audience a little better.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by tptacek on Thursday December 18, 2014 @12:37PM (#8768523)
To the extent it's an audience thing, it's got more to do with the audience not knowing what would or wouldn't be a credible thing to say about the internal workings of the search and "deals" team inside Google.

If anything, I'm inclined to think charitably about Google, because my contacts there are on the security team and are uniformly excellent people.

I know the feeling though; I've taken similar swings at deadpan humor and struck out, too.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by gcb0 on Saturday December 20, 2014 @12:04PM (#8777128)
everyone knows the good grunts on evil companies. but unless you know the execs, don't go with that.

i bet lots of good, honest people worked for Enron.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by dctoedt on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @06:25PM (#8765089)
Upvoted to compensate (I probably would have ignored the comment otherwise).
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by pepon on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @03:52PM (#8764280)
That is a pretty strong accusation. What is your source?
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by akamaka on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @07:08PM (#8765287)
I got that it was a joke, but I downvoted you because it's not really funny and a waste of my time to read.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by zakelfassi on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @11:21AM (#8762808)
Reminds me of Season4's Ep3 (Two Girls One Code) of The Good Wife.

Two startup founders who developed voice recognition software were negatively affected by tweaked search engine page ranking of ChumHum after refused being acquired.

Coincidence?

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by wickawic on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @11:38AM (#8762879)
The Good Wife takes lots of stories from real life. I'm thinking specifically of the episode when a show (like Glee) lifted a cover of a song (like Baby Got Back) from an artist (like Jonathan Coulton) who didn't technically own the copyright to the lyrics or melody.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by Mandatum on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @05:58PM (#8764930)
What's interesting is this is a perfect case of having a single monopoly on search is so damning to businesses. This company essentially depended on being indexed by Google - once they were struck off, their fate which was at the hands of Google is sealed.

In reality however, the spam which was being linked by users to their sub-sites should have been hosted on a separate domain name. That was a bad choice by the company. Especially if they weren't going to actively disallow links constantly.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by wmeredith on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:05PM (#8763046)
Would Google use their influence to kill a competitor for the own benefit? Definitely. They have a pattern of going against their own rules, their users' interests, and even the law when they stand to gain. To say this situation is any different in the absence of hard evidence, would be naive. (Edit, OP provided the aforementioned evidence that Google did have a competitive reason to do this.)

They have a rich history of stomping on little guys as well as being a masterclass in the, "do what I say, not what I do" sort of hypocrisy that always seems to come from those with great power. In my eyes, they've long lost the benefit of the doubt when it comes to matters like this. Google holds a lot of utility for me and I use their products daily, but I hold no illusions as to their predatory nature.

1) Google has claimed non-existent partnerships with their competitors in direct marketing of a competing product. They were literally calling their competitor's customers on the phone, saying they were a partner of the competing company, and hard selling that company's customers to sign up for their product.[1]

2) Google has the honor of receiving the largest civil penalty the Federal Trade Commission has ever imposed for overriding their user's privacy settings in Apple's Safari browser.[2] For some perspective: this fine was 0.1 percent of Larry Page's net worth, or what Google takes in over the course of about 5 hours.

3) Google search makes a regular habit of scraping other web sites and displaying ads against the content, something explicitly banned by their ToS for Adwords users.[3]

4) Google search also regularly shows upwards of 75% ads on a page. For instance, a search for "Kansas City real estate" returns you nine ads and three organic search results when viewed on a 2560 x 1440 screen[4] (15" MacBook Pro). This is explicitly against their policy, "Publishers should avoid site layouts in which the ads push content below the fold. These layouts make it hard for users to distinguish between the content and ads."[5] This also violates their add limit per page[6] laid out in their ToS.

5) This might be my favorite. If you Google "Scraper Site" they will actually scrape the explanation of the term from Wikipedia and serve up for you[7].

This what I could put together in about 20 minutes. Doing anything more than cursory research on this subject will leave with a very bad taste in your mouth about Google as a steward of the world's information. From convenient banning stories like this to lying about the data they collect in the first place and then lying about how long they keep it.

[1]http://business-ethics.com/2012/08/14/10058-is-22-5-million-...

[2]http://imgur.com/RjiKmOy

[3]http://imgur.com/ehIAsOa

[4]https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/1346295?hl=en#Diff...

[5]https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/1346295?hl=en#Ad_l...

[6]http://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-misuses-mocality-d...

[7]http://searchengineland.com/google-scraper-tweet-185684

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by tptacek on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:25PM (#8763156)
You seem more sure about this than the principal of the impacted company, who seems to have commented downthread.

A top comment from the last thread about this story:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4755386

Another comment on that thread points out that Amazon also sanctioned them:

http://techcrunch.com/2007/05/21/zlio-banned-from-amazon/

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by wmeredith on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:37PM (#8763224)
Yep, they were spamming and deserved what they got. The point of my comment is that Google is not to be trusted at face value. They have lost that privilege. In this case, the company that got blacklisted screwed up and you can prove it by looking at their link profile. So Google did no wrong here in my eyes.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:26PM (#8763487)
On the other hand, if I'd realized I'd be starting a Google hate train with my original comment, I wouldn't have commented. My question was strictly about this particular case.

No company is perfect. There have been a few distasteful decisions from Google, but every company has had those. And besides, Google could be far more evil than it has been. We should probably give them the benefit of the doubt unless there is some strong evidence.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by wmeredith on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:45PM (#8763592)
>>Google could be far more evil than it has been.

This is the bar they have to clear? Pretty low standards if you ask me.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by magicalist on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:52PM (#8763631)
Yes, Google "scraping" search snippets (using wikipedia as an example even though it's CC-BY-SA!), which has been a feature of google forever and has been ruled as fair use on multiple occasions, is a much better standard.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by javajosh on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:48PM (#8763610)
Not sure why Google sanctioned Zlio, but the Techcrunch article hints quite heavily that Amazon did it to clear the way for their own competitive offering, aStore.

Update: We haven’t heard from Amazon, but Zlio looks to be in direct competition with aStore, a new service from Amazon. See Centernetwork’s coverage here from late last year. Zlio actually launched the same day as aStore. That still isn’t a good explanation as to why Amazon has shut them off, however.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by gcb0 on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @02:54PM (#8763953)
it is easy to abuse your power without consequences when you write laws to make everyone guilty.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by anon1385 on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:38PM (#8763228)
It appears that you have replied to the wrong post, otherwise your comment makes no sense.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by kyrra on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:45PM (#8763271)
The "scraper site" is perfectly reasonable though. Wikipedia's content is published under Creative Commons. Heck, you can download all of Wikipedia yourself[0]. Google properly attributes the content they have to Wikipedia and displays it. I don't see anything wrong here.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Database_download

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by wmeredith on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:00PM (#8763362)
I've seen examples before where it was definitely not CC published info, but I can't come up with one now and am too busy to take a deep dive, so strike it from the list. The rest of the cases still uphold the point.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by IndianAstronaut on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @03:36PM (#8764193)
Being in the SEO world, one can get a sense of how much power Google has. Google has the power to make or break online businesses. A site penalty or demotion of the site on adwords, can lead to business failures.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by TrainedMonkey on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:44PM (#8763266)
So much for don't be evil.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by rogerbinns on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @01:39PM (#8763559)
The Google Maps app for Blackberry had this "fun" feature where it uninstalled an open source product Mobile GMaps every time you ran Google Maps. Google ignored all attempts to communicate with them about this. I interviewed at Google years ago when I was a Blackberry user and had been very annoyed at this "evil" functionality. The response of people there was eye opening, largely amounting to:

"That is evil, Google does no evil, therefore that doesn't happen."

Edit: Two links substantiating this

News item: http://www.mgmaps.com/news.php?older=1#item174

Forum discussion: http://forum.mgmaps.com/viewtopic.php?t=1868

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by asuffield on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @07:36PM (#8765393)
The first one links to the second; the second is a broken link.
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by hobolord on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @11:20AM (#8762806)
I think they put majority of the blame on Google, but maybe it was because their SEO team wasn't able to get them higher on Google's pagerank? Or competition?
Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by jber on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:03PM (#8763032)
We had no SEO team before the blacklisting.

We gave to all of our members/stores owners the possibility to customize their store template.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by bsaul on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:14PM (#8763093)
Didn't know your tech guys were based in israel. Would that explain, now that i think about it that i see a kind of similar spirit between wix.com and zilo ?

Also, i was a zilo user back in the time, and really liked it. Glad things turned out well for you !

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by jber on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:20PM (#8763124)
It was Zlio not Zilo (Yep, I know it was a poor name)

Wix and Zlio: We had the same investor. Mangrove. They discovered Wix when they came to Israel for a Zlio Board. They know own 25% of Wix.

Re:The Email I Received from Google in 2007 When They Wanted... by dmak on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @09:37PM (#8765727)
Responding to the spamming bit: I think this should be taken lightly. I mean, ANYONE could post up those links.