Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by tripzilch on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @06:49AM
(#8761950)
> Why should a calculator (for example) know if there is incoming call?
Because it's running on a phone.
Remember those cool requestAnimationFrame side-channel timing attacks. I think it'd be pretty hard to hide at least certain things like these from an app if it really wanted to know. In this case I think it's pretty fair to just give it an API call for it.
Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by MichaelGG on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @08:30AM
(#8762198)
Why shouldn't it? It's on a phone; it's part of basic usability. And the cure in Google's case is far, far worse. Give them access to your IMEI and phone numbers in and out. I know assume incompetence over maliciousness, but this stretches belief. Especially combined with the rest of Google's little tricks.
Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by marcosdumay on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @09:43AM
(#8762400)
> I know assume incompetence over maliciousness, but this stretches belief.
It's worse than that. Android had a saner permission interface, with a separated permission just for detecting if the phone is ringing. Google "updated" it to the current format alledging the previous one was too confusing.
But this case should be handled by a permission in dialer (or whatever handles incoming calls) - something like "allow to broadcast mute to all other applications".