Agreed. Defending the story as reporting a rumour is even worse. As a journalist, being duped is one thing; not caring enough to print a real news story is another.
Now, the kid is not your average school-goer, but definitely petite enough to get himself in this situation. I blame him, but definitely not as much as the reporter, this looked like a load of BS right from the moment I saw it.
He made directional outright bets. In other words, say he bought call options betting for the price of the underlying security to go up. This is akin to buying underlying security with massive leverage. If the bet goes your way, you could make a massive return (for example, in Oct '05, I made ~1,000% one-day return on a very small amount buying Google out of the money calls expiring the next day and selling them in the money after stock picked up following earnings report). This is an incredibly dumb strategy and it is completely unscalable to the figures quoted in the article. First, public/listed options are incredibly illiquid in most stocks/securities, and particularly at strikes that could yield this return. This would limit him to making really small bets. Second, you would need a catalyst for a significant price move, which doesn't come too often, so most of the time you would just bleed your option time-value ("theta decay"). Finally, and most importantly, no one is lucky 100% of the time and this type of directional strategy is sure to backfire on you and cost you ~100% of principal (trust me, been there, done that)
He traded volatility. This is effectively a hedge fund strategy, where you buy the option and short the delta of the option in underlying security ("delta hedging"). The hedge gives you protection against the price moves in the underlying and you effectively make money for small moves in the security, regardless of whether it goes up or down (due to "convexity"). Most of the time, you earn pennies on the dollar as the price fluctuates a bit and you trade your delta, and perhaps some of the time you make a bit more if the price moves a lot ("gamma event"). Now, here is the kicker - this is not fool proof either. The strategy trades the risk in the price of the underlying security to the risk in volatility - in other words, if you buy volatility high and sell low, you will still lose money. Most listed options have notoriously bad bid/ask volatility spreads and retail investor would unlikely make any money consistently and reliably enough following this strategy. Needless to say - no way to scale it to the numbers quoted in the article using listed options. Hedge funds and derivative desks at banks mostly trade in OTC (Over The Counter) options which are bespoke bilateral contracts with a ton of protective provisions (averaging periods, stock borrow protection, illiquidity protection, etc) and they still have to take a view on volatility and they do get it wrong sometimes. Even for professionals who are wicked smart and do this day in and day out, the only reliable way to make money is to buy volatility on the cheap in a special situation.
There are a few other strategies that come to mind (e.g. Black Swan) but there has been either no catalyst to make it work or they would be inaccessible to a high school kid from Queens.
The second part that really made me cringe were all the negative references to SV by the kids and by the reporter in her subsequent Tweets. Reality of the situation is that, whatever you may think about early stage bubble in SV, SV tech companies actually create real value, have actual products and serve actual customers/users.
Finally, what is sad about all this is that Mohammed appears to be a smart talented kid and I can't help but think he tainted his prospects quite a bit with this debacle. On the other hand, all this makes a hell of a "what I learned from a failure" college essay.
I was once told that in vol trading, if you're "making more than 60% a year, you're doing something wrong". The point being that with any option spreads, there is a risk-reward ratio, professional's care about money management than profit. You're trying to earn on the theta decay or vice versa, facing theta decay and banking on gamma moves. So you're either facing the death of a thousand paper-cuts with option time premium eroding your bankroll, or you're facing the LTCM catastrophic loss with the wrong kind of risk management.
Even when you trade directional, this past year, both realized and implied vol has been low, with VIX bouncing between 11-20 with median at 13 or 14; you can make lots of money long OTM options in 2008 or flash crash, basically you're playing Nassim Taleb's "long-tail"; this past year simply doesn't warrant that kind of performance unless you're doing some kind of OTM buying on biotech companies and betting correcting on a majority of your catalyst events.
Don't know what was realized vol in oil lately (likely high given recent price action, have no sense of the shape/magnitude), but perhaps that's where he's seen some returns in simulated trading. Needles to say simulated trading is very, very different than the real world, with bid/ask spread dynamics, options illiquidity, collateral requirements, funding costs, borrow costs, etc.
I don't see it as a major mark against him. First, it's unclear that he, himself, tried to create the lie. Second, social proof arbitrage (which we both know isn't a real "arbitrage" but the hacking of peoples' reference-counting algorithms in order to establish personal credibility) is something that everyone does, especially in Silicon Valley where it's just a necessary social skill. It's just a bit juvenile to attach it to a rather verifiable claim of having made $72 million. The best social proof arbitrage is when you dishonestly represent the opinions of influential or reputable people, rather than creating false facts (that will eventually be refuted).
The way I think about this is that if I was Sty teacher who wrote Mohammed's college recommendations, I would be very uneasy right now and think really hard about what I do next. If they really like the kid and believe in him, they may leave it as is and perhaps write it off to youthful indiscretion or lack of life experience (and there is a ton of that, starting with choice of friends - Kazakh "oligarch" heir made me puke on the inside a couple of times). On the other hand, they may be worried about their reputation with college adcoms' and really smart talented kids they write recommendations for in the future. Bottom line - they may be inclined to write a retraction.
I just fail to see this in a positive light. At the end of the day, when you stack up with a ton of other smart talented kids (as is 100% the case at Sty and with credible applicants at all top schools), intangibles like judgement, view and character become really important. He unfortunately failed on those just at the time when colleges are rolling out their decisions. I, perhaps naively, refuse to believe that duping a reporter with lies would give you any good credibility.
A high school kid from Queens wouldn't have the type of collateral and in the amounts required to get that type of leverage. Heck, he wouldn't even pass diligence process for account opening at a prime broker that could provide him with the level of leverage required.
That's why I thought of options as the only way the story could maybe perhaps work. At the core, challenges with options strategies are similar regardless of whether they are credit, equity or commodity options.
At the end of the day, who knows, but I really hope the kid bounces back and makes the best of it. And if not, he can always get into NYU's finance program and work on Wall Street </snark>
[1] http://www.businessinsider.com/most-impressive-students-at-m...
The reporter claims she saw "bank statements"...the validity of which seem to be in question if the boy has recanted everything. I wonder if she got taken in by the good-ol edit-the-HTML-of-official-documents-with-the-Web-inspector trick?
On the upside, at least this teenager doesn't have to bear eternal Internet shame for being part of a public prank/lie. His name is pretty much Google-proof, or at least as Google-proof as someone named "Jesus Christian" would be. That said...I just Googled "Mohammed Islam" and was pretty surprised to see all the top results relating to the young man at hand. I would've thought that Google's algorithm would've associated such a query with Islam the religion and the prophet Muhammad.