Ask HN: Is there anything like Glassdoor, but for recruitment companies?
Would be nice to have a service that lets you know which are the firms that care about the client and the potential employee.
(
25 comments
| 33 points
| on HN
)
Recruiters are incentivized by the companies that hire them for two things:
1) Providing a steady pipeline of candidates for their clients.
2) Maximizing the compensation numbers for candidates they close.
It's arguable that a recruiter that pushes hard to get you a good salary "cares" about you. But they won't care too much if the company they get you into completely burns you out and treats you poorly. Nor will they spend much time prepping you for interviews if they don't see you as a sure bet to land a position with one of their clients.
The recruiter's motivation is the same as a realtor's: Close the deal as soon as possible in order to earn the commission. A 10% salary bump for the candidate is real money. A 10% commission bump for the recruiter is nothing when they could be spending their time earning a whole other commission.
Of course, a good recruiter is going to make sure that the candidate's salary expectations are in line with the employer's. If a recruiter brings you an offer that's exactly what you wanted you've almost certainly left money on the table.
hkarthik's comment is right on the money.
The very high level executive recruiting firms tend to care more about both sides of the equation (employee and client/employer) because its a higher stakes game for them and the talent pool is fairly limited at that level.
In my experience, far too few recruiters can evaluate fit effectively.
If someone has been emailing me for years but never sent me on an interview, I configure it to remove their messages from my inbox.
There also are a couple others I refuse to deal with. They insist on meeting me in person each time, but never sent me on an interview, or sent me on a large number of low-quality interviews. If I was unemployed and desperate, I might give them another chance. I already have a (mediocre) job, so I'm trying to spend my limited job search time efficiently.
It would be like a whitelist of recruiters. You could go and enter your zip code and get a recruiter in your area. Maybe see various metrics as rated by employees.
Maybe to start you could let all recruiters sign up, and remove them as soon as a poor review comes in. Maybe set up some "honey pot" resumes and see if they spam them, and remove them that way too.
From their FAQs:
> Since we're unable to fully verify the identity of an anonymous user, we require each user to certify their employee relationship to the company when they post any content. We also require all users to validate their email address before their posts are made available to the community. This verification process allows us to put measures in place to identify suspicious users and/or posts. And all of these, combined with active community moderation and our commitment to review every post, allow us to have confidence in our information.
What a joke. By "certify their employee relationship..." I'm guessing they mean tick some checkbox, because I don't recall having to prove anything when I've posted reviews. And verifying email addresses? Gee, nobody is going to get around that...
Meanwhile, I had to rewrite a negative review because someone claimed that I was revealing trade secrets. Unless treating your employees like shit is a trade secret, I did no such thing.
In my experience, Glassdoor reviews aren't worth much. They can be taken down for inane reasons, but won't be for legitimate problems.