News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:04AM (#8735064)
From CCC in the early 80s to TESO in the 2000s, through LoD, MoD, cDc, L0pht

With the exception of LoD and MoD, these "groups" (brands, really) have nothing in common with each other. And none of them had any common purpose.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by pastProlog on Thursday December 11, 2014 @03:47PM (#8736979)
L0ck had a common purpose...

The article talks about uniqueness, but being in a group does not affect uniqueness. You could almost compare it to all the Hacker News advice to not do a startup solo, as you need companions to talk to on the long slog. A hacker in a group can brag to them about his achievements (he could tell the whole world, but then he'd be arrested). He can also brag to other hackers about being in an elite group. It socially enhances them as an individual, it doesn't take away from their individuality.

They say the French revolution was formed in the salons of Paris. What were the salons of this bygone hacker scene? The BBS's running on the Apple ]['s and Commodore 64's that were sitting in the bedrooms of teenage boys. That the means of communication were completely controlled by teenage boys (through a mostly oblivious Bell) affected things in a whole host of ways. Any kid with a phone line in his room and $200 for a Commodore 64 could host a node on this communication network in the mid-1980s.

Two forces destroyed the scene - the carrot and the stick. The stick was the government beginning to notice their existence. The 414's were busted in 1983. There were a series of raids in 1987. In 1990 MoD was busted and Operation Sun Devil happened. This didn't really kill the scene though. A complete free-for-all changed into more careful hackers, not making calls from their house but using acoustic couplers on payphones or (modded) cell phones. They also were quieter about laws they may be breaking. They also became more sophisticated, really understanding the phone system, how Internet hosts and security worked etc. In some ways, attacks by law enforcement made them more dangerous.

The real death knell of the groups was the carrot. The Internet became more widespread, and these people began to get jobs. They formed companies, which they sold for millions of dollars to billions of dollars. Which is not hyperbole. When the guy you knew, who was not all that smarter than you, creates a billion dollar company, wardialing or sniffing the traffic of some host seems less important. Idle hands are the devil's workshop. The closed off world of mainframes on x.25 networks run by Computer Science Phds from top universities, counterposed to another network of working class mischievous teenage boys with their Commodore 64 BBSs in their bedrooms - this is a ripe ground for a hacker scene. A network where you hear stories of teenagers making millions on the hit app they wrote - opportunities like this put a damper on hacker scenes.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @05:00PM (#8737291)
Yes: L0ck's purpose was to be a shared joke between a bunch of people who met up every month at Chicago 2600.

I guess I agree with your last graf.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by pea on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:48AM (#8735374)
Yeah it's a bit sensationalist: in the mid-2000s most hacker groups were just trollin' and pwning each other instead of trying to spread any political message. There was very little purpose in phrack.ru / h0no (apart from pwning whitehats and pissing people off. Their motto was literally rm -rf *)
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by atmosx on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:50AM (#8735390)
Hm, not quite sure. There was a "full disclosure" vs "non FD" going on there and it's pretty big political argument if you wanna see it as one. So in a sense, it was not just rm -rf / as you say... It was a little more than that :-)
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:05AM (#8735475)
cDc and L0pht had very little to do with the "full disclosure" debate. More than anything else, that was '90s Bugtraq.

(L0pht obviously had a side in the full disclosure "debate", but they didn't have much to do with the outcome of the debate. I don't recall anyone serious taking the opposing side on full disclosure, by the way; that outcome was a foregone conclusion.)

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tedunangst on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:18AM (#8735549)
> that outcome was a foregone conclusion.

Can you expand on this? I'd say the outcome has been the opposite of the foregone conclusion, unless I've misinterpreted you. FD seemed like the "of course it's this way" option (unless I misremember), but that's not where we are today.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:24AM (#8735591)
Do we mean different things by FD? Would you say we're not FD because researchers are incentivized to collaborate privately with companies to resolve vulnerabilities?

What I'd say is that today, few people bat an eyelash if a researcher does a detailed writeup of how a vulnerability and its exploit work (for instance, look at the Google security blog). That wasn't true in the 1990s: if a company of Google's stature had published something like that, it would have been controversial and newsworthy.

I'd suggest FD prevailed because it's relatively safe to publish vulnerabilities today; in fact, it's a career booster.

During the FD debate, there were "important" people suggesting that all vulnerabilities be routed to organizations like CERT, which had as a charter the concealment of vulnerability details.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tedunangst on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:35AM (#8735647)
OK. I think full disclosure isn't quite the norm. More like "FD is tolerated" than "FD prevailed". Project Zero is kind of remarkable. But I suspect we're putting different emphasis on the word full.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by atmosx on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:06PM (#8735815)
@pea isn't talking about cDc and/or L0pht, he is talking about h0h0 and phrack.ru ... They've wrote some tools to expose honeypots that were used to find 0-days, also released (phrack.ru) a 'fake' phrack version with some interesting content nevertheless.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by pea on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:54AM (#8735408)
Yeah you're right for phrack. I never got why it was such a HUUUUGE issue for them. h0no was straight nihilist though.. http://shootingsawk.lescigales.org/h0no/h0no3.txt
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tedunangst on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:18AM (#8735164)
Well, apparently they all existed in some agrarian free time society, before industrial capitalism crushed our collective dreams. Because nobody cared about money in the 80s.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by lawnchair_larry on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:46AM (#8735361)
Really, CDC and l0pht had nothing in common? TESO had nothing to do with CCC? No MOD members ended up at X-Force with TESO members? I can draw many lines across all of those groups.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by mitchell_h on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:33PM (#8735970)
anyone that spent anytime on IRC could tell you all the groups all talked to each other and spent significant amounts of time in various IRC chans with each other.

They might have ./smurf.c'd each other constantly but they all pretty much came out of the same environment.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:02AM (#8735457)
I know more about cDc and L0pht than TESO and CCC. Maybe you can correct me on the TESO/CCC thing.

How seriously do you take cDc and the L0pht? We should probably make sure we're not talking past each other before we try to debate.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by dpeck on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:04PM (#8735806)
You could probably connect nearly every group through the early 2000s with X-Force as the join.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:16PM (#8735879)
You'd miss a good chunk of w00w00/guild, OpenBSD, and Europe that way.
Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by dpeck on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:24PM (#8738447)
a quick search shows w00w00 would be connected. Not sure of the others, but I (and I'm sure you do too) know of at least MoD, TESO, ADM folks who came through there.

Not saying all groups by any means, but even with being a few years late getting started in the infosec world of Atlanta there were still a lot of old guard hackers hanging around when I got out of school and people still felt comfortable sharing stories from time to time.

Re:The Fall of Hacker Groups by dpeck on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:02PM (#8735790)
very odd wording to me, makes it sound like LoD/MoD/cDc/L0pht were all after TESO.