News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Popular Myths about C++, Part 1 by pjmlp on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @10:43AM (#8729724)
Everything from C++ can be discussed in the context of C++, there is no need to refer to other languages.

A struct is a C++ data type that offers the same set of features as a class, just with a public access as default.

The use cases for a struct are POD (Plain Old Data) used to aggregate variables that refer to a common data structure, hence struct as abbreviation.

> C# and D are sufficiently different, D and C# will not compile most/any C programs.

But they also have struct. So you don't need to explain struct to those developers?

You can also do memcopy and pointer manipulations in C# and D.

Why shouldn't then they also learn about C?

Regarding the C subset in C++, it is actually C89 with a few semantic changes.

There quite a few examples of C89 compliant code that won't compile with a C++ compiler or will have strange behaviors.

The way struct namespaces work is such example.

Re:Popular Myths about C++, Part 1 by throwawayaway on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:06PM (#8730229)
>Use struts when you just need a data container. Use classes when you need to add behaviour. Simple rule,

> A struct is a C++ data type that offers the same set of features as a class, just with a public access as default.

these are lies. at this point it's a semantic argument, what you mean by "understand" is "use". what i mean by understand is its dictionary meaning.

to answer your questions, no you don't need to explain them or teach C to them because the syntax for struct in those languages is not identical to C. that is why. because they are not C structs. "C++ structs" are C structs with some syntatic sugar applied. C structs will not compile in those languages. C structs are not valid code in those languages.

I am aware of the long list of minor incompatibilities between C89 and C++, and how C++11 has removed some and added more

In short you know nothing about this I don't already know and you are quite happy to knowingly deceive your students. i object but there's no point in debating with you further.