Your description summarizes my experience meeting elementary education majors in college quite well. They weren't the hardcore intellectual types, but they really like working with kids. So they optimized for a route that made sense for them. Unfortunately for the children, they won't get exposed to the intellectual areas because the teachers really weren't into that.
That said, yes, public schooling is insane. We pile children into classrooms and then expect them to all learn the same subjects at the same rate. We grade them based on arbitrary deadlines and we force them to learn more complex topics without making sure that they have mastered basic concepts. How someone can get an 'A' and not know 10% of subject matter is beyond me. Oh, and in the US we force all children into the schizophrenic "No Child Left Behind" program which encourages teachers to only teach to tests administered at arbitrary times.
In any kind of reasonable system, children would be able to learn at their own pace, and wouldn't advance to more difficult subject matter until they had achieved 100% mastery. Montessori teaching has elements of this, but I think it will really take new tools like Khan Academy and "flipping the classroom" to make it practicable.
Preschool should be about group play, socialization and getting ready for kindergarden. It shouldn't be about academics.
Next up: difference in distance between one battleship to another; difference in distance across two axis; difference in x and y being called slope.
Then the possibilities are endless.
Is it because many people find it more intellectually gratifying to watch children develop literacy than numeracy? (i.e. Learning to talk makes a child into someone you can interact with and share experience, while learning to count has little immediate impact on how a child can interact with a parent or teacher)
Symmetries, commutativity, associativity, transitivity, basic algebra/equation solving, some geometry, etc.
Teaching these ideas gives children a language to describe the world they're in and make sense of the ideas and concepts that bombard them - they're perhaps even more useful than numbers in this regard. The problem is that most elementary teachers aren't up to explaining these more advanced math concepts (lots of them have trouble with advanced middle school level math), and instead focus on just basic arithmetic.
This does a huge disservice to our children, because kids soak these topics up when well explained, and seem to really enjoy the learning (which is often hands on). I spent a fair bit of time in university (where I studied math) volunteering along with a professor to teach lectures to young children (1st-4th grade in the US) about math.
I honestly wish we could just accept that mathematics is as much of a specialized language/topic as foreign languages, and get specialist teachers starting early on.
> Symmetries, commutativity, associativity, transitivity, basic algebra/equation solving, some geometry, etc.
And games. Even rock, scissors, paper (plus variants).
That said, my impression would certainly be that the numbers and/or patterns work (which I would consider low-level fundamental math stuff) amounted to more than one minute a day.
Specifically, have schools tried to partition students into courses based on achievement level, regardless of age? There would be the Math 1 course that might have 1st, 2nd, and 3rd graders in it, and Math 2 might have brighter 1st graders, etc.
The problem, I think, is not that kids can't learn (in fact the amount neuroplasticity in young children is simply off the charts, to the point where 6-7 year olds who can play really good violin are not something special), but is that the educational system simply does want to go there, to increase the levels of math taught in schools.
(Born, raised, and educated in California)
However, one reason it might be avoided is due to the potential negative effects tracking [1] strategies may have on some students. In my public school district, any form of tracking at the elementary level was difficult to implement due to pushback from parents, even in situations where the educators felt it was beneficial.
A decent fraction of the kids learned math at home, making it hard to assess how well the school was actually doing.
Alas, in general, American schools are underperforming in teaching the most advantaged members of American society,[2] especially in mathematics,[3] while not doing well by the least advantaged young people in American society either.[4] The current efforts in preschools reported in the interesting article submitted here should be followed up by further reform of elementary school mathematics instruction. The book Knowing and Teaching Elementary Mathematics by Liping Ma[5] is especially informative about what to do to help all learners in the United States learn mathematics better in early schooling.
[1] http://www.ets.org/Media/Education_Topics/pdf/TQ_full_report...
[2] http://educationnext.org/when-the-best-is-mediocre/
http://educationnext.org/young-gifted-and-neglected/
[3] http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/
[4] http://www.oecd.org/pisa/pisaproducts/pisa2009/48165173.pdf
http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf
[5] https://www.engageny.org/sites/default/files/resource/attach...
http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/18/opinion/q-a-with-liping-ma...
http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematic...
In my experience, elementary school teachers tend to be soft-skills people who primarily just love working with young children. Many didn't enjoy math, felt they were bad at it, and would prefer to teach children reading and writing. And because elementary schools have one teacher guide the same group of children through all four core subjects instead of specializing in one subject (like middle or high school teachers) the teacher's less-preferenced subjects get less time.
Source: former (public) high school science teacher