News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by eastbayjake on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @04:52PM (#8726057)
I was shocked listening this morning that only 58 seconds of every 5 hour preschool day are spent on math.

In my experience, elementary school teachers tend to be soft-skills people who primarily just love working with young children. Many didn't enjoy math, felt they were bad at it, and would prefer to teach children reading and writing. And because elementary schools have one teacher guide the same group of children through all four core subjects instead of specializing in one subject (like middle or high school teachers) the teacher's less-preferenced subjects get less time.

Source: former (public) high school science teacher

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by pnathan on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:47PM (#8726387)
> elementary school teachers tend to be soft-skills people who primarily just love working with young children.

Your description summarizes my experience meeting elementary education majors in college quite well. They weren't the hardcore intellectual types, but they really like working with kids. So they optimized for a route that made sense for them. Unfortunately for the children, they won't get exposed to the intellectual areas because the teachers really weren't into that.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by Patrick_Devine on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @01:48AM (#8727993)
I agree with you that the way we teach school is completely ridiculous, but 58 seconds for _preschool_ on math is probably fine. Ages 3-5 are really about learning how to socialize, play and interact with the world, and it isn't until about age 6-7 when many kids even develop an aptitude for mathematics. Scandinavian countries use a concept called "Readiness to Learn" and don't teach reading or mathematics until age 7. Your children will likely be much better off playing and being kids in pre-school and learning things like how to sit still as well as fine motor control.

That said, yes, public schooling is insane. We pile children into classrooms and then expect them to all learn the same subjects at the same rate. We grade them based on arbitrary deadlines and we force them to learn more complex topics without making sure that they have mastered basic concepts. How someone can get an 'A' and not know 10% of subject matter is beyond me. Oh, and in the US we force all children into the schizophrenic "No Child Left Behind" program which encourages teachers to only teach to tests administered at arbitrary times.

In any kind of reasonable system, children would be able to learn at their own pace, and wouldn't advance to more difficult subject matter until they had achieved 100% mastery. Montessori teaching has elements of this, but I think it will really take new tools like Khan Academy and "flipping the classroom" to make it practicable.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by musername on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @05:33PM (#8732148)
i heared age four as the beginning to mathematical understanding. sure socialization is important, but why would that precludes the abillity to calculation, maybe without the formal approach.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by Patrick_Devine on Saturday December 13, 2014 @02:33PM (#8746083)
Nothing precludes you teaching your children about mathematics. That's something you can easily do at home for 5-10 minutes every day or two. With my four year old I do this, and also practice things like the alphabet, but it's not something I expect her preschool to do.

Preschool should be about group play, socialization and getting ready for kindergarden. It shouldn't be about academics.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by rdtsc on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @06:03PM (#8726446)
I guess at that age (preschool, first grade), math doesn't have to be math to be math. It can be jumping up and down and counting as article says. I can be counting stairs going up and down, building a tower out of sliced cucumbers during lunch. I feel an intuition about quantities and being familiar with numbers is a good foundation. At least that is what I am trying with my 3 year old.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by nashashmi on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @06:13PM (#8726502)
I would second this. I just thought my 5 year old cousin grids and locations on a grid simply because I wanted him to play battleship.

Next up: difference in distance between one battleship to another; difference in distance across two axis; difference in x and y being called slope.

Then the possibilities are endless.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by GotAnyMegadeth on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @09:29AM (#8729273)
I learned grids and coordinates at school (UK) when I was 5.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by colomon on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:16PM (#8726205)
58 seconds of every _preschool_ day. The stat has nothing to do with elementary school teachers.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by eastbayjake on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:55PM (#8726415)
You are correct, but it's still astounding. (I edited the parent comment, thanks!)

Is it because many people find it more intellectually gratifying to watch children develop literacy than numeracy? (i.e. Learning to talk makes a child into someone you can interact with and share experience, while learning to count has little immediate impact on how a child can interact with a parent or teacher)

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by ObviousScience on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @09:38PM (#8727381)
There's lots of math you can teach that isn't basic numbers though!

Symmetries, commutativity, associativity, transitivity, basic algebra/equation solving, some geometry, etc.

Teaching these ideas gives children a language to describe the world they're in and make sense of the ideas and concepts that bombard them - they're perhaps even more useful than numbers in this regard. The problem is that most elementary teachers aren't up to explaining these more advanced math concepts (lots of them have trouble with advanced middle school level math), and instead focus on just basic arithmetic.

This does a huge disservice to our children, because kids soak these topics up when well explained, and seem to really enjoy the learning (which is often hands on). I spent a fair bit of time in university (where I studied math) volunteering along with a professor to teach lectures to young children (1st-4th grade in the US) about math.

I honestly wish we could just accept that mathematics is as much of a specialized language/topic as foreign languages, and get specialist teachers starting early on.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by eru on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:29PM (#8727697)
> There's lots of math you can teach that isn't basic numbers though!

> Symmetries, commutativity, associativity, transitivity, basic algebra/equation solving, some geometry, etc.

And games. Even rock, scissors, paper (plus variants).

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by eru on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:49PM (#8730532)
Especially imbalanced variants. (Let the kids figure out the imbalances.)
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by colomon on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @10:50PM (#8727589)
Our son was in a cooperative preschool for a while, so I got to see it in action a number of times. They weren't teaching literacy either. The main focus of the classes were developing the skills you need to be able to function in kindergarten -- things like doing what the teacher tells you, raising your hand, being quiet, playing nicely with the other kids, etc. There was basic learning of the alphabet and numbers. Generalized world knowledge. And lots of play time.

That said, my impression would certainly be that the numbers and/or patterns work (which I would consider low-level fundamental math stuff) amounted to more than one minute a day.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by clarkmoody on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @04:59PM (#8726118)
I am interested to hear if high-school/college style teaching has been tried at the elementary level. And what were the outcomes?

Specifically, have schools tried to partition students into courses based on achievement level, regardless of age? There would be the Math 1 course that might have 1st, 2nd, and 3rd graders in it, and Math 2 might have brighter 1st graders, etc.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by pmalynin on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @07:12PM (#8726745)
Well, yes and no. I can only speak from my experience of doing grades 1 through 7 in a Ukrainian school and then 8-12 in Canada. The year I went into school I was placed into the "Sapling" (Rostok) programme, which was a very accelerated "experimental" programme. I remember that in Grade 2 we were learning Venn Diagrams and basic set notation. And so on. By Grade 4 we were allegedly 2-3 years ahead of the "regular" system. Now when I got to Canada in Grade 8 I honestly did not know what to do with myself, the level of math I was exposed simply eclipsed what was being taught (Integer beads, the fuck?) and this has been my general experience of the school system up until Grade 12 where we started doing Calculus (which in "Sapling" was supposed to be done in Gr. 9-10).

The problem, I think, is not that kids can't learn (in fact the amount neuroplasticity in young children is simply off the charts, to the point where 6-7 year olds who can play really good violin are not something special), but is that the educational system simply does want to go there, to increase the levels of math taught in schools.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by cmollis on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @07:26PM (#8726817)
I believe this is also called 'business as usual'... but you actually put it much better.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by 21echoes on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:52PM (#8726408)
Coming from Delaware, most every school, public and private, that I know of partitions students into math courses based on achievement level. They typically don't let students go "out of grade" by more than a year, but that's a sizable amount in high school (e.g., some juniors learning the same material as some freshman). I didn't know there were places that didn't do it that way-- do your local schools not have advanced math & regular math tracks for their students?
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by slayed0 on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @06:06PM (#8726467)
Most schools do it at the high school and maybe jr. high level but I have never heard of this happening at the elementary level. We had separate math "groups" in elementary school but this was still within the same classroom and the more advanced group simply learned more about the concepts we were covering.

(Born, raised, and educated in California)

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by 21echoes on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @02:40AM (#8728115)
you're totally right -- I was talking about the jr. high and high school levels. Occasionally you'll see exceptions and some kids will be allowed up a grade or two in elementary, but it's not embedded in the process the way it is in jr. high and high school.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by jkimmel on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @07:15PM (#8726765)
I haven't heard of this being attempted, though I would surprised to find that it hasn't.

However, one reason it might be avoided is due to the potential negative effects tracking [1] strategies may have on some students. In my public school district, any form of tracking at the elementary level was difficult to implement due to pushback from parents, even in situations where the educators felt it was beneficial.

1 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tracking_%28education%29

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by analog31 on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @06:44PM (#8726632)
The elementary school that my kids attended had a couple of approaches. In higher grades, teachers paired up, and swapped classrooms so the stronger math teacher taught math to both classes. They also had "math specialists" who could float from one classroom to another, along with other kinds of special teachers and aides of various stripes.

A decent fraction of the kids learned math at home, making it hard to assess how well the school was actually doing.

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by eximius on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:46PM (#8726384)
I imagine that anywhere it is suggested it would be shot down by logistical concerns as well as sociological concerns of mixing age groups. You need a relatively common level of maturity, etc.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by tokenadult on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:38PM (#8726340)
Another Hacker News participant recently kindly shared in a comment a 2007 report by Educational Testing Service (ETS) titled "Teacher Quality in a Changing Policy Landscape: Improvements in the Teaching Pool".[1] The report showed that even though changes in teacher license requirements are boosting selection of higher-SAT-score rather than lower-SAT-score aspiring teachers, elementary teachers are drawn from college students who scored significantly lower than most college graduates on the SAT math section (Figure 21 in the report). The mean score of a recent prospective elementary school teacher in the United States when that teacher took the SAT for college entrance was barely above 500 on the math section.

Alas, in general, American schools are underperforming in teaching the most advantaged members of American society,[2] especially in mathematics,[3] while not doing well by the least advantaged young people in American society either.[4] The current efforts in preschools reported in the interesting article submitted here should be followed up by further reform of elementary school mathematics instruction. The book Knowing and Teaching Elementary Mathematics by Liping Ma[5] is especially informative about what to do to help all learners in the United States learn mathematics better in early schooling.

[1] http://www.ets.org/Media/Education_Topics/pdf/TQ_full_report...

[2] http://educationnext.org/when-the-best-is-mediocre/

http://educationnext.org/young-gifted-and-neglected/

[3] http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/

[4] http://www.oecd.org/pisa/pisaproducts/pisa2009/48165173.pdf

http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf

[5] https://www.engageny.org/sites/default/files/resource/attach...

http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/18/opinion/q-a-with-liping-ma...

http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematic...

Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by ludamad on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @01:30AM (#8727959)
Fun story, I literally cried in class when my elementary teacher insistently spent a whole lesson teaching BEDMAS wrong.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by IndianAstronaut on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:50PM (#8726397)
We should probably start to separate the teaching away from the supervising. Have some high quality instructional videos to demo to students along with some learning software. Use the instructors mainly to monitor and supervise students.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by userbinator on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:31PM (#8726303)
I'd like to know what the other 17942 seconds are being spent on, if not maths.
Re:Why Math Might Be the Secret to School Success by infinite8s on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @02:51PM (#8731267)
In general, free play and basic obedience training.