That's ridiculous. It has been a hell of a long time since antivirus applications affected the performance of a machine that way. The performance impact on any remotely modern machine is negligible.
And under no circumstance is it 'better off with the virus instead'.
Really, look at what they do. They pre-emptively scan every executable program you run at the least. Unless you're on an SSD, and probably not even then, this is a blocking operation that is impossible to not notice.
I think the main problem with antivirus on modern hardware is that commercial entities selling antivirus have to add bells and whistles. Few people would be willing to pay $x a year for a program they aren't even aware of running. So, that $x program makes sure you see it frequently by adding progress displays, toolbars, task bar items, etc. they also make sure they have stuff to report, even if that includes meaningless stuff such as registry keys on Windows. Detecting that meaningless stuff takes time, too.
I think you're spot on, but from the scope of a user who knows 90% of that stuff is BS, it's just another bullet point in the list of why I don't run AV software.
Earlier this year my Windows 7 machine with a Xeon W3565 (3.20 GHz) and 6GB RAM was slowing down noticeably every time Symantec Endpoint Protection 12 downloaded new definitions--something it did twice a day. I would consider this a reasonably powerful machine, and the slowdown had an effect on my ability to work.
Sense the tone. My tongue is clearly planted firmly in my cheek, and if you're too literal to recognise that, at least err on the side of not downvoting.
For the record, it's been about 4 years since I used antivirus software on Windows, maybe things have improved since then.
Do you have the benchmarks to support this claim? Unless things have improved considerably in the last year, simply doing a "git clone" took measurably longer even on a machine with an SSD. Microsoft Security Essentials had by far the lowest impact but it was still easily visible.