News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by toothbrush on Monday December 08, 2014 @06:36AM (#8715957)
Non-ironic question: do many people on HN use anti-virus of some form or another? Generally i'd probably trust people's judgement here as far as that goes. I naively use Linux with no externally accessible services running and no active anti-virus -- am i an idiot, should i clean-install everything ASAP? Or do yous reckon this is reasonable?

edit: clarification

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by Karunamon on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:19AM (#8716817)
Myself, no. It's been my experience that AV programs only warn after it's too late and you've already been owned by some nasty bit of code. Gee, thanks for nothing, time to flatten and reinstall. There's also the problem that literally every one I've found on a Windows platform appears to be designed for the lowest common denominator, easily frightened end user - scary warnings and dire predictions about what might happen if I don't renew my subscription (another problem, you have to subscribe to all of these on a recurring basis), Fisher-Price level UI, and so on.

To borrow a phrase from the /g/ community, I run Common Sense 2014 platinum edition. I.e. I don't download stuff from sketchy websites in general, I don't click email attachments, I don't use the Java web plugin, I do use things like Adblock and Noscript, etc.

If I do end up with a possibly suspicious file it gets sent off to a multi-scanner environment like VirusTotal or Jotti where I can get about 30 different opinions simultaneously.

The last few infections I've gotten were due to doing something boneheaded. Running something from a torrent without checking it first, or turning my browser security off temporarily and forgetting to reenable it.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by wmt on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:55AM (#8717043)
I'd rather get informed after getting owned than be unaware of an infection, at least you then know to bin your system and start fresh.

However, I'd also run EMET to make it a bit harder for an exploit getting past NoScript to operate correctly.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by Karunamon on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:28PM (#8718085)
The average vulnerability bug that you're likely to get having taken those precautions (no open ports to the internet, no live code running on untrusted webpages, etc ) easily sidesteps antivirus protection anyways.

I know, security is all about layers, but the usability and performance tradeoff gained for this paper tiger protection is not worth it, in my mind.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by grimman on Monday December 08, 2014 @06:57AM (#8716003)
I do, but a very basic kind; ie. Microsoft Security Essentials. That doesn't change my distrust of binaries though, and if I must run things I don't trust, I frequently do it in a VM. But the gist of it is that if I can alleviate some of the risk that comes from running Windows, with no discernible cost (ie. no noticeable system slowdown), I will do so (obviously in addition to "common sense" security measures). It'd be foolish not to.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by 01Michael10 on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:34AM (#8716918)
Microsoft Security Essentials/Windows Defender is one of the few antivirus software that fails AV-TEST certification.

http://www.av-test.org/en/antivirus/home-windows/windows-7/

http://www.av-test.org/en/antivirus/home-windows/windows-8/

How old is your PC that modern antivirus software noticeably slows it down?

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by toothbrush on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:07AM (#8716031)
Yeah, if i had to use Windows i would consider it essential to use some form of active anti-virus, but then again, i don't think that would alleviate my (unfounded?) general unease and feeling of still not being that "safe". But i'm trying to get a reality check here :)
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by freehunter on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:00AM (#8716390)
Windows 8 and Windows 10 come with AV built-in. It's generally "good enough" for home users. It will flag suspicious downloads before they download and before they run, and then scan them as they're running. With those two OSes, I never use an AV. I'd prefer user education over a stricter AV.

On the other hand, my work laptop is Red Hat 6 and Linux, Mac, or Windows, we're required to run Symantec by corporate policy. Then again I work for a security company, so...

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by oneeyedpigeon on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:33AM (#8716096)
Nope, I use OSX and, maybe naively, assume that gives me a greater level of protection than if I were running Windows. I'm also pretty careful when it comes to the most obvious attack vectors. In my experience, anti-virus software really slows a machine down, almost to the point that it might be better off with the virus instead - of course, that is highly dependent on the nature of the virus! I'm deeply cynical about virus companies and what involvement they might have in virus creation in the first place, although I understand how conspiracy-theory-crazy this might sound.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by ionised on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:17AM (#8716475)
> In my experience, anti-virus software really slows a machine down, almost to the point that it might be better off with the virus instead

That's ridiculous. It has been a hell of a long time since antivirus applications affected the performance of a machine that way. The performance impact on any remotely modern machine is negligible.

And under no circumstance is it 'better off with the virus instead'.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by Karunamon on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:15AM (#8716795)
I know of at least, Intego's product for Mac OS as late as a couple months ago (got it as part of a bundle, installed, was horrified, uninstalled a day later), as well as CheckPoint endpoint security live up to the stereotype of antivirus programs being bloated system hogs.

Really, look at what they do. They pre-emptively scan every executable program you run at the least. Unless you're on an SSD, and probably not even then, this is a blocking operation that is impossible to not notice.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by Someone on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:43PM (#8718182)
But Mac OS X scans all code you run to verify code signatures, doesn't it? If so, the performance impact of scanning isn't that high.

I think the main problem with antivirus on modern hardware is that commercial entities selling antivirus have to add bells and whistles. Few people would be willing to pay $x a year for a program they aren't even aware of running. So, that $x program makes sure you see it frequently by adding progress displays, toolbars, task bar items, etc. they also make sure they have stuff to report, even if that includes meaningless stuff such as registry keys on Windows. Detecting that meaningless stuff takes time, too.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by Karunamon on Monday December 08, 2014 @02:13PM (#8718385)
Taking a hash of the binary and verifying that against a few-k signature at a known location is kind of on a different level performancewise than scanning literally the entire binary looking for various known signatures and applying heuristic analysis. (Windows does the same thing, FWIW)

I think you're spot on, but from the scope of a user who knows 90% of that stuff is BS, it's just another bullet point in the list of why I don't run AV software.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by emddudley on Monday December 08, 2014 @12:49PM (#8717796)
Hey man, just because you haven't experienced antivirus slowdowns does not mean they do not occur. Perhaps the slowdowns these people are experiencing are due to a system configuration that you have not used.

Earlier this year my Windows 7 machine with a Xeon W3565 (3.20 GHz) and 6GB RAM was slowing down noticeably every time Symantec Endpoint Protection 12 downloaded new definitions--something it did twice a day. I would consider this a reasonably powerful machine, and the slowdown had an effect on my ability to work.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by oneeyedpigeon on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:30AM (#8716897)
"almost to the point that it might be better off with the virus instead - of course, that is highly dependent on the nature of the virus!"

Sense the tone. My tongue is clearly planted firmly in my cheek, and if you're too literal to recognise that, at least err on the side of not downvoting.

For the record, it's been about 4 years since I used antivirus software on Windows, maybe things have improved since then.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by acdha on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:07PM (#8717949)
> It has been a hell of a long time since antivirus applications affected the performance of a machine that way

Do you have the benchmarks to support this claim? Unless things have improved considerably in the last year, simply doing a "git clone" took measurably longer even on a machine with an SSD. Microsoft Security Essentials had by far the lowest impact but it was still easily visible.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by wglb on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:20PM (#8718033)
On one of my systems I do, but that is required by my client when I attach my device to their network. And my wife's desktop has MS security essentials.

Keep in mind that when New York Times was hacked a while back that 50 kinds of malware was found, and only one of them was detected by multiple AV products.

So depending upon AV to protect you is fraught with peril.

Consider the possibility that adding AV to your system increases the attack surface. Does anyone remember the Michelangelo Virus from a while back? A well-known firm' AV software caused more damage than the virus itself. (It wiped out the boot sector.)

Don't count on AV to protect you.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by busterarm on Monday December 08, 2014 @03:42PM (#8719043)
Total non-antivirus user here.

I worked for 5 years in the trenches in the anti-malware industry and countless times I've seen antivirus software completely hose up computers and worse: having its own insecurity and hooks into the Windows API used directly to infect a system (I'm looking at you, AVG circa fall'09).

Most importantly, no antivirus seems to do a very good job of dealing with emerging threats and malware is rapidly getting more sophisticated than the AV vendors can cope with. The major problems these days all seem to come down to an insufficiently secured operating system.

The only real, effective antivirus is user education.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by acdha on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:16PM (#8718004)
Not since a brief period in the 90s. You're much better spending your time staying on top of updates and not having plugins disabled in your default browser. As long as you don't run an email client which executes code[1] trying to enumerate badness is a losing game - it's too easy to try to bypass signatures, particularly since a malware author can simply test against the various AV clients before releasing something.

1. i.e. not Outlook managed by an enterprise IT department

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by psuter on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:21AM (#8716830)
I do on my (Windows) work laptop, because the company that owns it justifiably insists I do. It's completely transparent, except for the odd days where an upgrade to VirtualBox or VMPlayer will introduce new "hardening" features, that the AV software will happily flag as a terrible threat.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by kodr on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:46AM (#8716143)
it depends on the market share. Windows is the most used OS, that's why you see virus on it. I heard OSX started getting some after becoming popular once again a few years back.

As long as linux isn't too mainstream, it will be less a problem. But you could still use ClamAV if you share some files with other computers.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by toothbrush on Monday December 08, 2014 @08:05AM (#8716195)
"Sharing some files" seems vague though: i'm not sure if i correctly understand the attack vectors, but apart from running untrusted binaries (and as a normal user even that doesn't sound too scary -- or does it?), i guess it'd be via things like targeted exploitation e.g. buffer overflows or somesuch? Other than that it seems unlikely (but far from impossible of course) that an adversary could simply make my machine do evil stuff like spamming or leaking my files. (edit 2:) Also, i have to trust my distribution... That's actually the part i find most worrying.

edit: Also, i'm not sure i agree with you that Windows being the most widely used OS is the reason for the proliferation of viruses for that platform. As i understand it (not wanting to start a flamewar here, i genuinely don't know), it also suffers from some poor security architecture -- but maybe my information is outdated. But sure, the fact that "everyone" uses it makes it a more valuable target, of course.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by danielweber on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:31AM (#8716554)
At a high level, Windows and OSX share the same general security architecture: most stuff happens as a user, with root called in when necessary.

The single best advice to not getting infected is to not do stupid stuff.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by kodr on Monday December 08, 2014 @08:10AM (#8716211)
your linux could be used as a shared drive (samba), without executing stuff. It could be nice to scan files if they can be used on other OSes.

As for Windows being unsafe, sure, it's easier to propagate stuff since you have root access. But like I said, viruses on OSX do exist.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by toothbrush on Monday December 08, 2014 @08:12AM (#8716219)
I'm not sure i understand: do you mean i should scan my files, in case i share a file which would infect a Windows box? If so, i don't think i care. If you mean something else (i.e. somebody planting evil files on my "share"), please elaborate.

I also stated i do not run external-facing services. That applies to the Samba example, too (although i was fibbing: i allow keypair-only login via sshd).

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by kodr on Monday December 08, 2014 @08:15AM (#8716229)
> in case i share a file which would infect a Windows box?

yes, that's what I meant.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by justfane on Monday December 08, 2014 @08:41AM (#8716328)
Nope. Haven't used A/V in 3 years now. On OSX, Windows or linux. When you're more tech friendly you know to sandboxie things that seem suspicious or test in a vm.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by clarry on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:45AM (#8716633)
So you sandbox all the documents and images and movies and whatnots that come from untrusted sources? Because they all look suspicious? And after testing, how do you know you're infected?
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by justfane on Monday December 08, 2014 @11:50PM (#8721099)
Depends upon source of document; mostly now a days i can throw a document in google drive or a web editor and see it. PDF to HTML works good too; Movies are all from trusted sources streamed via Linux Server... So if its untrusted the clip would most likely loop with a blurred out screen saying i need a codec pack.

I don't do much locally other than write code. I use Web IDE's, Web Editors, Online Markup, Stream via HTML5... Not much to download now-a-days.

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by tptacek on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:40AM (#8716610)
No.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by HCIdivision17 on Monday December 08, 2014 @04:40PM (#8719372)
Whelp, if that's not a succint answer I dunno what is. I ended up asking the search engine what you thought on the topic [0], and I think it was informative. At least, it made me feel a bit less bad about my stance. (Confirmation bias / appeal to authority ahoy.)

[0] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=tptacek+antivirus#!/comment/foreve...

Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by toothbrush on Monday December 08, 2014 @05:47PM (#8719740)
I'll take the bait: what kind of system would you run? Linux? No evil web browser plugins? A personal computer which you never use to browse the web (RMS style)? Anything more exotic?
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by tptacek on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:01PM (#8720078)
I have a Macbook, like most of us. I turn the firewall on, and I use Chrome. That's about it.
Re:Antivirus Companies Shouldn’t Have Hidden What They Knew ... by etiam on Monday December 08, 2014 @12:03PM (#8717466)
To all?