News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by Zariel on Monday December 08, 2014 @04:10AM (#8715589)
Isn't it running ontop of the Mesos kernel, which has been around for longer than Kubernetes?
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by presspot on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:32AM (#8716561)
A bit of the history:

The Mesosphere DCOS is built around the Apache Mesos kernel

The Mesos kernel was developed at UC Berkeley in 2009 [1].

Spark was written as a sample app on top of it [2].

Ben Hindman and his colleagues at the UC Berkeley AmpLab had always envisioned Mesos as a kernel inside of a full-blown operating system [3]. They finally brought it to market.

[1] https://www.usenix.org/legacy/event/nsdi11/tech/full_papers/...

[2] "We have implemented Mesos in 10,000 lines of C++. The system scales to 50,000 (emulated) nodes and uses ZooKeeper for fault tolerance. To evaluate Mesos, we have ported three cluster computing systems to run over it: Hadoop, MPI, and the Torque batch scheduler. To validate our hypothesis that specialized frameworks provide value over general ones, we have also built a new framework on top of Mesos called Spark, optimized for iterative jobs where a dataset is reused in many parallel operations, and shown that Spark can outperform Hadoop by 10x in iterative machine learning workloads." ibid.

[3] http://people.csail.mit.edu/matei/papers/2011/hotcloud_datac...

Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by Zariel on Monday December 08, 2014 @04:38PM (#8719360)
Yep, also had input from Google around the time there were deploying (or building) their new scheduler to replace Borg, Omega.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by presspot on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:34AM (#8716574)
So, yes, Mesos predates Kubernetes by many years.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by kelseyhightower on Monday December 08, 2014 @05:18AM (#8715771)
That was my first question as well, but there must be a reason why Kubernetes was brought in.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by kozyraki on Monday December 08, 2014 @11:11AM (#8717144)
My view on this the following: Mesos is similar to the kernel of a conventional operating system (e.g. Linux). It provides very basic services (scheduling, interrupts, device management, etc) and a syscall API. But nobody wants to program to this API. Hence you need libc or other similar libraries to provide a higher level API that programmers use to interact with the kernel. Kubernetes, Marathon, Aurora, etc are such libraries, each optimizing for a different class of applications and providing different functionality. The two (the kernel and the libraries) need each other.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by boulos on Monday December 08, 2014 @12:08PM (#8717494)
I see what you're saying Christos, but I think I'd prefer "runtime" over library (library sounds like it's just a little convenience).
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by kozyraki on Monday December 08, 2014 @10:09PM (#8720762)
Sure, pthreads and other thread libraries that include a lot of runtime functionality would probably be a better analogy.
Re:Mesosphere Announces First Data Center OS and $36M in Fun... by presspot on Monday December 08, 2014 @09:38AM (#8716597)
I see Kubernetes as more of a programming model, not an operating system. It provides a way to express services and have them scheduled onto a datacenter. The rocket-science of how you schedule those workloads and optimize them in the same partition as other workloads is what you need a DCOS for.

In the Mesosphere world, Kubernetes is a "datacenter service" which is installed on your datacenter so that you can run Kubernetes workloads. You might also want to install DEIS to run DEIS-organized workloads. Or Spark, for Spark workloads... and so on -- all multitenant in the cluster. This is what the DCOS is uniquely good at, and why it qualifies as a true operating system.