News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday December 06, 2014 @01:04PM (#8709735)
>This article, like most others, overlooks the primary reason the A-10 has been slated for retirement for so long even though no one contests its effectiveness in its role. Due to the way the aircraft was designed, it has very limited upgradeability compared to most US military aircraft.

The real reason is that it has always been the red-headed step-child of the ch-Air Force. There has never been any real interest in the CAS role from the mgmt, other than to keep that turf away from the Army and Marine Corps.

>While the airframe still makes for a great weapons platform, the sensor suites, avionics, and countermeasures are obsolete, and not in a good way. They've been doing a lot of nasty hacks to allow it to support modern weapon systems and electronics but there are a growing number of important capabilities that simply cannot be "backported" to that airframe.

I was about to make a similar comment that the A10 performs its role well despite having relatively primitive weapons / targeting systems. But I disagree about the reason for the obsolete weapons / electronics. Sensors and computers have only gotten smaller and better, and I am afraid I don't understand why you think that the A10 cannot be fitted with proper electronics and sensors.

>This has been increasing its vulnerability to more advanced threats

The definition of a CAS role practically implies that the airplane can only operate in an arena where air-superiority is assured. The A10 is by definition vulnerable to "more advanced threats" and so will any acceptable substitute share similar vulnerabilities.

>Its shelf-life has been extended by virtue of it being used in practice against adversaries with unsophisticated weaponry.

Exactly the kind of adversary it is being deployed against, though it has proven itself against others as well.

>It is a relic of the Cold War not just in its history but, unfortunately, also in its defenses and weaponry with no obvious upgrade path. To replace it with something that could support the capabilities they desire, they would need to design a completely new airframe.

I agree, and I hope they call it the A10-mkII, and that it is practically a modern rebuild of the A10.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by jandrewrogers on Saturday December 06, 2014 @01:21PM (#8709787)
The vulnerabilities and limitations of concern are not addressed by air superiority. It lacks modern protection from more sophisticated ground threats.

Basically, the US military is concerned because they know that they already have ground threat capabilities that would significantly reduce the survivability of platforms like the A-10. Looking forward, they expect this level of weapon sophistication to trickle down to increasingly unsophisticated adversaries. The A-10 lacks the power systems required to drive modern defenses and weapons.

It is no different than how the US military has been planning for the obsolescence of heavy armor.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by mturmon on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:32PM (#8709926)
As an example of the kind of losses that can result from better equipped adversaries, consider what has happened to the Russian Su-25 CAS in conflicts in Georgia and in the Chechen wars. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sukhoi_Su-25#2008_Russia.E2.80....). Quite a few have been shot down. MANPADS are getting more omnipresent, and overall theater air superiority will not always be enough.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by tim333 on Saturday December 06, 2014 @03:50PM (#8710155)
Not sure any of the shooting downs have been with MANPADS though.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by mturmon on Saturday December 06, 2014 @05:34PM (#8710457)
You have to read the link:

"On 4 October 1999, a Su-25 was shot down by a MANPADS during a reconnaissance mission over the village of Tolstoy-Yurt killing its pilot. The wings of the aircraft were put on a pedestal in the central square in Grozny."

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by techdragon on Saturday December 06, 2014 @09:38PM (#8711044)
Ok there's the fist problem. Why is a CAS plane doing recon?

The CAS role consists of two things: 1st, bring death from above with heavy firepower and weapons capable of seriously damaging and mobile threat in the area of engagement; 2nd, be the invincible angels, surviving everything from small arms fire to light Flak cannons through to even a stinger missile or two.

The survival part of their role necessitates not going in blind, a CAS plane has no place doing a recon flight. It would be like riding a wounded horse through a hungry pride of lions to check on how hungry they are.

In a world of satellites and drones, recon is their job, they are unmatched at it, smaller, safer, cheaper. Tasking a CAS airframe with recon work is going to cost you a plane, and possibly a pilot as well.

This is why the A-10 remains effective. It's a bone saw or a rib spreader, designed for a task. Yes these days with a da vinci robot you don't need to crack open the ribs as often, but when you need the rib cage open or you need to saw through the humerus to amputate, those are the tools you use.

The A-10 is a dedicated specialist the airforce wishes to replace with more general purpose planes, which may work some of the time, but won't work all the time.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by nl on Sunday December 07, 2014 @05:46AM (#8711843)
I think you are reading a lot into a Wikipedia summary of some fairly vague reporting.

I suspect the "reconnaissance" was tactical recon: they were hunting things to shoot up. They didn't have people on the ground there.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by tim333 on Sunday December 07, 2014 @12:37PM (#8712874)
Ah - fair enough.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:13PM (#8709884)
>The vulnerabilities and limitations of concern are not addressed by air superiority. It lacks modern protection from more sophisticated ground threats.

>Basically, the US military...

Chair force types itching for a new jet.

> Looking forward, they expect this level of weapon sophistication to trickle down to increasingly unsophisticated adversaries.

That is a totally reasonable assumption. I agree that MANPADS may prove problematic. There is the potential to develop countermeasure for these, just not the will, which is a shame because the rotors would benefit from it as well. But, the AF doesn't care for those, either.

>The A-10 lacks the power systems required to drive modern defenses and weapons.

You state this as if it were some kind of objective proven fact. It isn't. It may be the case that some existing weapons system can't be bolted on; but it is not a credible assertion to say that that a suitable solution cannot be developed.

>It is no different than how the US military has been planning for the obsolescence of heavy armor.

It is quite different. Heavy armor is useless, everyone knows it, and to the .mil's credit they are phasing it out. The A10 fills an important CAS role that other platforms can't replace. The F35 definitely isn't going to perform well as an A10 replacement. The Apache works well, but for some reason (sortie cost / availability?) it hasn't obsoleted the A10. Some yet undeveloped unmanned drone might be able to do so, but that is yet to be demonstrated.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by tim333 on Saturday December 06, 2014 @04:40PM (#8710316)
>The Apache ... for some reason ... hasn't obsoleted the A10

I think the Apache's are not able to take being hit nearly as well as A10s, plus have less fire power and take longer to get places.

There's an article here on the problems http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/war_stories/...

And a story here where Warthogs saved 60 US soldiers in 2013, where "because people were shooting all over the place, the JTAC didn't feel safe bringing in helicopters in to evacuate the wounded personnel."

http://www.af.mil/News/ArticleDisplay/tabid/223/Article/4667...

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday December 06, 2014 @06:10PM (#8710550)
>I think the Apache's are not able to take being hit nearly as well as A10s,

No, they definitely can't! But they are much better at avoiding taking fire in the first place.

>plus have less fire power and take longer to get places.

This, and the higher maint-man/hour per flight hour.

>"...the JTAC didn't feel safe bringing in helicopters in to evacuate the wounded personnel."

Thanks for that link, hadn't seen it.

>...the convoy's commander approved the pilots to engage "danger-close." The term is meant to clearly communicate to the ground and air forces that the need for support is so grave the ground commander is willing to accept the potential risk to the friendly unit for the life-saving employment from the air.

Scheisse. Gives you chills if you really think about it.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by PhasmaFelis on Sunday December 07, 2014 @02:02AM (#8711520)
A related concept is "final protective fire," which means something like "We are being overrun, please drop artillery shells directly on our position, we're in foxholes and they're not so hopefully it will work out." Scary.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by bdunbar on Saturday December 06, 2014 @07:45PM (#8710784)
My company gunny (1988) got a bronze star when, as an 19-year old mortarman in 1969, aimed his tube straight up and dropped rounds all over his company's position, saving the day.

I know this because he grabbed me by the scruff of my neck and made me read it, as part of up-close and personal counseling.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by elpachuco on Sunday December 07, 2014 @12:01PM (#8712741)
I really don't understand what you are saying. Are you saying that he fired upon his own people and got a medal because of it?
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by bdunbar on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:08AM (#8727782)
He was with a rifle company, in mortar squad. The company was over-run during an attack, at night: Marines in fighting holes, bad guys running around in the open, a very chaotic situation.

To eradicate the enemy, and save his company, he pointed the tube of his mortar straight up, dropped a shit-load of rounds down the tube, one at a time. The rounds went up (pretty far, but I no longer recall how high up they go) and came back down all over the place.

Risky, but Marines, generally, were in their holes, the bad guy were not, and so were more exposed to blast and shrapnel.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by hga on Sunday December 07, 2014 @12:58PM (#8712933)
Exactly that, "his own people" including himself, which is arguably more brave than calling more powerful artillery fire on your own position. See PhasmaFelis comment in this subthread; this is the true last resort after final protective fire.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by gaius on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:25AM (#8716073)
In that situation they flip a coin, you either get a medal or a court martial.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by quanticle on Sunday December 07, 2014 @12:09AM (#8711310)
>No, they definitely can't! But they are much better at avoiding taking fire in the first place.

From what I've read, that really depends on the terrain. The Apache, from what sources I've seen, was really designed to take on Soviet ground forces in Germany. It's a tank hunter, designed to hide around and behind rolling hills, make quick attack passes on advancing armor columns, and then get the hell out of Dodge before AA can shoot back. Unlike its Soviet counterpart, the Mi-24 "Hind", the Apache isn't very well armored. This makes it not very well suited to the sort of mission where it has to loiter in an area and provide fire support for friendly forces.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by Semiapies on Saturday December 06, 2014 @09:45PM (#8711058)
It should!

Here's a video of something like that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPvVacN41lY

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by zobzu on Sunday December 07, 2014 @01:14PM (#8713000)
Cost per sortie on the apache. They prefer sending vipers which arent as good but cheaper to operate. A10 isnt even really in the picture.

Another thing is the limited amount of aircraft carriers, their lack of agility. F35s and helis can take off smaller, cheaper,more numerous amphibious vehicule carriers. Thats why theyre even making the f35...

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by gaius on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:23AM (#8716064)
We keep hearing how heavy armour is useless... Then events keep happening that demonstrate otherwise. You can't hold territory from the air. You just can't. The Russians know this, and they know the psychological effect tanks have too.
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by unsigner on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:32PM (#8709925)
Interesting about heavy armor - can you point me at something to read?
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:53PM (#8709975)
Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by marktangotango on Sunday December 07, 2014 @04:57AM (#8711780)
Those articles merely state the Army doesn't want to upgrades, they want to wait until a new version of the M1 is available in a few years? I took the above conversation to mean that there's a (universal?) consensus that heavy armor's time is past. These links don't support that.

At the end of the day, it's kind of hard to do a thunder run [1] without tanks.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Baghdad_%282003%29#Th...

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday December 07, 2014 @10:51AM (#8712488)
>I took the above conversation to mean that there's a (universal?) consensus that heavy armor's time is past. These links don't support that.

No, those links don't. Forgive me, it's the most recent / best that I could find in a single web-query. I also didn't find a better link for you after searching again today. (search results too full of RTS game related junk)

The tank's day is done though, and while we'll maintain a small number of them, our war strategies do no rely on them, nor should they. If that were so, then any opposing force with one (of the many available) Javelin missile[1] like capability could stop our tank forces in their tracks. Killing tanks cheaply is a solved problem.

[1] See also Shershen, Metis, Spike, etc.

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by bro-kaizen on Sunday December 07, 2014 @05:30PM (#8713856)
> " thunder run "

Didn't they used to call that Blitzkrieg?

Re:America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane by hga on Sunday December 07, 2014 @06:11PM (#8713995)
Yep, but it's more like good combined arms operations (the use of multiple combat arms like armor, artillery and air, you might start with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_arms) and a "cooperative" enemy. Like France in WWII.

I get the impression that Saddam's conception of war was strictly WWI era (right down to chemical warfare, although perhaps the issue there is why it wasn't widely used in WWII (ask for details if you're interested)), although this was most relevant in the First Gulf War, where we tricked him into thinking he would receive a frontal attack, and we hooked around his right flank. This avoided the expense of a frontal attack, he was no doubt hoping would cause us problems back home or worse.

For the rematch, well, he certainly had a lot less force, I would suspect the "thunder run" might vaguely resemble Patton's dash after the breakout from Normandy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_S._Patton#Normandy_brea...), or if you want Nazi analogies, the crushing of small/relatively weak countries prior to France.