News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by cpks on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:02AM (#8703848)
That actually doesn't seem unreasonable to prohibit...
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by ge0rg on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:11AM (#8703889)
I am not so sure about it. Blocking/prohibiting information will only lead to increased interest, and it will never be possible to block all instances of that information.

A far superior approach would be better social care for people who might commit suicide, but that would cost money and effort, as opposed to a symbolic act of prohibition.

Besides, Internet filters always start with the really evil things, like suicide instructions or child pornography, and once established they are slowly expanded to cover terrorism, homosexual pornography, regular pornography, copyright infringement and finally political opposition. You really do not want to go down that slippery slope.

One example of this is the UK porn filter which is now also used to block jihad propaganda: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/nov/14/uk-isps-to...

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by vidarh on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:21AM (#8703929)
> One example of this is the UK porn filter which is now also used to block jihad propaganda

The article does not support your claim.

EDIT: To clarify, as per the reply I gave further down: There is no country wide "UK porn filter". There are voluntary filters put in place by each of the largest providers that are wildly inconsistent in what they block, and wildly ineffective.

Most of the filtering is also opt-in or opt-out for most of these providers, mostly apart from blocks targeting child porn.

Outside of the top 5-6 providers, many smaller providers don't filter at all.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by dsp1234 on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:28AM (#8703953)
They have also agreed to ensure that terrorist and extremist material is captured by their filters to prevent children and young people coming across radicalising material.
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by vidarh on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:37AM (#8703978)
The point being there is no single government mandated "UK porn filter". Each of the biggest ISPs have individual filters. Many of the smaller ISPs don't have filters.

EDIT: Maybe whoever downvoted might care to explain why? The comment is factual. There is no legally mandated filtering across the board in the UK. The only legally mandated filtering is a small set of specific court orders targeting a group of the largest ISPs, requiring them to filter specific sites (Pirate Bay being the main target).

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by ge0rg on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:23AM (#8704134)
The point made originally was that Internet filtering is bad for society. The fact that there is not a single mandated filter but a set of different(?) filters at the major ISPs, which do not even have a legal basis, is just making the situation worse for end users. While I admit that my original wording was misleading, I can not see how the enacted back-and-forth contributes to the discussion.

From the media coverage of the "UK porn filter" that I followed, the government said they would make a law to require filtering, then the ISPs jumped on it and implemented their filtering systems, and then the proposed laws failed / stalled.

I do not know enough about the UK ISP landscape to be able to determine if all users of the major ISPs can switch to a non-filtering one, and at what additional expense.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by vidarh on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:43AM (#8704201)
> From the media coverage of the "UK porn filter" that I followed, the government said they would make a law to require filtering, then the ISPs jumped on it and implemented their filtering systems, and then the proposed laws failed / stalled.

That's not quite how it went. The government hinted that it might do so unless the ISPs implemented filters that people had to ask to opt-out of.

The ISPs jumped on adding a filtering choice for users in the form of a checkbox when they sign on. Something many of them had before. Some providers - notably the mobile providers - have defaulted to opt-out (since long before the government interference, on the basis that e.g. pay as you go sims can easily be obtained without providing id, and as a result they don't know if their subscribers are over 18), while most regular ISPs default to opt-in.

The government subsequently then did not propose any law, and issued triumphant press releases about protecting children, after Camerons advisers had been pleading with ISPs to at least make the checkboxes default to ticked. Largely the result was that they got mocked for not actually achieving any changes that made a difference to anything at all.

All the largest ISPs still filters child porn regardless of subscriber choice, but that's the only thing you're not able to turn off. Even that filtering is not covering nearly all ISPs.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by Muromec on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:13AM (#8704097)
>You really do not want to go down that slippery slope.

Russia already did. Suicide filters were introduced two years ago or something. Now they are used to block porn, political opponents, sites about drugs and whatever government wants to declare "extrimism". Ah, and last time they added copyright infringement to the list.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by arpa on Friday December 05, 2014 @09:12AM (#8704528)
Oops. Now who could have guessed that filtering could be used for such purposes?
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by Muromec on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:58AM (#8708675)
Everybody did. Russians know shit about their government.
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by DanBC on Friday December 05, 2014 @08:24AM (#8704348)
There are different "UK porn filters". That alone suggests that the IWF list has not been expanded into general purpose censorship, and that other methods are used for different illegal content.
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by arpa on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:07AM (#8703872)
why? Would it be reasonable to burn/censor books dealing with such matter, maybe describing some methods of suicide? Homicide? Different political views?
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by vidarh on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:19AM (#8703922)
Suicide is a thorny issue, because while on hand there are free speech issues with it, and some people do think it through and have rational reasons for wanting to commit suicide (e.g. facing a protracted degenerative disease that causes lots of pain might be one), most people who are suicidal are most at risk as a result of temporary emotional states that they have little or no control over.

Accordingly, adding very small roadblocks for people who are contemplating suicide can have substantial effects in reducing suicide (an example is the restriction on amount of paracetamol/acetaminophen that can be sold per transaction in the UK), and people who attempt suicide and fail often express relief afterwards.

I'm not sure where the line ought to go, but that in any case puts it in a very different category from e.g. homicide or different political views.

Censoring suicide instructions is probably by far the least objectionable part of Russian censorship.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by pra on Friday December 05, 2014 @09:02AM (#8704483)
Do you really suppose that state-wide censorship machine is a justifiable and "a very small roadblock" for people contemplating suicide? Are you serious?

Let's put the fact aside that these "instructions" are a joke; consider a wikipedia page http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_methods. Should this page be censored? Since when removing the definition of a word in a dictionary makes a thing disappear? Sure, suicide is an issue, sure, it's better not to have it, but to censor anything mentioning it sounds like a bad adaptation of Orwells' 1984.

What's the problem with suicide prevention, suicide hotlines, destigmatisation of mental health problems? I'll tell you what's the problem - it doesn't help you instill an intellectual control system, censorship and, quite frankly, a form mind control (via media filters).

A censorship by any other reason is still a tool of oppression. It is not a tool for solving problems.

Also, could you please provide a reference to a single study published in a respectable peer-reviewed journal of psychology, which supports your claim that small roadblocks, and especially restriction on amount of paracetamol/acetaminophen sold per transaction helps prevent suicide.

Coincidentally, paracetamol poisoning a retarded way to go - it is probably more painless to kill oneself by drinking a lot of water (6l per 3hrs is enough to kill you). Why aren't drinking water sales not limited then? In fact, why aren't we all absolved of our personal responsibilities and taken care by the state, like some kind of a nanny?

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by tomjen3 on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:14PM (#8706609)
As long as you can get into your car, remove the seat belt and run 200 miles an hour into a bridge support the idea of censoring suicide is stupid.

Of course the people who fail express relief - if they don't we might lock them up. The same goes for your blanket arguments about temporary emotional states, _when you threaten a man with prison (whatever the hell you want to call it) he is way likely to say whatever he thinks you want to get out_.

Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by binarymax on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:10AM (#8703880)
The problem with this position is that censorship is a very slippery slope. What happens when the boundaries keep getting pushed. Where do you stop? Who decides what is Ok and what is not? What may be amoral to one may not be amoral to another.
Re:Github may block content if they receive a valid request ... by icebraining on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:10AM (#8703881)
Even if it's legitimate to prohibit, it's even more futile than trying to stop file sharing. At least a copy of The Hunger Games doesn't fit in a 4chan comment.