TextSecure-enabled WhatsApp beats Telegram on a pure engineering level; we don't even need to reach politics to prefer it.
In contrast, observing the network traffic, debugging the application, and examining the decompiled binary will tell you exactly what's going on.
This cannot be caught by observing the network traffic and it is really hard to catch by reversing or tracing the binary. Especially if the compromise is not an outright srand(0), but an algorithmic weakness. Then, even if it is found, then it's virtually impossible to determine whether it was benign or deliberate. Now further consider the implications if an app uses a 3rd party PRNG such as those supplied by the operating system or the hardware or if it gets its PRNG seed data from an inherently untrusted sources (such as the OS).
I mean ... the source code being open is obviously irrelevant to the security of a pre-built binary and the adherence to the open specs is not much of an assurance either, because of the PRNG angle. In practical terms it really means that you have to have trust in a product vendor. Period. Because there is always a way for them to screw you over and to get away with it.
People can give you whatever source code they want. That doesn't meant it's the same as what's running in production. While this is tin-foil-hat paranoia, when it comes to encryption software in this post-snowden world it is definitely more reliable to reverse-engineer the binary & network traffic than to just believe the provided source-code to encryption in a popular social app. Or compile the app from source that has been verified by trusted people. Definitely not believing that a binary blob running on your hardware is the same as the provided source.
That said, it's also good to ask for source code so later on when reverse-engineering shows something different you've now caught the offending party in a lie; which is something good to have on record to refer to later on.
So you are telling me if you had the source code you would not be able to verify the code and also use the code to fully verify the expected behavior of the binary?
https://whispersystems.org/blog/a-whisper/
(Just replace "Whisper" with "Signal" :)
Because the widely used chat app I happen to be using does that for all communications without any special direction from me. I didn't even know they were encrypted, it just happened!
Isn't that a pretty dangerous assertion in itself? It's a private company running private servers that you have no control over and no ability to tell whether or not an external entity has accessed your data.
FTFY
As far as you know. Why would they publicise it if they did? How can you prove they've not been forced to?
Also if you look at the forums about justice and advocates etc you can see that Microsoft provides user data but not Google or Facebook (except very big and obvious crimes). But Microsoft, oh it is like your best enemy. So my point is that you will hear it (except spying) if it is a legal request.
Really? In their FAQ [1] they state:
> ordinary chats use client-server/server-client encryption and are stored securely encrypted on our servers
What's your source?
https://core.telegram.org/methods#working-with-messages
...where's the encryption on message histories? There is none. If the data is encrypted server-side, it's with keys that live on the servers. In other words, the encryption provides no value and the servers are "trusted." The point of end to end encryption is not to have to trust servers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moxie_Marlinspike
If there's one person that I would trust with my privacy, it's Moxie.
Gee, sorry TextSecure is not on your platform of choice yet...
I can think of worse things then something being located/developed in the USA...
Beyond doubts with the protocol itself, I think the more important consideration is that most people never use it. Telegram is not encrypted by default. Users have to create a special "secret chat" with contacts that is ephemeral, and some Telegram clients don't even support that mode. Last I checked, there was no way to have group "secret chats" in any client at all.
The result is a situation where many users seem to think that Telegram is somehow secure by default, when it definitely isn't. Telegram even stores plaintext copies of everyone's entire message history on the server for multi-device sync.
I think what Telegram is doing right now is dangerous, and potentially another Lavabit in the making. I'd like to see them incorporate a modern end to end encryption protocol, and enable it by default.
To be transparent, I work on TextSecure and am involved with the WhatsApp end-to-end encryption project.