News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers by s-phi-nl on Monday December 01, 2014 @05:20PM (#8684321)
I have experience of performers, when not accompanied by a piano, choose to perform intervals closer to 1.50000 than 1.50001, so it seems they prefer them.

However, the answer is more complicated than that. Quoting directly from my acoustics textbook:

"Research on the intervals played or sung by skilled musicians shows substantial variability in the intonation from performance to performance. These variations are frequently larger than the differences between the various tunings. Studies of large numbers of performances have shown that deviations from equal temperament are usually in the direction of Pythagorean intervals (Ward 1970).

"Several investigators have found that performers tend to stretch their intervals (including octaves), even when unaccompanied by a piano. Many choral conductors prefer the third in a chord slightly raised, especially in sustained chords or cadences, to avoid any suggestion of 'flatting' the chord, a particular nemesis of choirs. How much of the apparent preference for sharpened intervals is due to constant exposure to pianos with stretched turning is difficult to determine."

The Science of Sound, Third Edition, by Rossing, Moore, and Wheeler, p. 187.

(Ward 1970) is "Musical Perception" by W.D. Ward, in Foundations of Modern Auditory Theory, Ed. J. Tobias.

Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers by the_duck on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:28PM (#8688827)
> Several investigators have found that performers tend to stretch their intervals

Johan Sundberg has excellent examples of this "stretched" tuning in some of his talks. He claims that musicians stretch intervals intentionally in order to add excitement to particular passages. The link below contrasts equally tempered and "stretched" versions of the same musical phrases.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CxFVjKMsaTc&t=50m32s

To my ears the stretched versions are far more engaging, especially the example with the tenor Jussi Bjorling around 52:50.