News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by chimeracoder on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:29PM (#8682728)
Not a direct response to what you said, but since this is a common discussion on HN, I just want to get some facts straight pre-emptively:

1) The AMA has nothing to do with limiting the supply of doctors in the US

2) The AAMC (not the AMA) formerly limited the number of medical students per-year in the US, but they stopped this practice sometime around 2004 with the stated goal of increasing the number of medical school graduates.

3) Even if we doubled the number of medical school graduates overnight, we still would not have more practicing physicians in the US, because the bottleneck occurs during residency (after medical school) - there are a very limited number of residency slots.

4) Residency programs in the US are funded by the federal government through Medicare, so increasing the number of practicing physicians would require increasing funding to hospitals that offer residency programs by increasing spending on Medicare. This is both politically complicated and incredibly expensive (training a resident is very cost-intensive when you look at the big picture).

So yes, there is definitely an issue with the number of practicing physicians in the US, but fixing it requires Congressional authorization to increase spending (and not just by a little), so it's unlikely to change anytime soon.

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by mahyarm on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:47PM (#8682844)
So how about a residency system that doesn't depend on medicare government funding? Or accepting foreign residency programs? I wouldn't think canadian, scandianvian, british, german, australlian, etc residencies and doctors should be considered invalid for example. From what I know, even being a Sweden trained doctor makes it hard to transfer into the USA and get a licence.

Residents from what I know are not well paid, what makes it a profit cost center for them that they require government funding for it?

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by idaniboy on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:08AM (#8685814)
The reason why foreign residency programs aren't considered valid in the US is quality control, from both competency and medico-legal standpoints. If you were CEO of a private practice or hospital in New York City, who would you hire? A grad straight out of a US residency or one out of Swedish residency? The safer bet is the one straight out of US residency for numerous reasons: you can more easily trust and call his references, he has already likely taken the US medical licensing exams, you don't have to give him an English comprehension test, familiar with the mess that is US medical system, etc...
Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by mahyarm on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:22PM (#8689198)
As a CEO of a hospital that wants to make money I would hire the Swedish grad for less and give him a 4 month US legal medical mess class for a lot less in cost that wouldn't involve a doctor. Since I'm known as a hospital that accepts non-us residency people, I can save a lot of money until the market resolves this inefficiency.

Also there are the other 5 anglo countries, which will have no problems with english. Many of these UK, german, etc grads could also be people from the US originally, so there wont be english competency problems there. Many europeans also have excellent english on average, like germans and scandianvians. It would be miles ahead of the average non-west euro immigrant software engineer that is very common in the USA.

QC and skills wise, I don't have much worries from these top tier countries medical practices. Do you freak out if you have to go to a hospital in Sweden because the doctors may be bad!?

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by pc86 on Monday December 01, 2014 @05:10PM (#8684251)
I've heard of residents being paid as little as $25-30k/yr.

The issue is largely that you have an attending physician making a great deal of money (compared to the median US, not necessarily for a doctor) who spends the majority of his or her time teaching, watching, and fixing what the resident does.

You can easily have a hospital/government (not sure what the funding split is) spending $500k/yr for $100k/yr in productivity.

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by maxerickson on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:59PM (#8682918)
Is there some reason that hospitals can't fund the programs themselves? Or do they just choose not to?

More usefully, what could be done to get hospitals to fund the programs? Some hospital systems have billions of net income, they can clearly afford to fund at least a few residencies.

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by sytelus on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @06:43AM (#8686652)
Couldn't it be same incentive why we like interns in tech? In tech, we love internships and most top companies go out of their way to have attractive internship programmes. This allows you to (1) filter future hires much better than hour long interview (2) lot of less complicated stuff can be offloaded to them (3) well, yeah, cheap labor (4) much better cultural training (5) young energetic employees with passion to improve things.
Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by crpatino on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @03:44PM (#8689757)
If consumers of IT products were given the right to potentially sue for every bug that resulted in adverse situations arising for them, the whole industry would collapse in less than a year.

Now, put yourself in the shoes of a company/NGO that arose to fill in the abandoned niche afterwards. Would you be willing to take in a junior employee and let it do unsupervised work? Would the affordability, cultural fitness or "passion" of said junior employee make a big factor in your decision?

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by sytelus on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @09:03PM (#8691448)
We obviously don't give wheels to interns and all go on vacation. Initially interns gets work that is fairly low risk to your business. You observe their quality and evolution and gradually give them work that has higher stacks. Same for residents, I would think they would get work that is at Nurse+ level initially, then may be they start as helping hand in operating rooms and so on. As you see they are reliable and consistent, you increase your risk tolerance. Although tech industry don't get as many law suits I think they face much higher financial consequences for screwing up. Imagine Facebook intern bringing down a service because of an error. That would be equivalent of many lawsuits in terms of loss of revenue.
Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by crpatino on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @01:30PM (#8695462)
> Although tech industry don't get as many law suits I think they face much higher financial consequences for screwing up.

Agreed on that, though there is an upper limit on that, you cannot lose more revenue than you make over the time it takes to resolve the incident.

On the other hand, doctors can be assigned punitive charges (is the term correct?) well beyond the "objective" loss of the patient. That kind of stuff can bankrupt health care practitioners... that's why they have insurance AND legal departments.

Maybe it is just the perception of risk, but I think that explains why there's much more caution around it.

Another data point. Medical schools in US accept only people that has successfully completed an undergraduate degree with transferable skills. In many countries, you can enter medical school after highschool (though the degree takes more years of study than your standard 4 year bachelors).

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by fnordfnordfnord on Monday December 01, 2014 @03:12PM (#8683443)
> Some hospital systems have billions of net income, they can clearly afford to fund at least a few residencies.

What incentive, economic or otherwise, exists that would cause them to do that?

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by maxerickson on Monday December 01, 2014 @05:53PM (#8684539)
Yes, that was the question I was asking in the previous sentence.

I wouldn't be surprised if hospitals were able to benefit from cheaper doctors though.

Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by rhizome on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @06:24AM (#8686606)
Public benefit.
Re:From hacker to hospice in seven weeks by droopyEyelids on Monday December 01, 2014 @08:11PM (#8685136)
What are the expenses involved in a med student's residency? From the outside it looks like they do a full doctor's work, but are only paid 40k a year.