I usually don't trust vinyls that don't indicate their recording/producing/pressing method.
But I don't buy vinyl for the sound, I buy it because I like having a wall full of it.
However, aside the tactile arguments, one of the properties of vinyl that many enthusiasts love is the "warmth" distortion that the medium adds - even from a digital master.
I understand that's not the point of playing vinyl (I frankly don't understand what the point is, but then again, I don't understand the point of collecting a room full of shiny discs in plastic cases either), but the audio quality argument sometimes offered by people who like vinyl sounds like the typical justification bias, a bit what you regularly hear from people who buy gold-plated HDMI cables.
This last point might sound weird, but there have been some (informal?) studies that have suggested that to be the case. http://news.slashdot.org/story/09/03/11/153205/young-people-...
Personally I don't like the "sizzle" of MP3s, but I wouldn't say I miss the warmth of vinyl either. I'm someone who have always preferred the clarity of FLAC or CDs. Each to their own though :)
I am puzzled why my previous comment got down voted though. Would whoever negative repped me mind elaborating why they considered my post so heinous it deserved to be modded down?