News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by harperlee on Thursday November 27, 2014 @07:58AM (#8667010)
I don't know a lot about the requirements of these operations; how can the European Union guarantee that each Subgoogle does not agree with the rest to provide services to each other that I can't access to?

I don't see how they can enforce that any company can be playing a level field against another subgoogle competitor...

Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by tomwilde on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:07AM (#8667039)
That's the real problem; they don't know what to do about it, but they'll rather do anything instead of nothing. Either it's gonna be a lot of hot air or turn out for the worse.

What's funny is that Google already operates as separate legal entities in different European countries (though some countries share one HQ and hence legal identity).

How they plan to further "break it up" I can't imagine.

Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by soneil on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:32AM (#8667159)
I don't think the aim is geographic boundaries, but functional boundaries. eg, Google Advertising is the only ad network allowed on Google Search.

To use a loose analogy with the Microsoft trials; msft having a monopoly on the desktop wasn't the problem. They earned it. Using that monopoly to create a second monopoly in the browser space, was the issue. Hence the unbundling.

In this case, Google having a monopoly in search isn't the problem - again, they've earned it fairly. But using that monopoly to prop up additional monopolies in, eg, advertising, is problematic.

I don't think they'll actually try to split Google up. It's so-far sabre rattling, and this decision just ensures they actually have a sabre to rattle.

But if, eg, third-party advertisers were allowed to compete with Google on Google's own properties? That'd be interesting.

Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by rtpg on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:18AM (#8667099)
It says it right there: break the search engine component from the rest of the company. This would mean that Gmail and Yahoo Mail would be on the same playing field if someone searches for "free webmail client".

I can't even begin to imagine the engineering nightmare that would be though, especially now that accounts are unified.

Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by arethuza on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:18AM (#8667098)
I don't think HQ location has much to do with legal entities - don't you need a local legal entity in a country if you actually have any "operations" there (offices, staff etc.) as you need to comply with local statutory reporting etc.
Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by netheril96 on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:24AM (#8667121)
If Google is broken into parts, then each parts will be owned and operated by different people, and different people will have different interests. In addition, people generally don't willingly cede their power for the common good. That is why they will probably not cooperate.

Of course, your imagined scenario could totally happen. But I think the opposite is more likely.

Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by justin66 on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:11AM (#8667064)
That's not what it's really about. It's going to end up being about the fine, which the article suggests could amount to five billion dollars. That buys a lot of limousine tires and office chairs.
Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by kjjw on Thursday November 27, 2014 @08:27AM (#8667136)
What unsubstantiated, loaded dross. Sorry but what point is there in saying what you have? How does progress any discussion at all?
Re:Google should be broken up, say European MPs by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday November 27, 2014 @07:58AM (#8667014)
That would be an oligopoly and illegal. They could no more do that than oil companies could (legally) conspire to fix prices.