Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by pjmlp on Thursday November 27, 2014 @10:20AM
(#8667550)
Yes we have. Xerox PARC systems were mainly developed in Mesa after some bootstrap work in BCPL.
ETHZ OS were done in Modula-2, Oberon, Active Oberon.
Olivetti and DEC were using Modula-3.
Several OS were being done in Algol and PL/I dialects back when UNIX was being born.
C's ubiquity is a consequence of UNIX adoption by some successful startups in the workstation market.
If one of the other systems had enjoyed a similar adoption another safer systems programming language would have taken C's adoption.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by illumen on Thursday November 27, 2014 @12:04PM
(#8668041)
If Minix had used something else, then Linus probably/might have used that.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by alkonaut on Thursday November 27, 2014 @10:58AM
(#8667703)
The thing is; Rust could have been implemented long ago. It was triggered by Mozillas need for a parallell browser engine that is safe and doesn't crash all the time. One would have thought the same need would have existed for other code such as kernels and drivers for many years.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by ajkjk on Thursday November 27, 2014 @03:22PM
(#8668630)
This is my opinion as well. I know C is the only option right now. I'm amazed that we still find ourselves in that situation in 2014.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by alkonaut on Friday November 28, 2014 @02:57AM
(#8670050)
Also: C is the only option for parts of an OS. Writing it all in C because 10 or 25% needs it is a strange choice.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by digi_owl on Thursday November 27, 2014 @07:23AM
(#8666922)
Rust looks sexy. And i think Mozilla is using it to implement an alternative render/JS engine or something.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by adrianN on Thursday November 27, 2014 @06:45AM
(#8666829)
Ada is a modern language that allows for very low level code and is about as fast as C.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by digi_owl on Thursday November 27, 2014 @07:19AM
(#8666912)
Thats what the US military use on mission critical systems, right? Seem to recall reading that it is a pain to work with.
Re:Escaping the Safari sandbox with a kernel GPU bug
by pjmlp on Thursday November 27, 2014 @10:23AM
(#8667565)
Ada is used in environments were human lifes are at risk life like life support systems, traffic control and so on.
From FOSDEM talks its use has been increasing thanks to C lack of safety, even with MISRA C.
Not for kernel development we don't.
The only modern, memory-safe language that gets close(-ish) to the performance of C for kernel development is Rust and it's a long way from being stable enough for mainstream kernel development.
And even a safe language like Rust won't prevent escalation problems like this if you're placing too much trust in incoming data. That's a design problem that has nothing to do with languages or memory safety.