the nvidia box is definitely more solid than the radeon; the nvidia one does every 3d game I've thrown at it with no noticable issues. However, it's blacklisted by chrome for webgl, and when I tried forcing it, there were definite stability issues.
The radeon box, however, has noticable z-ordering artifacts and some minor flickering on games. Chrome is by far the worst application for it though, web gl or no web gl.
I assume you've verified against other 3D apps on those machines that the graphics stack itself is standards-compliant.