Despite all of this, though, it is a good idea and a good start. I hope it works out.
Agreed, I was going back and forth between making sure the article text didn't get overwhelmed by the screenshots and vice versa.
You also have some errors in your html ( http://vldtr.com/?key=webdesignerd.com ). Especially the double use of id="header" could lead to some unexpected behaviour at some point. And don't forget to encode & as &
I just dislike how images look to the left of the text on Digg, Reddit, etc. so I wanted to try and break out of that a bit. But if it's unreadable it's unreadable.
Anyways, I highly recommend some books on cognitive ergonomics - it's a bit odd that we have a bunch of UX guys running around who don't even know what the term means.
It's generally understood that, for western countries anyways, people read content from top to bottom, left to right. When trying to present something in a skimmable, easily parsable way, you must stick with this format.
The somewhat flaky nature of your thumbnailing is also distracting. When presenting a list, the list must be consistent - and right now it is anything but. Behaviour and location of information radically differs between thumbnailed vs. non-thumbnailed entries.
No offense, but the move away from the top-down list seems driven more by an attempt to be different rather than any perceived gain in usability.
Nonetheless, the main page is a pretty gigantic violation of basic cognitive ergonomics tenets, and IMHO trades way too much usability for what I perceive as mere prettiness.
Also, I'm very skeptical of the usefulness of the thumbnails altogether - the thumbnail communicates nothing (usually it's a screengrab of a wall of text) and doesn't tell me anything about what I'm about to visit.
I don't disagree with you. I'm going to try and find the time to add a toggle b/n list view and grid view so the user can save their preference. Then if it seems that most use the list view, I might just make that the default.
> Also, I'm very skeptical of the usefulness of the thumbnails altogether
Thumbnails of designs are a pretty standard convention with "design gallery"-type sites (http://cssremix.com, http://www.unmatchedstyle.com, etc). It's meant to do nothing more than give you a small idea of the site you're about to visit. The only alternative would be listing the site's title or URL and that certainly wouldn't be any more helpful.
Thanks again for the feedback.
Of course its almost surely because I am so used to the HN simplicity and directness. But it is indeed hard to parse for me. Lists are very very friendly. I find myself being able to parse HN very fast, starting from the top left, reading each listed line until it loses my interest, and then proceeding. Very hard to do on your site since much of my effort is ignoring the design aspect and also the fact that I have to scan so wide horizontally does not help.
Much easier for my mind to know that each line is its own concept, and a newline refreshes the concept. With your box model, my mind has to consciously give meaning to the structure and boxes. Same thing for hierarchy. There is an assumed, implied, and very natural order with a list. Not so with your box model.
Perhaps I'm just thinking too much but for usability, your site gets a "too much effort." and I'd much prefer HN.
Of course as you may have guessed, I'm not a design guy. I can appreciate and love good design, but my take is that design should complement the goal in not only an aesthetic but utilitarian manner.
I feel there is just too much benefit in using the HN list model to go with anything else.