It is ability to gain a community rather than design that matters for this type of web-service.
It's a handful of PHP scripts with little to actually "do" - at least at the intro level - training is merely clicking on some JavaScript buttons.
What difference for the player does it make what technology was used for scripting and buttons? An average guy from these 40k users might not even know such words as JavaScript/PHP/Flash.
Yeah, I get that, but the front page is just a signup form. If I set up a page like that, it wouldn't magically get signups. There must be some marketing involved someplace.
Because if it were just handful of PHP scripts, hey, I can code them in a weekend :)
and then the leaderboard as you point out would be a strong motivator as well.
(Update: I signed up and played for several minutes so far. It's a handful of PHP scripts with little to actually "do" - at least at the intro level - training is merely clicking on some JavaScript buttons. This guy must be a Derren Brown-like master of persuasion if he really has 40k regular players - wow, hats off to him.)