News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by cryoshon on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @01:21PM (#8631639)
This translation of the Manual isn't very good, in my opinion. I've only heard of it as being called the handbook of Epictetus and not the manual, also. The word handbook has a lot different connotations than Manual, so I have to say I really don't agree with the decision to translate it that way. I'll refer to it as the Manual for the sake of consistency with the title, though.

My favored translation of the first line is: Some things are up to us, and some things are not up to us.

The Manual is a great introduction (and perhaps largest contribution) of the Stoic school of ancient philosophy. It's also by by far the most practical of any philosophical document that I've ever read, though it's a bit light on pragmatic responses and, perhaps, realism.

After reading the Manual, it's hard not to live by its suggestions. In particular, my favorite suggestion is to relish good moments by pausing and remarking to yourself explicitly what makes the moment good. I believe the example Epictetus picks to illustrate this concept is a child, but perhaps it's a bowl or woman in actuality; when Epictetus notices the positive emotions that looking at his child/bowl/woman gives him, he stops and professes something along the lines of, "my child/bowl/woman is wonderful, and I am happy to have experienced my time with him/it/her. I love this child/bowl/woman."

It's a good way to appreciate what you have, and to reject negativity when it's not something you can control.

The primary hazard of Stoicism is passivity, of course. A trend of declaring some things as up to you and other things as not up to you can feed onto itself, leading you to write off responsibility when it isn't directly and unmissably yours. Conversely, a control-freak would endlessly fret about the things that are "up to him" when in reality they might be only tangentially or abstractly so.

I definitely recommend everyone read the Manual. At a minimum, it's a new and orderly perspective on how to experience life and deal with the good and bad. There's some conceptual overlap with Buddhism from what I understand.

Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by anigbrowl on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @01:53PM (#8631825)
The word handbook has a lot different connotations than Manual

You really think so? The former is just an anglicization of the latter. Manus is Latin for hand, and you can still hear this in French main Spanish mano etc.

Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by cryoshon on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @02:43PM (#8632158)
"Manual" implies stuffy reference material to be referred to only when there is a malfunction.

"Handbook" implies action, portability, and usefulness.

Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by anigbrowl on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:08PM (#8637441)
These are highly personal associations which I don't share with you at all.
Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by jkmcf on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @05:08PM (#8632976)
Do you have a preferred translation? Do you remember where you read your favored translation?
Re:The Enchiridion, or Manual, of Epictetus by cryoshon on Thursday November 20, 2014 @11:04AM (#8636350)
Nicholas White's translation is my favored one. It's quite modern and very digestible.