Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet
by imanaccount247 on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:48PM
(#8626902)
But by the same measures you can claim bicycle helmets are important, they would be just as important for walkers as cyclists. Or people in cars.
> But by the same measures you can claim bicycle helmets are important, they would be just as important for walkers as cyclists.
Because, of course, walkers are elevated and moving at 20 to 30 km/h on an inherintly unstable platform.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet
by imanaccount247 on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @08:13PM
(#8627581)
It doesn't matter what they are doing, it matters if the basis for claiming helmets are useful for cycling apply to walking. And they do. The testing bicycle helmets undergo is in fact approximating the speed of a walking person falling over on their head. Research has failed to support the idea that helmets offer a net benefit for cycling. I suspect the same would hold true of walking if people took the insanity to the next step and push helmets on walkers.
I looked into car helmets a few years ago [1] and my takeaway was that in older cars helmets would have helped, but cars made in the last 20+ years have enough interior padding and airbags that helmets wouldn't add much if anything.
If you convince me otherwise I'll start wearing a helmet in the car and advocating other people do so too.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet
by theossuary on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:54PM
(#8626937)
Just because people don't wear them in those instances doesn't mean they shouldn't. Also, it's less likely to fall over walking than to fall over riding a bike, one is inherently less stable than the other. Get pushed walking and stumble back a bit, get pushed riding a bike and you'll most likely fall over.
I imagine you catch your self more reliably when walking, too, and avoid head injuries.
Yes, but if you throw in the fact that walkers have far fewer crashes to the pavement than walkers then it is not the same. And cars have seatbelts...
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet
by imanaccount247 on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @07:57PM
(#8627530)
Walkers hit their heads all the time. People die from it. And seat belts do not prevent brain injuries.
The same is not true of motorcycle helmets. The forces involved in motorcycle accidents are a lot higher, so fewer accidents are survivable even with a helmet. Motorcycle helmets also make you feel fucking invincible, so I can definitely see why people would take more risks.