News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by Luc on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:03PM (#8626667)
> If you ride a bicycle, please wear a helmet.

Or you know, don't, because you've got perfectly safe bicycle infrastructure and you're never going faster than 20 km/h anyway.

What works for you is not a universal law.

You know how this bicycle helmet issue always turns into a shouting match on the internet? I think it's to a large extent because people don't have the empathy to see themselves in the situation of a bicyclist on the other side of the world, in a different automotive culture, with different laws and history.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by scott_s on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:05PM (#8626678)
Falling off your bike at 20 km/h and hitting your head is still enough for a decent head injury.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by Luc on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:15PM (#8626729)
Pfft, you don't need to be going that fast. My wife was pushed off her bike at perhaps 5 km/h and fractured her shoulder. Took nearly a year of healing and revalidation.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by carlob on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:27PM (#8626800)
That would be an argument for wearing protection when walking as well, you know?
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:31PM (#8626823)
Kind of ... no, not really. Walking at 2mph with both feet on the ground, very different from balanced on a frame of pipework rolling at 5mph. Much more likely to 'land on your feet' when walking.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by carlob on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:43PM (#8626871)
Parent poster wrote 5 km/h which is really the speed of most walkers not 5 mph. I'm sure that if you get hit by a car that's going fast enough it won't really matter if you have a bike, a skateboard, or just the soles of your shoes…
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:29PM (#8627091)
Yeah but you don't have to hit a car to take a dive on your bike. Just stopping at a light you can go over.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by gburt on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:06PM (#8626682)
I take it you missed his part about breaking his chain.

That said: http://www.vehicularcyclist.com/hfaq.html and a variety of research suggesting that helmet laws reduce ridership which causes far more cost (in heart disease and inactivity ailments) than the lack of helmets.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:19PM (#8626750)
Its the old observers paradox. "I haven't had a bike accident, so bike helmets aren't necessary". Nothing works but resorting to the statistics. What statistics have you to offer?
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by antientropic on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:52PM (#8626930)
Here in the Netherlands, nearly nobody wears a helmet. If the horror stories in this thread are to be believed, half the population of the country should be clinically brain dead at this point. They're not, so perhaps not wearing a helmet is not as dangerous as some people believe.

Regarding statistics: http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1012.html has some useful pointers. Conclusion: "Despite the considerable effort that has been put into research about cycle helmets, there is no real-world evidence that helmets have ever resulted in the net saving of even a single life. However, if helmets were actually effective, then many more pedestrian and motor vehicle occupant lives could be expected to be saved if these groups wore helmets."

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by jac_no_k on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @11:15PM (#8628225)
So I've seen the cycle commuters in the Netherlands. It's at a nice relaxed pace where it's unlikely a cyclist will be surprised or an equipment failure is going to be catastrophic. The use case is going to dictate what equipment is going to be needed.

When I had an internally geared hub, I had it fail on a steep uphill where I was standing to get enough torque down, where it essentially went into neutral, similar to a chain snapping. This almost threw me off the bicycle. Netherlands, relatively flat.

I've since switched to a road bicycle and traveling at higher speeds. Once a taxi blindly crossed in front of me, sending me hurtling over the taxi. I landed on my head, lost consciousness briefly. Helmet was deformed. Without it, the outcome would have been much more catastrophic.

Another incident, this time going slowly down a steep mountain road, while tightening my line to avoid an oncoming car, the front wheel slipped on leaves sending me down to ground. Landed mostly on my side but helmet hit the ground really hard, enough to stun me. The inner support of the helmet broke mostly free of the outer shell but stayed in place because of the chin strap. This too could have ended badly with no cell phone reception for about 15km and a civilization 30km away.

Anyways... it depends on use case. Over here in Tokyo, the utility bicycles and cyclists are just like the Netherlands. Sedate pace, low number of incidents. The roadies and faster cycle commuters have necessary equipment including helmets, safety glasses, gloves, blinkers, and lamps.

I recognize I have a higher risk profile and take on extra precautions.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:33PM (#8627113)
Read the thread! Everybody seems to know somebody/have experienced an accident where the helmet saved their skull. That "conclusion" can't be serious. Real-world evidence is all around us. I'm calling bull on that site.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by nathanb on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:15PM (#8626727)
Can you explain what you mean by "perfectly safe bicycle infrastructure" and how this removes the need for a helmet?
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by jepper on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:23PM (#8626778)
In the Netherlands we have dedicated cycling lanes along larger roads and car drivers that are comfortable with cyclists. Almost everbody cycles, nobody wears helmets. And we haven't got a raised head injury mortality or paralysis rate because of bike injuries. I've never had an injury and probably traveled more kilometers by bike than any other means of transportation.

I do wear a helmet while road biking but that's a whole different topic.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:27PM (#8626799)
Look here, and search for "Netherlands" for the full horror storey of 'safe' bicycle infrastructure:

http://www.bhsi.org/stats.htm

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:10PM (#8627014)
I don't see a horror story. Could you explain it?

In the Netherlands, 1/4 of all trips, and 8% of all distances traveled, are by bicycle, so the numbers reported there are hard to compare to other countries.

What level of fatalities and head injuries would count as "not a horror story" to you? What level of fatalities by running or jogging would count as "not a horror story" to you?

(BTW, the statistics only list "head/brain injury". I presumed that a scratch on the chin would count as a head injury. Also, the text under "And more from the same paper" does not exist in the referenced paper. The text says the 'estimates are partly based on research carried out in countries like the United States and Australia', so don't really reflect the infrastructure.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:30PM (#8627101)
The first paragraph in the Netherlands section:

"67,000 casualties of cycling crashes are treated at a first-aid department (Source: Injury Information System LIS), 8,000 cyclists are admitted to hospital (Source: National Medical Registration LMR), and 190 people die as a consequence of a cycling crash (Source Statistics Netherlands – Unnatural deaths). Of the seriously injured bicycle casualties2 admitted to hospital, a third were diagnosed with head or brain injuries (32%). "

We can assume 'seriously injured' does not include scratched chins.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @07:07PM (#8627275)
I read those numbers. My point is that I don't know how to interpret those numbers.

The Netherlands has a cheaper health care than the US. Do people go to the first-aid department for minor problems more often than they do in the US?

For example, in college I cut my figure once while cutting a loaf of bread with a hard crust. I was on the campus medical plan. I walked to the campus medical center and got a single stitch. Had I had to drive some place, and pay $100 in co-pay, then I would have waited longer and perhaps not gotten it.

The text says "Of the cyclists with serious injury who are admitted to hospital following a crash with motorized traffic, almost half (47%) are diagnosed with head/brain injury". It doesn't say that they only have a head/brain injury. Could be a broken collarbone and facial injury? The relevant Table 1 in the paper says "Annual number of cyclists admitted to hospital with head/brain injuries as main or second diagnosis", emphasis mine.

So no, we cannot, based on the presented data, assume that the head/brain injury is the serious injury.

In the US in 2012, 4,743 pedestrians and 726 bicyclists were killed in crashes with motor vehicles. http://www.pedbikeinfo.org/data/factsheet_crash.cfm . Do those raw numbers mean that bikes are safer than walking, in case of a car crash?

Certainly not. It needs to be scaled by amount of time that people are on a bike, vs. walking. More people walk in the US than cycle. "There are 127 million walking trips and nine million bike trips in the U.S. every day (2009 NHTS)." http://www.pedbikeinfo.org/data/factsheet_general.cfm .

While in the Netherlands, some 25% of trips are by bike, and 20% by foot, and 8% of all distances are covered by bike. See http://books.google.com/books?id=apGsBAAAQBAJ&pg=PA352&lpg=P... .

Tell me how to combine all that data to get a horror story. Because it's proved to be too complicated for me to figure it out based on what I can see.

My own experience in the Netherlands is that biking there is a joy. It feels very safe compared to biking in the US.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @07:14PM (#8627315)
You are kidding, right? What non-serious brain injury do you suppose they are diagnosing?
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @09:23PM (#8627861)
I have no clue. The information stated is "Head injury is the general category and generally implies brain injury, but sometimes there is head injury without brain injury."

I see nothing about if "generally implies" means 5% or 95%. Do you? I assume it's "more than 50%", so I went to the referenced paper. That says:

> In Table 2 head injury is the most general injury category which may also include injury to the back of the head, face and brain (some studies consider facial injury as a head injury, other studies do not). Brain injury specifically refers to the brain, and facial injury specifically refers to injury to the face (chin, nose mouth, jaws, eyes, forehead, ears). Elvik compared the risk proportions of a specific injury occurring or not occurring

In Table 2, however, you'll see that brain injury appears to be less common than non-brain injuries involving the head.

However, Table 2 is a metadata analysis with insufficient few brain injury studies to "allow correction for publication bias", and not specific to the Netherlands. (A copy of the paper is at http://www.cycle-helmets.com/elvik.pdf .) Therefore it can't be used to conclude anything about the situation in the Netherlands.

You'll also notice that point 3 of the conclusion in Elvik reads "When the analysis is updated by adding four new studies, the protective effects attributed to bicycle helmets are further reduced. According to the new studies, no overall effect of bicycle helmets could be found when injuries to head, face or neck are considered as a whole."

So, no, I don't know. I ask how you know when that information isn't available in the papers you cited.

Where is the horror story?

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @06:29PM (#8633411)
The horror story comes in when folks go to the hospital only when they are seriously injured, the diagnosis IS brain injury, those 190 dead people could have been saved, and we don't struggle to interpret all the data as naively as we possibly can.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @07:36PM (#8633724)
If you say that even 1 dead person is a horror story, then I'll agree with you, and stop this discussion.

Otherwise, if some lesser number is not a horror story, then please explain why 190 dead people is a horror story. Roughly what level would not be a horror story, but 'merely' tragic?

Is that level based also on the number of trips, or amount of distance traveled bike? Or is it simply the absolute number of deaths? How does that compare to the number of people who die by walking, running, swimming, or kayaking?

We cannot eliminate all risk. What level is acceptable? You seem to suggest that no risk is acceptable. The vast majority of the world seems to disagree with you.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by jabbrwcky on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @03:37AM (#8656876)
A concussion perhaps? Normally not too serious, sometimes just monitored overnight in hospital or at home.
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:31PM (#8626824)
"Perfectly safe" is of course impossible. It should be read as "as safe as walking" or, more realistically, "as safe as running." (Wearing a helmet while running, or while driving, may also be safer than not.)

For a safe infrastructure, see how Amsterdam and Copenhagen have bike lines which are independent of traffic and of pedestrians, including it own bridges and overpasses. See also how routes are arranged so that cycle and pedestrian routes are more direct than car routes, how bikes have right-of-way over cars, and how limited speed limits and narrow roads keep cars from going fast in roads which are shared with cycles.

Also, it wasn't only "perfectly safe bicycle infrastructure" but also "and you're never going faster than 20 km/h". That's a 3 minute km or 5 minute mile, which is slower than many people can sprint, and slower than the fastest marathon paces. It's hard to understand why cyclists, on their own paths, need a helmet when runners who might pass them do not.

Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @05:38PM (#8626847)
I think its because runners have their feet under them, and can respond in some emergencies. Falling off a bike almost always ends up head-first, with arms outstretched to brace yourself (broken collar-bone from the impact) or not (broken helmet/head).
Re:Tell HN: Wear a Helmet by dalke on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:46PM (#8627174)
Cyclists can also respond in some emergencies, including some that aren't available to joggers. For example, I found that two wheels + two feet made it possible to travel on an icy road where two feet alone felt very dangerous. Cyclists also very rarely get a sprained ankle.

I don't find where "falling off a bike almost always ends up head-first." My own injuries seem more of the slip on an icy or wet patch and fall on my side variety.

Looking around, according to http://books.google.com/books?id=cxn2dKfCg1AC&lpg=PA138&ots=... "gravel rash" on the hips, knees, butt, and elbows is the most common injury.

Bruising, cuts, and breaks (collarbone, ribs, and wrists, in that order) are relatively less common. I don't get a sense that head-first events top the list.