There aren't a whole lot of privacy concerns with CA's as long as you use OCSP stapling, so users browsers aren't hitting up the CA each time they visit a website (Chrome never does this but other browsers can do).
Re: CA compromise. One reason running a CA costs money is that the root store policies imposed by the CA/Browser Forum require (I think!) the usage of a hardware security module which holds the signing keys. This means a compromised CA could issue a bunch of certs for as long as the compromise is active, but in theory it should be hard or impossible to steal the key. Once the hackers are booted out of the CA's network, it goes back to being secure. Of course quite some damage can be done during this time, and that's what things like Certificate Transparency are meant to mediate - they let everyone see what CAs are doing.
That's something imposed by the audit criteria (WebTrust/ETSI). What you detailed is also why roots are left disconnected from the internet - if you compromise an intermediary, that can be blacklisted as opposed to the entire root.
These are the things you pay for when you buy a certificate from a CA. In fact, I would be 100% opposed to obtaining my website's cert from a CA if it were free-of-charge, because I know good physical security is expensive. However, I already trust the EFF and the Umich researchers (and their assurances of physical security), so I'm absolutely happy with obtaining a free certificate from them.
While probably not officially scriptable, free certificates have been available since a long time ago: https://www.startssl.com/?app=1
Also, no free wildcard certs. Which I really want.
> What happens if a CA is compromised?
Looking at past compromises, if they have been very irresponsible they are delisted from the browsers' list of trusted roots (see diginotar). If they have not been extremely irresponsible, then they seem to be able to continue to function (see Comodo).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DigiNotar#Refusal_to_publish_r... https://blogs.comodo.com/uncategorized/the-recent-ra-comprom...
NB: This is a bit unfair, because the existing for-money CAs haven't always stopped someone from registering microsoft.com.
1. Over the wire encryption (which this handles)
2. As a bad, but the best we've got site identification system for stopping phishing mechanism.
Currently, for even the cheapest certs (domain+email validated) - the CAs will reject SSL cert requests for anything that might be a phishing target. Detecting "wellsfargo.com" is pretty easy, where it gets tricky is things like "wellsforgo.com", "wellsfàrgo.com" etc. Which if I'm looking at this right will just sail through with LetsEncrypt.
I suspect we're going to actually end up with two tiers of SSL certs as the browser makers have started to really de-emphasize domain validated certs [1] like this vs the Extended Validation (really expensive) certs, to the point where in most cases now having a domain cert does not know green (and maybe doesn't even show a lock) at all.
As a side note, Google had announced that they were going to start using SSL as a ranking signal [2] (sites with SSL would get a slight bump in rankings), from this perspective the "high" cost of a cert was actually a feature as it made life much more expensive on blackhat SEOs who routinely are setting up hundreds of sites.
1 - Screenshots: https://www.expeditedssl.com/pages/visual-security-browser-s...
2 - http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2014/08/https-as-...
There have been previous attempts, e.g. http://www.cacert.org/
AFAIK they failed in the politics front (getting accepted in mainstream browsers). Sounds like EFF might have better leverage.
There are very few companies out there that are okay with serving 1/5th of their potential customers an error page, and for good reason.
A quick glance over EU countries reveals that more than 91% of potential users support SNI.
It might depend on your line of business but I think for some entities this might be a viable option
https://www.globalsign.com/certificate-authority-root-signin...
There are a few other vendors that I've seen offer similar services.
An interesting thing happened at a meet-up at Square last year. Someone from google's security team came out and demonstrated what google does to notify a user that a page has been compromised or is a known malicious attack site.
During the presentation she was chatting about how people don't really pay attention to the certificate problems a site has, and how they were trying to change that through alerts/notifications.
After which someone asked that if google cared so much about security why didn't they just become a CA and sign certs for everyone. She didn't answer the question, so I'm not sure if that means they don't want to, or they are planning to.
What privacy concerns should we have if someone like goog were to sign the certs? What happens if a CA is compromised?