Re:Xv6 – A Simple Unix-Like Teaching Operating System
by maaku on Monday November 17, 2014 @07:49PM
(#8621814)
Why not.. MINIX?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Xv6 – A Simple Unix-Like Teaching Operating System
by japr59 on Monday November 17, 2014 @09:07PM
(#8622021)
It wouldn't be a bad idea to use both. It could be nice to study a monolithic kernel-based OS (xv6) and a microkernel-based OS (MINIX).
In 6.828, we read xv6, and we implemented parts of JOS, which is exokernel-based. Since exokernels are kind of like microkernels on steroids, I suppose it makes sense that we didn't focus on normal microkernels too much.
Re:Xv6 – A Simple Unix-Like Teaching Operating System
by dalke on Monday November 17, 2014 @08:28PM
(#8621926)
Quoting from the Xv6 web page, "Adding multiprocessor support requires handling concurrency head on with locks and threads (instead of using special-case solutions for uniprocessors such as enabling/disabling interrupts) and helps relevance."
MINIX didn't have multiprocessor support until MINIX 3. Unlike MINIX 2, MINIX 3 is not designed as a teaching OS.