News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by wodenokoto on Monday November 17, 2014 @04:55AM (#8617531)
The artist's contract with labels is not the consumers responsibility.

If you compare the price of spotify with average consumer behavior, you see that money spent on spotify is in every sense more than reasonable. Many album deals in the past have had pennies on the album reach the artist, so I fail to understand your argument that spotify is cheating artist. But that logic Walmart are cheating artist who doesn't have a fair record deal.

If artist don't receive money from consumer spending it is the label that is cheating the artist, not the distributor.

Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by forrestthewoods on Monday November 17, 2014 @10:24AM (#8618560)
I'm not talking about that. Labels don't make shit from Spotify either. More specifically, rights holders don't make shit from Spotify. I don't care if that holder is an individual, a band, or a big ass record label.
Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by bryanlarsen on Monday November 17, 2014 @02:04PM (#8619817)
70% of spotify revenue is paid to rights holders.
Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by forrestthewoods on Monday November 17, 2014 @02:44PM (#8620047)
So? Spotify pays $5,210 per million streams [1]. It would take an individual artist about 8 million streams to make a mere $40,000. A band of 5 artists would require 40 million streams for each person in the band to make a $40,000 salary.

That's jack shit. It's not enough to be a meaningful revenue stream for any artist at any level. It's not enough to help, support, or incubate indies. It's not enough be a drop in the bucket for a mega star.

[1] http://thetrichordist.com/2014/11/12/the-streaming-price-bib...

Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by bryanlarsen on Monday November 17, 2014 @04:14PM (#8620620)
Those numbers seem fairly comparable to CD's to me.

Let's run some numbers. After subtracting manufacturing, shipping & retailer cuts, a label makes about $3-5 from a record, and sends about $1 of that to the artist. So for the sake of argument, let's say you need to sell a thousand CDs to make the same revenue as a million Spotify streams. Given ~10 tracks per album, that means that the crossover point is 100 album plays. IOW, if I play an album on Spotify more than 100 times, I give the recording company more money than I would if I bought the CD.

That seems like totally fair pricing. I have no idea how many times the average CD is listened to but I bet it's above 100. The median would be below 100, but the mean above. The albums that are listened to 10's of thousands of times would really skew the average.

Re:Is Spotify the music industry’s friend or its foe? by wodenokoto on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @05:43AM (#8629259)
And yet Taylor swift received 500.000 USD for the last single month she was on Spotify.

Looking at price per stream does not make sense. Looking at average consumption does. Spotify is way above average album consumption per person and it (or similar services) has the potential to cover a very large part of the population.