News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by WestCoastJustin on Sunday November 16, 2014 @06:02PM (#8615878)
Going out on a limb here, as I posted a pretty lengthy comment on Nation State attacks in the past [1], but does this Google/NSA relationship qualify as terrifying? Google finds out it has been targeted by a Nation State, who is actively siphoning off user data and company crown jewels, so they enter into an agreement with the NSA to share information about the attack, and develop technology and methods to prevent future attacks. I would argue that Google must share knowledge of Nation State APTs with the US Government, and other Silicon Valley firms, once they found out the scope included Symantec, Yahoo, and Adobe, Northrop Grumman, etc. NSA/Google/Facebook/Apple/Microsoft/Amazon should be trying to advance countermeasures and leveling up the industry as a whole, because they arguably have some of the most exposed attack surfaces, host most of our data, and have the financial resources and in house expertise to deal with it best. I would be terrified if Google did not have a relationship where it shared intrusions of this scope with the US Government.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8316430

Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by azakai on Sunday November 16, 2014 @06:58PM (#8616070)
You've interpreted the data in the most positive way possible. Yes, that is one of many ways in which things could have unfolded.

But as the article says, this is all secret. We don't know what exactly Google and the NSA built together in that first agreement shortly after the Chinese hacking scandal. And we don't know what else has happened since then.

Maybe it's all innocuous stuff, as you said. Maybe it isn't. To just assume it is all good or all bad seems unjustified by the amount of actual facts that are public.

Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 16, 2014 @07:14PM (#8616127)
The problem is, of course, most people will assume "all bad" because of the ongoing narrative.
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by adventured on Monday November 17, 2014 @04:20AM (#8617448)
It's a really bad narrative. Given the extreme, illegal erosion in privacy at the hands of the State, it sure seems a lot safer to bet on "all bad" or "pretty bad" when it comes to these tech giants doing deals with the NSA.
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by etha on Sunday November 16, 2014 @08:53PM (#8616455)
It does happen to be a positive interpretation, but there's no reason to think that's why it was chosen, since it's also the simplest explanation.
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by meowface on Sunday November 16, 2014 @09:36PM (#8616578)
I also think it's the most likely explanation.

It is not advantageous for Google's executives to collaborate in the tracking of US citizens; it adds a lot more work and it makes for absolutely awful PR. I'd also like to think that they possess some moral compass (even if it's a bit slanted) which lets them understand the difference between wide scale "anonymized" tracking for the purpose of advertising and giving all that data to a bunch of humans to scrutinize and judge for the purpose of spying.

Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by whyever on Monday November 17, 2014 @11:33AM (#8618907)
It only makes for awful PR if the public knows about it.

What do you mean by anonymized tracking? Isn't building a profile on every user necessary for targeted advertising?

Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by meowface on Monday November 17, 2014 @08:35PM (#8621945)
>What do you mean by anonymized tracking? Isn't building a profile on every user necessary for targeted advertising?

Yes. Anonymized wasn't the right word, perhaps "behind the curtains"? Google employees aren't actually making, looking at, or (not 100% sure of this last one) "splitting" and filtering the data to learn things about you. The process, beginning to end, is automated. This is in stark contrast to the NSA, where when they get a "hit" they will carefully and personally inspect you, your interests, and your activities.

Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by tesq on Sunday November 16, 2014 @08:36PM (#8616396)
Money is the oil that runs the firms. Kickbacks, favorable contracts, consulting opportunities, (legal) protection and maybe business intelligence from the most well funded vehicle on Earth? It's a cushy deal.
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by profoundly on Sunday November 16, 2014 @06:41PM (#8616014)
Do you have a working relationship with Google?
Re:Google’s NSA alliance: Deals between Silicon Valley and t... by WestCoastJustin on Sunday November 16, 2014 @06:42PM (#8616018)
No.