News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by Animats on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:03AM (#8594588)
We have the Metaverse. It's called Second Life. It works reasonably well. Second Life already supports the Oculus Rift. See "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWE91IB9QMI". They still seem to be struggling with the control side of the user interface, but somebody will think of something. Maybe a Wii controller. (Basic problem of virtual reality: looking around, moving, and shooting work great. Everything else is hard.)

From Mozilla, we have "Now imagine a Minecraft that under the hood was HTML, CSS, and JavaScript". Ugh. There was a previous idea like this. It was called Web3D, and it's VRML 97 in XML syntax. "A spinning logo in 40 characters" was claimed. Anybody remember Web3D? Anybody? Hello? Also, putting on headgear to browse the web seems a bit much. You can build it, but will they come? The web is going in the other direction, towards small mobile devices.

(Mozilla's video won't play in Firefox 33 on Ubuntu Linux. Their Javascript video player crashed with a type error at line 1790 of "vjs.js". And those guys think using Javascript will make things better. The annoying thing about the Mozilla Foundation is that their core product keeps getting worse. Firefox crashes more now than it did three years ago. The number of unfixed bugs increases over time. Mozilla has a huge technical debt; the code base goes back to the Netscape days, and it shows.)

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by moron4hire on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:01PM (#8597784)
And Second Life is owned by a single, proprietary interest. And that's great, but that's not the Web. The beauty of the Web is that nobody owns it all and yet it still all works together. Even one of Linden Lab's former founders is trying to help open VR up on the Web: https://highfidelity.io/

I tend to think the problem with VRML was less to do with markup and more to do with 1997. Did anything 3D look great in 1997? Not really, and even then it still impressed us. But we have the power today to make--while not the most cutting edge graphics--certainly anything better than was available in, say, 2010, and we can make it cross-platform, open, and on the Web.

Doesn't that sound like something we should at least try to do? Just once?

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by serf on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:17PM (#8598237)
> And Second Life is owned by a single, proprietary interest.

Linden Lab's/Phillip Rosedale's stated goal was world economy creation. Second Life is to be thought of as a web protocol that is undergoing standardization, and is stated to become fully open-source when that standard is finalized.

>And that's great, but that's not the Web.

Well, 'There', the predecessor to Second Life which created most of the control scheme concepts and user content creation schemas that were employed in Second Life was actually a technology demonstration between a collaboration of Forterra Systems and the US Army for private training simulation and remote work.

If a system which was co-created by a defense group eventually becoming standardized for public use isn't 'the Web', I don't know what is.

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by rhelmer on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @05:18AM (#8594739)
I filed https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1097572 to track the issue you're seeing with the JS player - I think it's vid.ly not air.mozilla.org that's not working, but it's worth looking into.

Can you send me more info on your crashes? I work on crash collection and reporting. If you put about:crashes in the address bar and hit enter, you can click on some of the crashes there and send the links to me.

Is this the Ubuntu Firefox build or did you download it from Mozilla? (they do their own builds)

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by Animats on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @12:44PM (#8596901)
Sure. There will be a SERVICE CHARGE of $125 for custom debug assistance services.

(Sorry, you can't expect end users to debug your product. That's your job. It's probably because I'm using Flashblock and Ghostery to block ads and tracking, and Mozilla tried something those won't allow. I don't have time to debug every defective web site.)

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by rhelmer on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:54PM (#8598079)
The site in question is not hosted by Mozilla, but embeds video hosted by vid.ly, which air.mozilla.com also uses.

You certainly don't have to go out of your way on my account! If you'd like help with crashes or anything else, let me know or file a bug.

Nobody has been able to reproduce the problem you hit with the video, although I appreciate knowing about it. It's pretty difficult to test arbitrary sites with different sets of addons and other local config, so I certainly appreciate if you don't have time/desire to dig in further.

Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by anonbanker on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:39PM (#8598379)
I'll pony up the $125 right now. Give me a PayPal or Bitcoin address to send it to. I want to see your about:crashes
Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by zyx321 on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @08:07AM (#8595247)
No one wants to go out and compare their project to Second Life though, since SL is (to put it mildly) a case study in what people will do given the ability to create anything they want.
Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by Animats on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @12:45PM (#8596911)
That's the Metaverse. That's what it does.
Re:Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse? by roca on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @06:38AM (#8594955)
This is a completely different approach to X3D/VRML. Everyone involved is acutely aware that a declarative approach won't work.

Every project's unfixed bug count increases over time, unless the project is dead. Likewise, technical debt is a problem that every large successful project has.